CTA Case No. 2167 (Decision)

Hf. l'f\',TC OF fu.: I'HI LfPP.'.; t:l COL RT OF' T"L' APPEALd QUEZON CITY -- . ~ . �� ,., 7 -... - ...... � '1 r l n of f ~1 �l ;� �� f h y ng �n � i :r. ... t 1

t ( � 21 7 h . rhis court on J ~,nl. ax "'.7.. 1~1 " r~nd on he G~ � ) r i s ufi c . i.s �on ith � ~- .. dC.!. ndur. . ;; . ,...,,, . {c: . ). 2 4 ,. ,\ til sc..le i.' lit�(~ i$ :t not �� . �. t i 1 on ... �~ .... ., ' l ~ ~) l.~.ty tl iJ. p ., 'I' of -t in"' t.m �.tt ., th t ailu.r } "il(i;.""' 9.co..:n Sl \ H rti. f c t C"'.t'�, 0 ~:lS f ...,-: 11't <: rn: i o -.a l i.)~.t ,. s c!oo to ;. c .-- .. o.. ,. .Jy :..n � cha s n; . ' � t . n . ,,,an1. . �st . .;rhich v t. .. r 2

(l i � h :�~n �s in a I1 por .. 0 IJUl" .ei �1 n in th \llt .tt ..:t:t n .nh 'J ,,_ ~~o . :o. "'1 ,f I' t � t ,.ust )~� *1". t � �d , ... .,. 1 1, . l !,'! la � fol (1 t o \!:r~~~t au t y.i.�n.*a' iJ) :nc . vs . o. 2 .;7'/i. , ...~<h a .Lnc. � I' lh..; . ({.. 1. nc . v11 � .1 , , 3

- 4) ! ' ., � !'', \f' . t c his. ' o� r in . �~ l'J 7J. .t o1 t i s t '� 3 bn . iv n pr vail in., l :) � n .. n�l , in .ust 4

- .. . v l ( r ; o� 1 � t n � i . . .. 1, ' h t n l. l . .. -:;7 � ~~~~? L-1 ~ 5