CTA Case No. 1429 (Decision)

___.... --� !!:l"UBLIC OJ' THE PHILIP.PlNhtl COURT OF TAX APPEA.LI QUEZON CITY T ., I .. ., .:. ,.. l. '.;. .) � .. .' 280

.. - .' .: . � ., .. ... � � t. t � . � . 1- 281

I �- �� ' ,, ,.. ... t .' .' y 282 t

.' . :" - �t 283

r � �� 284

... � . ' ... \ � 285

/. .I 'I !"'".~. 1.42�) � 286 /

~ .Q� '� �� lt (1 1 � ;: 287

-a, Cl IfJJ ..c ~T;~ CA:-� . �~ '1{ � l { � t.tt, one;. a t ... t. ��� - p;p ., ol) �� Eve. �J -~.."""""- �f � pall . (t. � � Jo!.nt V�1 twn�� t .t! t v lirJ to l.epo.&n a 4 O.l�ereuJ.t , h~ Ill� eu e ther ot. � e~1 "a l #' . � ln a J 1nt '�~Jil.li!J';"u�~ �-v- t 1; i..; not .t . � ~ - et>r. -t.l.:ttft � c J .~~t,.edv~~-~ ......t the p. t.l. . tllttst eo..,. .L"'!~ t.rt~ir .tlrvp~,rt.i"1 lliO'fktl,J t Sfi:P�A:!th or k1 ~~9~ r. e 'lltt ct>;~w1 n an:det'takin~ .fll (30 _m. �J\AJrio ~~ tZ � tU'l . wb� Qb, .n~ par y 1 t;o . t&tl.l.ttl1 h a a 0 01: "" 111 ans , l � 9 zict� . -296; l 02 r~ ,., ~ . 7!J3 ;. lto .,, J.; .- lu59 . )� 4 u t: t a ...nt 1! 1 1 : tJ~o p~ll'&'ti r~ � or .nk:,J.e' . i t ." 'd 288

.,. 0 .~.t { "" t ., 0 �� 289

l .., ~. c tin; 290

-- 291 I.

-- � , l '� 3 .. T~~a~urer of Associate~. The said two documents ,, 292

.;. t' . . ... .,. ... "' ,,, )\ 1,�_. ,, J� .. Q ' "" f.u r. - ( i ti- 1 �~ 293 / \ I

- .� � � ... ,..,� ' � \. for r

,_ It .. t'":., .... tio,rm d. 0"' &' u) �' (; 1 ~(!~ 1~ . ..tr4~ 'i ~ '. 1;. .., . I .- ~"'; ~�-� c -M "'l"C' ( .1~. "' (~,;) ~"'t ( .... � ' ..., .�,_{_ .. 295

) ... .4 � '>!:.') 17 1 .. r:O! // ,_ ro .. �t~ t '-hi. t 296

t'l . c rv:d i � �,.. i - I 297

- � � ' .. ' ' 298

i t�. t '' . �� � :~ :'o in �� . �~ '

h J'l. .t tr t C< of o.l it on r r .U1 . v 1~ r t ' tic � :~cj g .,. � t . u� .\ . ,� .. .,; fl � 300 �

J.2:t . t. .LU ' .I . �1 ., � .I..;., .. J. .. -"'" . !......... ,i. � ( ~' .. ... "� -. ... .. 301

l. lil c:t 11ay fro fi l ..LU ~}Q t 'J 'U ... -er�� .... .. tn, c .u.. l";o<' fi: 1 to p �cri j( � (.,ou b ).~�...l.. .iJ., h e ,..t ~ r,.. � � '.Ci q t 4!1 ~ -ltZ__ ' �- 302