[ G.R. No. 4545. March 25, 1908 ]

[ G.R. No. 4545. March 25, 1908 ]

[ G.R. No. 4545. March 25, 1908 ]

LAUREANA LUZURIAGA, PETITIONER AND APPELLEE, VS. THE INSULAR COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, RESPONDENT AND APPELLANT

WILLARD, J.:

IMMIGRATION OF CHINESE; HABEAS CORPUS.—From the Court of First Instance of Manila. This ease is analogous to Ngo-Ti vs. Sinister (7 Phil. Kep., 360), and Ko Poco vs. McCoy (10 Phil. Rep., 442), which are followed. Judgment reversed, and appellee remanded to custody of appellant.

Per Willard, J.

For appellant: Attorney-General Araneta. For appellee: Jose Ma. de Marcaida.

D E C I S I O N

This case is governed by the decisions in the cases of Ngo Ti vs. Shuster, 7 Phil. Reps. 355, and Ko Poco vs. McCoy, decided March 20, 1908.

The judgment of the court below is reversed and it is ordered that Irineo Lusuriaga be remanded to the custody of the Insular Collector. No costs will be allowed in either court.