CTA Case No. 2550 (Decision)

'< !<: f , II� l"H!UPPI:-JES 1�,,l f �~� t):: 'L\.\ .l.l'Pl1::aL::l Q!Jl:-.%01'- ~~lTV �~~..lv � .1.1 'v � ! �:L g.D t In\.. � t P~titlorwr , 't m~ '� Oi1LIS~""! .,1\f?:H :Jk' .,. Ut,\'1 0 ;I 1 p ~...<.;i ~nt . ~- - � � � - � � � � � - � - � A spot� 9!4\. �otntC1s~i~n~u' at: � u tom& , Gted Jul.)' Y; .1.9?.), . uph..~lc.in the aec1 on of tbl!i) Co leotol� . ur Lus s th t the t:u. t 1 6..P 1 ' ~ 1\1 � t.ce , , u;;; . .....111 ot' Llllf.Jahs tic . 6c \'IU. is s~eu st.tippin a e ..t ,. J: te 1 �1 u 1 ::.1: �.c:iew Co . in ,.avo.r of the ical (..- t.l"i t e� J lnC � nd h.l.SU ttl ln � ar 'o~�e1... n "�1 co ~~:?. ...1 'e s \0 ..;J.' tb v 'S - sel uc � ai'ln � the 4 casei:t ot co J:ec l.i ~n..~ri~s; ..&~ , ....._ _ - �L ~---:.--. .._..,

�r.........., ,... D l .. �2 3. ;. � 1 ct1 exe- n� 0 1 1 r 1 � t t e 1 1 ��ou scheme 0 u t 1n on 0 � l 16 h 1 205

� 3 l" � r in plai n 0 20 6

... ~ ... '.1. ...... . <). !'!', � �-~;v 4 f l"i ro b . c�, �)e � �a ..'\ . -lie� 1 1. vh<"' v� ~- un in ~u )., .. 1 ~n . ,.. ~�vr r~ tn .) ...1 \. is _,. h '-' scheme \. r il,, .~ r�i.i ..., t. t. p � 1- ' . . . '.a r , :0 t.J lo.ii.Jl}. .. l n .., w L t o .i"'w.:: ' ..;l� , I,; 't H . ' r in ... i.u 1,. VC I. ~~1 � Ul.li . a � ., r � ' . .. lb C.>' � �r C; ........ ::.. h;;., .,"t,;: Y � ..' .h c~ ' ��c .. .1. �u 1 -l �' no � �u 1.� I' 1 e ' ..1. ~ u .. 'i;;; 1 :.. ~c i<.; ru s o1' , CJ 'h t<. �r 1C�d. � u .. :('"' r- 207

f i t .1 r J' iry tt tu l 1- ( u' �t � ... ~ � J.l' . 1 ,,'3C\.0 0 .' . ) 1 � 0 ,7j!,.t) �i 1 � rui 1 r t Int :t� 1sl 1 .Jl.& .. >J t C' 'A. � 4!J 1' c � 11 1 v ;.J l , l97 � �E . � \ 208