CTA Case No. 2731 (Decision)

fYff .1. C(JI }, T ,. � iti n :r, .. � t � '>731 -... � ... X ~ ~i c l I �T - 1 "$ ;,n t 0 � ~ I� y ti t c ent 0 Ot" s a ... 0 i,.�;n . "'l 0 hilit t~jn~;.~' , ,.c:::il �ct� (lj to .c en .J.S f .~ o. t - th :r t 'ln r. c J�� . ;nto... L . cs Inc ., t:i..\0 � .. n::l ot u�n 0 (l ~ \ i t (.; "ic X' t "J . . J.loil. ,, t . cz::tn Of nd � .U( i"!t '97 tv \1 n f_ l �x c t�on loilo ....... 620

t u. 21 1 ... lu nt lo -~ n c o wit - .... ... -- ... ... - "' l a 73 - ..... .... ...... ... -- - ... n a 'I.~ 97'J " J n ''!'V 17, 197'.J - -- 7 \: - ' U.., �7 t t . .0: . \ Q� � 46 �- lc to k .. l O. 17 ~X .... .cla '" ~7 ) ..v:.W. .., f .� nt ... o 0 uCt b .CaU:..r� t....Bn ,....t� c e~ )t 0 n c1 y 621

i' � 731 .. i t. nc 0 .� l 4,, l. 76":J , , ...,. .I!: ! n, s ot .... J !! 0 l ted lo �'�b . ~ , 9~ . ..\, �' :'.~.,....... h t. r oal an ( y. � i/llj, 0 nt t.y � l ... 0 1 ilo 0 h ()ti n J.. .... 0 gr "t ci. of ti n. In u- J. th tr 0 t �lib 0 O'I lt I ,. 1:. ..o c 622

.' 731 ... t n s nt t{) f � � () il n . io 0 X el j ri t ut fall ~~ 1 te �lO , 46 ,. ('2) t t n el s �el 0 ion on . .. � 17 .47 :), 17 l �� � ecei e t 197~) t till ..�ty ( ) ny ,, 0 . 1 t t Ul l f tl :Ll f � nI r� 10 ( .... ~ (:lS r. q l l t':V) ..... /#" .... .. yQ 1 0 0 va 1 te 0 I .o 0 rt� 1f- l�.n ... n e;a . r:u t.od by hi~ r ,_ r v ~ re u n l of loilo � h �a t Iloil loil t ll 9 v 1 � 0 0 . �utin' .e .]. y uncil ! 623

.. t d tb t tl n~ T o. � and n co 0 n m~�:lt l~ . """ i $ 0 .� h ol � (} ' I o "! 'l i. l' i'ti n , invokJ.nc {l ('a t(# !, 1~�; no. tn t ~ -� 0!; I j xi. no ov of . ubl ic .ct tlo. ...1: l~edy 1� \ t, n~ c.::id ... p e v<)r : (j ~ 1, ill: .,J nt o- - ions 1i \;'O;.c Ct" If f .( : ; } aven ~~ in � . at t: ~ vo v � �'h t 0t j. l , ., w c n� 1 - t1 r J. <rn 0 t'C in .. 624

f � �! � { ~) 0 0 t1 r;land c .- t1 . l. n 0 : tr. o: $ "~ Ot cl l�y J. ' ~ efo �,�... .i h � ,. 1 t y �< �( ) Til ,. nil : c �.. se . ct n :J. ' ,Jl .. (c { ~.p.:-r. n . l ~ o~: i 0 n � c n it .nd oa "'1 iJ nt t. eri' n 0 t' n 1 ) � ll.n �:1' 625

.. . . No. 1 - 7 ... I) 0 s. � #� c :J. ie on � a an ri ~Gilt$ a 1 'IW (o. { :te j~ die:. on of t i s Cou t VC' n 0 n -�ne:f :r � h- Uc :l'.'d C) �n ~� f ) :r. p: t !LG" 1n .ayn o t n:...er tho i"l r y ic I . d� c in h; � "10 1 od. tJ d / t t n iw onts h~ t. i a �0 tion 1 nr al 0 0 L ul � h�'l t L y " t~ t ~ idcnti l r lt all j i lC �0 �� to 0 ns c l et c 1u 2 '' ) 6 ( � '01

- ,7 - 0 . o .. ,

XX .�~ .~ 628

.' - ory xovi s ot~ /' f .1 p. cvinc ,}t If) of c u .. or c�ty 0 rds o~.e ,. t.:Ci.:;i~n ~ ere - of� 629

�7 ... l - 1 or ' n � 1.. � 1 " l � j ic 1 f ( 0 � 12 f �� l: � () c T � c 'u n zn r 630

~..~. 7 1 ' f:r. n.. o�... 0 � ci �y � 0 d~ f e ~- ...J ., .,.. \... .:'!J( . ,, /. �C e �h !nch ~,. v ..� .� �r ~ t 0 e .! ,t :n ... fp'� - t� i.on ,.,( of th'"1 0 0 .~ \,) n - .r .at'1, 0 l Oat."' 6 t ..al ,, t .)� T e -l �"' ,7'Jl.C l i 'l o:. l ..!. .) :- 7( 3) 1 c ~..~ r �~ l- c I' t) c. , o f "-~ ~ c et't, n rg. . l ... <.,.. �..t 0 u j t �t~ r m('.'n � l . vur 0 v.... by l ,.,. l� 1 ~ y � it n 631

�7 - uj i i 1 t i of � �v; i

.. �� 7. l 1 ') e 11 n. tJ .. ll "'"'id 1111 f ' '�� '*' ....,~, ....n in ... 0- r;nc ' :t To n \ f fJ c:: \tnt -o :r al c � o. 1 631

', . ~l.;to:r - "" , 1 . , .... t... ,.;) ! Nv-. 2731 curt 1 .4. 1476:.> l �' Jv!'�;J, ". ~ 11.rf Ly thr. I oil bl thi~ ourt haO' t1f'lf'C>lJ <Jt{i ju.d r: :1.lctiml -~~. J.": vi by d ..~.u.........,u..... � c;;i ,.ions of rev nC:ic!l n r t he oerd

� "7 1 tl bo 1 - 1?- 1 � t ac 636

....\... .... ~c c: (! :L- O l low ~ ~ ~ ' ..1 .... h .. lJty l - ~� ,,, ( (r ~ JI -�I!'! ll ~ tI . l. ,y -.) f. tit , ...., to h I... y ert ,. c �c t. the 9 io..:o t~ tC � ct .. . .. "' ~ to t ~ o.l .u.. ~ \'.11! 1 a - .. lnt * �n. - ..... 1 " '. . t0 r.i ..1'"' , n .6 637

.. 1 t:t~ .... -tc ... t n-ul y � .ut: ,.. r y for ci... 0 t$ .int .rn uv 0 ten o� � c��� � no 'T.:)i�t.:. fo u h d of the cv nl ;r ... qUJ. c' rt r 0 nal n .I " ld st if1 .... . ""..II ( ltut_d t)'_f>.., eiftex ( ll ctor nu V!".J � :� ., . ~n il . '";~ .. B J l� � il . hi � 234; � nv ti 0 \ *1 -11 nu ry - � ' ~6 ,j{. ' 0 tJ , r 16, lJ6l . 1'7 � nto nal 't v .. � c . ... 't J nu rv " � _.n.!. ~;.. . �J h i s �t f"l ee 0 .. ~ �:ron.. <.ucly .aid v �~tio��o l n venu ou io rul- n to y�to . �t t� �on vi q s i n ... ~ c f r ac � ri�~ ctio h co � 638

~ 77------------------~~----~----------~----~�~-- .. � 73 � ...., . - .1, l ' 639