CTA Case No. 1482 (Decision)

~EPUBI.IC OF THE PHILIPPINc.; COURT OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY � - . - . . - .. - - - - p ... .- X ! Thic is th c 1s 0 of t ... t 0 n " .,1nplt.. t~ ' i t ... ��� o .. 1 ( 2) n1 97, t.>l. u {c . c r.-~ � . � ro . 1568). c ..i ill t or c i. ~on . etit1o r oot. ~ pin � nuf � Corp tJ t l on t t r.l ' 19 l c 1 0 .,.. ct ~ 7� in tre fc y, 1 t 19 0 52 )25'3. 0 'N'& r: i pur- su t to 1 r 1 tior.. to ~~ ctic 1 6 � th Coft t hieh w r � p t ro ~pan, .�-.-.... no t � t C,/ ~-- re � ct� r t- i onc into f o� u ~ cent. n r" o ... ceo ..in ;;> 0 nc y it. c 1 ct 0 1 on t coc nut oil .ctur c 246

2 b t 1 ion-.r .f t<Jt" p a - ~ l.Ug t lU d.VUl1C tt;,X on tn.a t i 9 a nd be111')V':l. n~ tnn� i t L.) o �. r' t he ~ Et1F lim o. t x, c ti t-�on r fi J. d . l th r~s ~ o~ on temb 23 , .. 96 a 0 ai J.. ' 1 Jept b r \, .. G ':l... as fi lor 2~ - """ .. " Wit 0 w� ,f. i J. rr ,~ c 1~1 on it cla _ <l t i t p pQ.a,l e..t tiO t no. t re l-' . 1.4 0 l.~.e ��roo 0 (ins ' � 0� ... v�nc r; l. b 961 to y . Cttl l' )' pst:t tion 1.. �' � :re u ~'l.~ " 0 !II 52,253 . . 1 ) .A..... 0 0 t;L t .�' !; ' l'r J� ve�J... u~.t"' 3 "IJ 0 ~0 t) 1963. I "' � �1 !&. \ ) :-.., ts;:e,..,.. , ~':-.�� f of' 11, t ..)2~ .J ' h.c ou.nt o ~ &. ,. n 1 nnl av Jl .... '�li. th Cas o. .. r. sp et t o .ne of th c : e.L1 :1 itt. . t ( l ., 24 7

�1 2 f}68 ..) . )..- .:: �o 1! ll ' 1 h t 1 ~ o "'ot� ' t1 ' .�.. ~ '1 o "' It n._l , nv;;;:c;ue � conta.1 :r�r il ject to 7"" --.~tv.nc� ll J b 1 Coda. Co ,, !ne, lf"" . I. � ..... o t d J.n- ~ 21171, :r. n, plat "' .:r<:> ide ro a.,. au R ~P n"ont l ie�; -� 186, 0 ot erwts, .. g.r t , t~ ~ ::: ~~ li ,.. ,_ ..'1... t ' 0~ ...., .. . _ ~ ....... tori . , 1 i .... r't~ tO � ' r .. J � , J ,~~, re , .... ~ .... ... 0 tb. it .< , l;t 1 1.o _,o �- ut t.o.:r. on y di.t'r \;oo .. .... t :.i e ~~n .:. J ,;~L 0~ � .l. � ~o~O.l"' .:;J..i ~ll \ ing co. , tn � � h e:: i~ ..'.. ~ ...in o:f ~.~i raw mat br . r,c .l " ol d I I,,.!. � L.;., pl te � _,"-"" f... orm �' n H...l- . .i- ' ,.0 "c"� .:; .�.-.... �~ i..~t..c.U l ~,,~ ~-� 1s.uc in lV"! ln the two ca" es are the ~rl t vi.,� :1.1. it <rated in Vic tor ...s t�l l l ng co . v � . ormnis<:! ione.:-, � .� o .,1.;- 2 765 - ... ,:::lt-??9, eb. 25, 1967. 248

- 1568 . .. the price ,(,_'.["!) J.0 Cod~: '?) ,;t...a . . J�o~ Ht-lic'1 ~;r ,~ in i .;;,,,,~,-� ~- . -� !'0 .,., .,. i.l.., ts ( e� :1 CJtL... -.;~t CGO :..lt ol'.t) ;J ~ .�~ ~ .J ::.::...1-- l '"' ' ~� <.> ' cu .. . or ; �"' ...� r._, i l t l .,.. t~J\.. 3 (.'.l,.........,. i ~l . oi.l; j o r , ~ l 1.: ,~ ~ nc~ tt~e . sa. .e , ., � lv \n .-, 1�1 both ' ' .�I.J :,.",..\.,_' -� 1 ~; ~~ L �� ~ t . 1 ;"' ., . ��.f L. Co �~ � r t .. - t 1 - ., . ,..,l..,.. ,J,. ... ().r.'l..;. j, ( , l . "' - .i c� r.. ti ~1 tern '1t.;;n t ;J o�v- ;.so .!..' c re:::.ds ~ .. Ctl s ... t n... 249

' "C! I ON .. � 11-82 15' 8 w-h11 . the XX x .tx:tx . ~ s ~b ject to aR ander hu.ndre ei bty� nine o � th in 0 od o� t' ~ 2. v~

- - 25 t 1 J. t th 1 O.t co a y. / 251

!1 i~�l of h g, e ho. tho ti �late"" nc ~ ;:,l to;,. 1 tio 0 not to t ?, ~. pro vi n 'ecti n r~la � or:: t "'action 6, ot,~. l.e \io ever, t� tion filed ola 0 UO� 0 on th th-:.. Co ont$r Q nal <:JVCll. e in �e'l'�A� Cae- ..,o. !~82, t i s r. t t t 0 'th .. ra u 0 r ~ Ci i n c �~ .. ~ .. � l .r n .1 icinl Action fo r reco ry ~rrQ~ eo u~~ or illa, ~ l .p ool- lect :J .. . l ~ in uncil e:J. 1 fo uch t "' hall havo been f1 J. ~i t tll(; Commissi.o ~ f lnt � ~ al cv n e ..) ,...avi 11 . $ clo �o ~� ar.t tl . tc ttP n~Y of: t.L 11aid oun "' In ac:;d tion, p t .it�onn.r 1. e ,u lJ y �l1 tl 0 \.h v und 0 52, :53 . n ~ . T.l � c w . o. ,1. 5' . . 252

--- -..... ( It 1!)., . ~ou .,.~..,.,~ c ll ~ -:-:. ~ l' 3J; 110 �1t tL -t 1r. the s . ~ O~ h e ~ ti r nt tat1 n o is i tl tc s ec .:tr but th r et- tr1 . ul. not 1 c..:.t�-. Inti n, 1t in l i u of tt1~ th i r u , ( ec . 4, u �, .. of o t Gn th . J ~ lt of t eccn 0 s..... t i ' ':1: or n~ L � � doc" mantary t 1mpo c os f .np 11 J tt al a t~ - � \C � of y t � . n t 1. ,.,.. pu <;;: ' L Ant t1 �8 to . ,~ tt: '"1. r made ..) � cfu _ or I t M nufr etu 1 pet1 ti .o s 0 r tto 253

- - . - ,.., ...,._�~ 9 adva.nc sales tr.x rr n>O ::..1 J. 10. on i ts 1m~ o . ted tin... pl.;1t�L � ~� t o't p:r:. unc e ..t (; t cod.t� . tl ~''Ot City , Jtlly 3 , 191"": - � .to � 1/ C i��.t- ;..:nE::oci;7.ttc "fU.CJGn on leave