Opinion No. 23-08Re: Lending company activity

Exchange Commission Securitiesand ILIPPINES

OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

SEC-OGC Opinion No.23-08 Re: Lending company activity

q May 2023

Unit 1404 One Park Drive 9th Avenue cr. 11th Drive Bonifacio Global City, Taguig City allan@canejalaw.com MARISOL CANEJA & ASSOCIATES marisol@canejalaw.com

Attention: Atty. Ronald Allan Ydia Atty. Marisol Caneja

Gentlemen:

whether the intended business activity using the online platform called "Earned Wage Access (EWA)" constitutes a lending activity which requires obtaining a Certificate of Authority to Operate as a Lending Company from the Commission. This refers to your letter dated 01 September 2022 requesting the Commission's opinion on

company registered in Singapore. WageSage is in the process of registering a wholly-owned subsidiary in the Philippines under the reserved name "GetPaid Philippines Incorporated" ("GetPaid"). As stated in your letter, the EWA platform is developed by WageSage Pte. Ltd. (the "WageSage"), a

extending support on earned employment benefits and providing technological platforms in relation thereto. It includes providing the online platform EWA for employees to get early access to their earned Wages. GetPaid intends to provide administrative and operational support on human resources, such as

The EWA platform works as follows:

1 "[T]he Company or GetPaid will enter into a commercial contract with the corporate employers (the "Employers" on the use and access of the EWA for its employees. An (sic) employer access details will be provided by the Company or GetPaid;

2. terms on the use of EWA, provide details of their bank accounts where funds can be transferred, and once registration "[T]he employees of the Employers who are interested to avail and use EWA will have to register online, agree on the is completed, an (sic) access details will be provided by the Company or GetPaid (the "Registered Employees"); 3. "[P]art of the terms that the Registered Employees will be required to agree on to will be on the assignment of the payment of the relevant amount of the earned wage from the Employer to the Company or GetPaid;

"[T]he Employers will provide the Company or GetPaid the relevant information on hours/days worked by its Registered Employees and the monetary equivalent of the earned wage; 5 "[W]hen a Registered Employee needs money in between payroll dates, the Registered Employee may access his/her available earned wage reflected in the EWA platform. For each access which results to transferring funds to the Registered Employee's bank account, a transaction fee of up to four percent (4%) is deducted out of the total amount being used;

[ 14/F The SEC Headquarters, 7907 Makati Avenue +63 288185348/+632)88185418 www.sec.gov.ph|ogc_picc@sec.gov.ph Salcedo Village, Bel-airMakati City TOVRheinland CERTHED I0865378 ISO 9001:2015 0S0 0 e

Page 2 of 5

6. "[0]n [the] specific payroll date, the Employer will release to the Company or GetPaid the equivalent amount that has to the relevant Registered Employee; been transferred by its Registered Employee, and any balances of the total earned wage or salary will be paid directly

I "[B]y way of example: Registered Employee has Php500.00 per day salary (net of all regulatory contributions and deductions), and has worked for five (5) working days. At the end of the 5th working days (sic), the Registered Employee has Php2,500.00 as earned wage and [this is] reflected in the EWA platform. The Registered Employee and access EWA to transfer Php1000.00. The Company or GetPaid will transfer to the designated bank account of the needs urgent access to funding for emergency requirement of Php1000.00. The Registered Employee can go online Employer of the Registered Employee will transfer to the Company or GetPaid the amount of Php1000.00 while the Registered Employee the amount of Php960.00 (net of the Php40.00 transaction fee). On the payroll date, the rest of the total salary will be paid directly to the Registered Employee; xxx

using the EWA platform has not been classified as a lending or loan activity. wherein it has not been required to obtain a lending license or similar license because its business activity You averred in your letter that WageSage has business presence in Singapore and Indonesia,

to operate as a lending company. of the EWA Platform, is not a loan and in carrying out the business activity in the Philippines, GetPaid should not be considered as engaged in a lending activity and therefore should not be required to obtain a license In relation thereto, you posit that the intended business activity, which is the above-described use

You are now requesting confirmation of your position.

license in Singapore and Indonesia because its business activity using the EWA platform has not been in the Philippines, it must comply with Philippine laws. classified as a lending or loan activity. However, since GetPaid intends to conduct the same business activity At the outset, we recognize that WageSage was not required to secure a lending license or similar

Loan and lending company as defined under Philippine laws

Article 1933 of the Civil Code of the Philippines1 defines loan as follows:

contract is called a commodatum; or money or other consumable thing, upon the condition that the consumable so that the latter may use the same for a certain time and return it, in which case the same amount of the same kind and quality shall be paid, in which case the contract is simply called a loan or mutuum. Article 1933. By the contract of loan, one of the parties delivers to another, either something not

Commodatum is essentially gratuitous. Simple loan may be gratuitous or with a stipulation to pay interest. In commodatum the bailor retains the ownership of the thing loaned, while in simple loan, ownership passes to the borrower. (Emphasis supplied)

loan, one of the parties delivers to another money upon the condition that the same amount of the same kind and quality shall be paid. A person who receives a loan of money acquires ownership thereof, and is bound to pay to the creditor an equal amount of the same kind and quality. In the case of Santiago vs. Spouses Garcia2, the Supreme Court held that "by a contract of simple

Based on the foregoing, the elements of a loan are as follows:

(2) Person who receives the money or consumable thing (debtor) acquires ownership thereof; and (3) Debtor is bound to pay to the creditor an equal amount of the same kind and quality. (1 One of the parties (creditor) delivers money or another consumable thing to another;

2 G.R. No. 228356, 09 March 2020 1 Civil Code of the Philippines, Republic Act No. 386, 18 June 1949

wa aa ahasa 14/F The SEC Headquarters, 7907 Makati Avenue BL

www.sec.gov.ph |ogc_picc@sec.gov.ph

Page 3 of 5

was later on enacted to regulate the establishment of lending companies and to place their operation on a sound, efficient and stable condition to derive the optimum advantages from them as an additional to lay down the minimum requirements and standards under which they may be established and do source of credit; to prevent and mitigate, as far as practicable, practices prejudicial to public interest; and Republic Act (RA) No. 9474 or the Lending Company Regulation Act of 2007 (LCRA), as amended3

business.

Section 3 of the LCRA provides that:

SECTION 3. Definition of Terms. -- For purposes of implementing this Act, the following definitions shall apply:

companies, pawnshops, insurance companies, cooperatives and other credit institutions already (a) Lending Company shall refer to a corporation engaged in granting loans from its own capital to include banking institutions, investment houses, savings and loan associations, financing regulated by law. The term shall be synonymous with lending investors. funds or from funds sourced from not more than nineteen (19) persons. It shall not be deemed

may be agreed upon between the lending company and the debtor.4 company, as a creditor, may grant loans in such amounts and reasonable interest rates and charges as Similar to the Civil Code of the Philippines, Section 7 of the LCRA recognizes that a lending

creditor, the lending company, and the borrower or person granted a loan by such lending company,5 company, it can be inferred from the rest of the provisions that this involves a subject to interest or charges as authorized under the said law. Thus, while the LCRA does not specifically define "loan" as used in the definition of a lending contract between a

Proposed business model of GetPaid through the EWA Platform

engaged in granting "loans" as its primary business activity. Applying the foregoing to the facts provided, it must be first determined whether GetPaid will be

proposed business model: Based on your letter, it appears that there are three contractual relationships that will exist in your

1. Between GetPaid and the corporate employers - GetPaid will enter into a commercial contract with the corporate employers on the use and access of the EWA for its employees. The employers will provide the Company or GetPaid the relevant information on hours/days worked by their employees and the monetary equivalent of the earned wage.

2 Between GetPaid and the employees - The employees of the employers who are interested to registered employee's bank account, a transaction fee of up to four percent (4%) is deducted avail and use EWA will have to register online, agree on the terms on the use of EWA, provide details of their bank accounts where funds can be transferred, and once registration is wage reflected in the EWA platform. For each access which results to transferring funds to the out of the total amount being used. completed, access details will be provided by GetPaid. When a registered employee needs money in between payroll dates, the registered employee may access his/her available earned

3. Between the employees and the employer as regards the amount advanced by GetPaid - Part of

the terms that the registered employee will be required to agree on to will be on the the GetPaid. On a specific payroll date, the employer will release to GetPaid the equivalent assignment of the payment of the relevant amount of the earned wage from the employer to

5 (bid., Section 3(b) 3 RA No. 9474, Lending Company Regulation Act of 2007, 22 May 2007, as amended by RA No. 10881, Amendments to Investment Restrictions in Specific Laws on Adjustment, Lending, and Financing Companies, and Investment Houses,17 July 2016 4 Ibid., Section 7

www.sec.gov.ph [ogc_picc@sec.gov.ph 14/F The SEC Headquarters7907 Makati Avenue +63288185348/+632)88185418 fo Vi 103 Bel-air.Mak O O

Page 4 of 5

amount that has been transferred by its registered employee, and any balances of the total earned wage or salary will be paid directly to the relevant registered employee.

amount of money to registered employees with the latter's earned wage as the maximum amount of money that can be advanced less transaction fee up to four percent (4%), as the limit. Based on the foregoing business model, the main business activity of GetPaid is advancing an

Philippines, to wit: The elements of this business activity fall within the definition of a loan under the Civil Code of the

1. 2 A sum of money using the EWA Platform; GetPaid delivers to another, the registered employees;

3 Upon the condition that the same amount shall be paid in return, subject to interest or charges

incidental to such transaction, if any.

monthly etc.). This is precisely the reason why the amount is being extended by GetPaid to the said amount advanced by GetPaid using its own funds. While the amount transferred is based on the wage earned by the registered employees as the limit, the said amount is not yet owned by the registered employees, as the same is to be received at a later date as agreed with the employer (e.g. bi-monthly registered employees in the first place. It must be emphasized that what is transferred by GetPaid to the registered employees is an

Article 103 of the Labor Code on the time of payment of wages provides:

"Article 103. Time of Payment. - Wages shall be paid at least once every two (2) weeks or twice circumstances beyond the employer's control, payment of wages on or within the time herein provided cannot be made, the employer shall pay the wages immediately after such force majeure or circumstances have ceased. No employer shall make payment with less frequency than once a month. a month at intervals not exceeding sixteen (16) days. If on account of force majeure or

(2) weeks shall be subject to the following conditions, in the absence of a collective bargaining The payment of wages of employees engaged to perform a task which cannot be completed in two agreement or arbitratior That payments are made at intervals not exceeding sixteen (16) days, in proportion to the That the final settlement is made upon completion of the work." (Emphasis and underscoring supplied) amount of work completed awarc

over it; he cannot assign it without the consent of the government. belongs to the government. Accordingly, before there is actual delivery of the check, the payee has no power or employee does not belong to him before it is physically delivered to him. Until that time, the check In De La Victoria vs. Burgos6, the Supreme Court held that the salary check of a government officer

as agreed with the employer. Prior to such time, ownership over the said amount remains with the employer and the employee cannot appropriate the same until it becomes due and demandable. services were already rendered, the ownership over said amount has not yet been transferred to the employees until the same is remitted to their personal accounts according to the specified time of payment Applying the foregoing, although the wages of the employee are already earned by them since the

loans from its own capital funds to the registered employees which falls within the concept of lending activity, GetPaid is considered as a lending company as defined under the LCRA. Since the proposed business activity of GetPaid under the EWA platform involves extension of

6 G.R. No. 111190, 27 June 1995.

www.sec.gov.ph |ogc_picc@sec.gov.ph 14/F The SEC Headquarters,7907 Makati Avenue +63288185348/+63288185418 do VillageBel-airMakati Ci

Page 5 of 5

exempt or remove the activity from the ambit of the term "lending" or "granting of loans". The LCRA does not distinguish as to whom or for what purpose the lending companies should offer their services.7 That the financial service is limited to only those employees registered with GetPaid does not

it should secure a secondary license to operate as a lending company in the Philippines. A secondary license to operate as a lending company, is a mere privilege, and the issuance thereof is conditioned on the grantee's full compliance with applicable laws and regulations. Section 4 of the LRCA explicitly states that the Commission should grant a prior authority to operate as a lending company before such company can conduct its business in the Philippines. With GetPaid's usage of the EWA Platform falling within the act of extending a loan under the LCRA

circumstances and documents disclosed/submitted, and should be considered relevant solely to the particular issue raised therein. It shall not be used in the nature of a standing rule binding upon the Commission in other cases or upon the courts whether of similar or dissimilar circumstances.8 If upon investigation, it will be disclosed that the facts relied upon are different, this opinion shall be rendered null and void. It shall be understood that the foregoing opinion is rendered solely on the basis of the facts,

Very truly yours, Uo mN&LgbmM ROMUALD C.PADILLA General Counsel

8 Section 7, SEC Memorandum Circular 2003-15, 16 December 2003. 7 SEC-OGC Opinion No. 19-45, Re: Lending Company Activity, 7 May 2019.

14/F The SEC Headquarters, 7907 Makati Avenue +63288185348/+6328818 5418 Salcedo Village, Bel-air, Makati City ISO 9001:2015 0E0

O www.sec.gov.ph [ ogc_picc@sec.gov.ph D 10865378