Opinion No. 06-07 RE : Retail Trade : Qualification to Engage in Retail Trade

, •~ ~.'.', () 31 January 2006 SEC Opinion No. 06-07 Retail Trade: Qualification to Engage in Retail Trade Atty. Daisy L. Parker Orion Maxis, Inc. (OMI) 20/F LKG Tower 6801 Ayala Avenue, Makati City Madam: This refers to your letter dated 26 August 2005 requesting opinion on whether Orion Maxis, Inc. (OlvII), a domestic corporation with a paid-up capital of P14,OOO,OOO.00,may be allowed to engage in retail trade. Records with the SEC disclose the following: Orion Maxis, Inc. is a corporation duly registered with the SEC under Company Registration No. A200017060. Its primary purpose is to engage in and undertake the business of establishing, developing, operating, maintaining and providing management and logistical infrastTllcture service and technical support, with application/access to commercial website for the facilitation of retail and wholesale operations of all types of merchandise, as well as the management of enterprise and market incentive systems solutions, as well as to engage in other allied businesses and services, and to acquire and dispose of any property real or personal as shall be deemed necessary or convenient fo~.the conduct of business. ,OMI's General Information Sheet filed with the SEC on 25 November 2005 shows authorized capital of P50,OOO,OOD.00, and subscribed capital, as well as paid- up capital, of P14,500,OOO.00.It has five stockholders on record. Of the five stockholders, Tutuban Properties, Inc., a domestic corporation, holds almost 100% or 14,999,996shares of OMI. Section 5 paragraph 2 of the Retail Trade Law provides:

.' ..• •... \, "SECTION 5.Foreign Equity Participation. -_ Foreign-qwned ., partnerships, associations and corporations formed and organized under the laws of the Philippines may, upon regish"ation with the j Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Department of I Trade and Industry (DTI), or in case of foreign-owned single . proprietorships, with the DTI, engage or invest in the retail trade' business, subject to the following categories: I Category A - Enterprises with paid-up capital of the equivalent in Philippine Pesos of less than Two million five hundred thousand US dollars (US$2,500,OOO.00)shall lIe reserved exclllsi7lely for Filipino citizens and corporations wholly owned by Filipino citizens. Category B - Enterprises '''lith a minimum paid-up capital of the equivalent in- Philippine Pesos of Tl'\TOmillion five hundred thousand US dollars (US$2,500,OOO.00)but less than Seven million five hundred thousand US dolIars (US$7,500,OOO.00)may be whony owned by foreigners except for the first two (2) ye~rs after the effectivity of this Act wherein foreign participation shaH be limited to not more than sixty percent (60%) of total equity. x x x (underscoring ours)" It was established in a previous SEC opinion1 that Tutuban Properties Inc. (TPI), the major stockholder of aMI, is a duly registered corporation under Philippine laws engaged in real estate business, with a paid-up capital of P200M2 or 3 US$3,571,428 and wholly owned by Orion Land Inc. (OLI). aLI is a domestic holding company which in turn is 100% owned by Prime Orion Philippines, Inc. (POPI), a publicly listed company of which 26% of its outstanding capital is owned by foreigners as of 17 December 2004. As of said date, POP!'s total holdings subscribed amounted to P2,141,826,456.00 or US$40,576,422.39.4 Hence, aMI is not a corporation wholly owned by Filipino citizens. aMI has a paid-up capital of US$274,699.255 or Two I-Jundred Seventy-Four Thousand Six Hundred Ninety-Nine US dollars and Twenty-rive Cents; hence, it has a paid-up capital of less than US$2,500,OOO.OO.Category A enterprises, or enterprises with paid-up capital of the equivalent in Philippine Pesos of less than US$2,500,OOO.OO shan be reserved exclusively for Filipino citizens and corporations wholly owned by Filipino citizens. . 1 SEC Opinion No. 04-35,14 June 2004 2 paid-up capital is still the same as of 26 November 2005 per GIS on file with the Commission 3 US$1.00=P56.00 4 US$1.00 = P52.785 (as of 20 January 2006) 5p14,500,000.00=$ 274,699.25 at US$1.00 = P52.7R5 2

, .; For OMI to be qualified fo engage in the retail trade business, it has to increase its minimum paid-up capital to Two million five hundred thousand US dollars (US$2,500,OOO.00) and it should amend its articles of incorporation to include the intended "retail trade business" in its purpose clause. . Very truly yours, VERNETTE G. UMALI-PACO General Counsel 3