Opinion No. 17-10 Re: Condominium Corporation: Membership; Proxy Rules; Compensation of Directors and Officers; Hold-Over Capacity; Corporate Term.

Page 1 of 7

Securities and Exchange Commission Republic of the Philippines Department of Finance

OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL

31 August 2017

Re: Condominium Corporation: Membership; SEC-OGC Opinion No.17-10 Proxy Rules;

Officers; Hold-Over Capacity; Compensation of Directors and Corporate Term

SELECTED HOMEOWNERS/RESIDENTS OF URCI LAS PINAS TOWNHOMES URCI Las Pinas Townhomes Alabang Zapote Road Pamplona 3,Las Pinas City 0740 rasecdguzman@gmail.com Bldg.Unit 15-07

ATTENTION: Cesar L. De Guzman, John F. De Guzman, Federico Malaga, Fe T. Alagos, Eduardo A.Baquir,and Francis Janda

Gentlemen:

Condominium Corporation (ULPCC, for brevity). requesting for an opinion regarding the present situation of your community, URCI Las Pinas This is in response to your letters dated 14 February 2017 and 16 February 2017,

In the letter, you raised numerous concerns regarding several topics, namely: 1. Alleged violations of the by-laws by the Officers/Board of Directors 2. Imposition of sanctions on the members of the Board of Directors for their alleged mismanagement, overspending and other contestable actions; specifically those concerning Board election, implementation of increase in association dues and other contestable actions;

Page 2 of 7

3. What government agency will govern your community if you chose to be a

plain Homeowners Association, as well as the requirements needed for the

4. Scope of work and compensation of the employees of ULPCC; transition, and the composition of its management;

5 The definition of "members" in relation to the ULPCC by-laws and the

Governing Guidelines for the Election of New Members of the Board of

6. Validity and duration of proxy voting documents in relation to the election Directors;

7 Validity and limitation of compensation of the Directors and the Officers of of the members of the Board;

8. 9. Hold-over capacity of the incumbent Board of Directors; Questions on corporate term of the corporation; and ULPCC;

10. The list of documents that should be submitted regularly to the Commission.

opinion on matters which: (1) require determination of factual issues, (2) involve the Please be advised that as a matter of policy, the Commission refrains from rendering

exercise of business judgment or discretion that properly falls within the competence of the management of the entities concerned1, (3) require interpretation of administrative rules and issuances of other government agencies considering that it is the promulgating agencies which are competent to undertake such construction by reason of their knowledge of the specific intent and extent of application of the subject issuances2, and (4) involve the substantive and contractual rights of private parties who would, in all probability, contest the same in court in an intra-corporate or civil case, if the opinion turns out to be adverse to their interest3.

(Questions 3 and 4), and substantive and contractual rights of private parties which are litigious in nature (Questions 4 to 9), the Commission shall thus refrain from categorically interpretation of administrative rules and issuances of other government agencies answering the same. Considering that your queries involve intra-corporate matters (Questions 1 and 2).

However, for purposes of information only, the following may be imparted.

provides that; As to your first and second queries, the Securities Regulation Code (the "SRC")4

1. Devices or schemes employed by, or any act of, the board of directors, business associates, officers or partners, misrepresentation which may be detrimental to the interest of the public and/or of the stockholders, partners or members of any corporation. xxx.; amounting to fraud or

1 Section 5.9, SEC Memorandum Circular No. 15, series of 2003 2 Sec. 5.6, supra. 3 Sec. 5.2, supra Republic Act No.8799

Page 3 of 7

2. Controversies arising out of intra-corporate partnership, or association

3.Controversies in the election or appointment of directors, trustees, officers between, any or all of them and the corporation, partnership, or association of relations, between and among stockholders, members or associates; and which they are stockholders,members, or associates,respectively; and

or managers of corporations,partnerships, or associations,

are considered intra-corporate disputes which are beyond the jurisdiction of the Commission5.

in the Regional Trial Court which has jurisdiction over the principal office of the corporation, partnership, or association concerned6. All actions arising from the aforementioned grounds shall be commenced and tried

jurisdiction of the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board (the "HLURB"). As to your third query,a Homeowners' Association is now under the exclusive

neighborhood associations to the HLURB.Sections 4 and 20 of the law declare that every Homeowners' Association, including those previously registered by the Commission, shall register with the HLURB9, to wit: Republic Act No.99048 bestows jurisdiction over issues covering homeowners' and

be required to register with the HLURB. This registration shall serve to grant same by operation of the General Corporation Law or by any other general law Section 4. Registration with the HLURB. -- Every association of homeowners shall juridical personality to all such associations that have not previously acquired the

Section 20. Duties and Responsibilities of the HLURB. - In addition to the powers, authorities and responsibilities vested in it by Republic Act No. 8763, Presidential Decree No.902-A,Batas Pambansa Blg.68 and Executive Order No.535, Series of 1981, as amended, the HLURB shall:

XXX XXX

by the parties concerned before the regular courts: Provided, that all decisions of the HLURB are appealable directly to the Court of Appeals; organizations of the associations; controversies and/or conflicts, without prejudice to filing civil and criminal cases (c) Register all associations, federations, confederations or umbrella (d) Hear and decide intra-association and/or inter-association

7 SEC Case No. 03-06-128, Ibabao Bagong Lipunan Community Asspciation, Inc. (A Homeowners' Association) vs. 8 Otherwise known as the Magna Carta for Homeowners' Association. 5 Section5.2 of SRC. inrelation to Section5 of Presidential Decree No.902-A See Note7 6 1bic Ibabao Bagong Lipunan Community AssociationInc

Page 4 of 7

and other pertinent special labor laws, which are enforced by, and hence, within the employees are matters subject to business judgment and are governed by the Labor Code With regard to your fourth query, issues involving work and compensation of

competence of the Department of Labor and Employment.

by his Condominium Certificate of Title (CCT).However,based on the Memo dated 08 March 2010,the Board of Directors revised such definition by adding Absolute Deed of Sale as an of Absolute Sale have been abused by the incumbent directors so as to be qualified as candidates to the Board. by-laws as one who is a duly registered owner of a condominium unit at URCI, as evidenced additional evidence for one to be considered a member.You further stated that these Deeds As to your fifth query,you stated in your letter that "members" is defined in ULPCC's

accordance with Section 48 of the Corporation Code. Under the said Section, amendment of stock corporation, at a regular or special meeting duly called for the purpose. Whenever any the Commission of a certification that the same are not inconsistent with the Corporation Code. by-laws must be made by a majority vote of the Board of Directors or Trustees,and at least amendments are adopted, such amendments must be filed with the Commission to be a majority of the outstanding capital stock, or at least a majority of the members of a non- attached to the original by-laws. The amended by-laws shall only be effective upon issuance by Your letter did not state if the aforesaid amendment to the by-laws was made in

requirement for proxies, thus: As to your sixth query, Section 58 of the Corporation Code ("the Code") prescribes the

Sec. 58. Proxies - Stockholders and members may vote in person or by proxy in all five (5) years at any one time. meetings of stockholders or members. Proxies shall be in writing, signed by the stockholder or member and filed before the scheduled meeting with the corporate secretary. Unless otherwise provided in the proxy, it shall be valid only for the meeting where it is intended. No proxy shall be valid and effective for a period longer than the

laws can further prescribe additional requirements as to form10, pursuant to Section 47 of the Code. However, Section 58 provides only the minimum requirements for proxies, as the by-

valid for any member to use other forms of proxy as long as it is compliant with the minimum articles of incorporation or by-laws requiring a particular form for proxy, the board of of the Code, and the imposition of that particular form would be void, making it perfectly requirements of Section 58.11 directors cannot prescribe the form of proxies other than as provided for under Section 58 In a long line of opinions, the Commission held that in the absence of a provision in the

1 SEC-OGC Opinion 07-16 dated 13 August 2007. addressed to Mr. Joaquin M. Gonzales IV 10 Section 47(4) of the Corporation Code of the Philippines ( BP BIg. 68)

Page 5 of 7

reason is that though the duration of the proxy may be fixed by its own terms, the Code may be used, but it cannot exceed five (5) years, renewable for not more than 5 years for each renewal. If the proxy does not fix the period, then it expires after the meeting for which it was given. It cannot be used again for a subsequent meeting unless it is renewed. The regulates the continuance of time of proxies.12 With regard to the duration of a proxy, the proxy may fix the period during which it

also applicable to non-stock corporation, states that: As to your seventh query, Section 30 of the Code, which, pursuant to Section 8713, is

to directors by the vote of the stockholders representing at least a majority of the Provided, however, That any such compensation other than per diems may be granted outstanding capital stock at a regular or special stockholder's meeting. In no case shall the total yearly compensation of directors, as such directors, exceed ten percent (10%) of the net income before income tax of the corporation during the preceding year. "In the absence of any provision in the by-laws fixing their compensation, the directors shall not receive any compensation, as such directors, except for reasonable per diems:

net income before income tax for the preceding year.14 is a provision in the by-laws fixing their compensation or when the stockholders representing a majority of the outstanding capital stock at a regular or special meeting agree to give the directors compensation; and (2) such compensation shall not exceed 10% of the of directors can be granted compensation aside from reasonable per diems: (1) when there Under the afore-quoted Section, there are two requisites before members of the board

Directors, Section 23 of the Code provides On your eighth query as to the hold-over capacity of the incumbent Board of

such corporations controlled and held by the board of directors or trustees to be successors are elected and qualified." "Unless otherwise provided in this Code, the corporate powers of all corporation formed under this Code shall be exercised, all business conducted and all property of elected from among the holders of stocks, or where there is no stock, from among the members of the corporation, who shall hold office for one (1) year until the

be indefinite. annual election of directors and officers. However, in case of failure of the corporation to hold an election due to any justifiable reason, the incumbent Board may hold-over their office until their successors are duly elected and qualified.15 Thus, hold-over capacity cannot The Commission has consistently opined on several instances that there must be an

(Davao) Foundation, Inc. corporations, except as may be covered by specific provisions of this Title 5 SEC OpinionNo.05-17dated 06December2005, addressed to Ms.Nelia Estuaria-Tumarao,Secretary to PICPA 12 SEC Opinion 06-16 dated 06 March 2006 addressed to Atty. Anthony B. Peralta I3 Section 87. xx The provisions governing stock corporation, when pertinent, shall be applicable to non-stock 14 SEC-OGC Opinion No.15-12 dated22September2015 addressed to Capt.EusebioV.Perez (Ret.)

Page 6 of

Relative thereto, non-holding of annual meeting for the election of the Board of

stockholder or member may petition the Commission to order the calling of a meeting by the said provision, the Commission may compel the officers of any registered corporation or Directors and Officers without justifiable reason is subject to Section 5 (k) of the SRC.Under association to call meetings of stockholders or members thereof under its supervision. Any giving proper notice required by the Code or by the by-laws.16

Coming now to your ninth query, Section 11 of the Act provides:

the condominium project, the provisions of the Corporation Law to the contrary "The term of a condominium corporation shall be co-terminus with the duration of notwithstanding."

In relation thereto, Sections 13 and 14 of the said Act provide:

Sec. 13. Until the enabling or the master deed of the project in which the condominium Court except upon a showing: voluntarily dissolved through an action for dissolution under Rule 104 of the Rules of corporation owns or holds the common area is revoked, the corporation shall not be

stockholders representing more than seventy percent of the capital stock entitled to vote, if a stock corporation, are opposed to the continuation of the condominium have been met. (a) That three years after damage or destruction to the project in which the corporation owns or holds the common areas, which damage or destruction renders a material part thereof unfit for its use prior thereto, the project has not been rebuilt or repaired substantially to its state prior to its damage or destruction; or units therein untenantable and that more than thirty percent of the members of the corporation, if non-stock, or the shareholders representing more than thirty percent of the capital stock entitled to vote, if a stock corporation, are opposed to the repair or reconstruction of the project, or (c) That the project has been in existence in excess of fifty years, that it is obsolete and uneconomical, and that more than fifty percent of the members of the corporation, if non-stock, or the stockholders representing more than fifty percent of the capital stock entitled to vote, if a stock corporation, are opposed to the repair or restoration or remodeling or modernizing of the project; or and that the project is no longer viable, or that the members holding in aggregate more than seventy percent interest in the corporation, if non-stock, or the (e) That the conditions for such a dissolution set forth in the declaration of (d) That the project or a material part thereof has been condemned or expropriated regime after expropriation or condemnation of a material portion thereof; or restrictions of the project in which the corporation owns of holds the common areas, (b) That damage or destruction to the project has rendered one-half or more of the

Sec. 14. The condominium corporation may also be dissolved by the affirmative vote of all the stockholders or members thereof at a general or special meeting duly called

16 Title VI. Sec. 50 (4) of the Corporation Code of the Philippines (BP BIg.68).

Page 7 of

for the purpose: Provided, that all the requirements of Section sixty-two of the Corporation Law are complied with.

regularly to the Commission are the General Information Sheet and Audited Financial Statements. Please refer to the SEC website (sec.gov.ph), for the complete information regarding the reportorial requirement of corporations registered with the SEc Lastly,with regard to your tenth query, the list of documents that should be submitted

We hope you find these information pertinent and useful

Very truly yours

ChSEA General Counsel