CTA Case No. 1047 (Decision)

~ / . a .I p ~ PHILIPPJN COURT OF iAX APP l4.AN LU 1 � I ion r, -v s- .. c . � 1D47 co .. 0' - ......... - - - - - -~ CI an J'l n of th Co - m1 sion r o () cr 1 forf itur 1 A VO or h . ru n r 519 rto r " - 1 ldu ci I 00 ril 1 , 1 5 on bo 1 oc h c ryd r 1c t 1 � i a tt 1c n p t t.., or th s 1. r 11 h 0 ct ) h Vi 17 0 t i Ot1 c, 10 ' 0 ?U 0 n r t or J lo . :O 86

" / I ... 2 ... L~ ter ., in tb offio of the pat ol div:1, 1on of th Col �ctor of cu to of Jolo , p t1t1on r, r o.r1ng d t ntion , d ni d 0�1n r hip o , th 519 o ourton~ eL h s rr ldl : ci r t~.e � �Io ev r, in a own rsh1p ovar th sa e. t" i e tl 0 ci r tt s 1n u tion r s tra nt .I.I.. ,. Jolo . ~h ~ .zed, p 'W n ith r a Ei t r nr.l 1 po:rt !' in eith 1 or an l. � A ter form 1 h.aring, tho olleotor of Cl ~t s o Jolo ord r th 0 tl Cl. �ar tt in qu t o � P ti io.n r �p 1., to i.one.r of Cu tc s who ffir ed th l.:i C':ion. of th Coll ctor o to ot J lo. h Commi sion :r based hi deer e of forf it r � on r r ph (f) a d ( -1) of S ti n. 1363 of h d ni cd � The v d nee nd r cor how tha p ti on r r 1v d t c a .d a eo cr t 1e �cini n, dat A.ar h 22+, 1961 of th Com eslon�r or Gu t on areh 27 , 1961 . � n pr1 1 ~4 , 15f61, h il d otion or recon -�1' ton 'l ie. d~n1 d. 5 receiv d the ord r of d nial on uri 28. 9 1. 0 pril 29 961, nh po d t t " nil ' ost Offia b re,ist�red nd op c1 1 d l1v ry in..,t nt 11 and addr � s to thi Co rt, th - 1t1o r r view ieh t is Co :r r O ;iVed on ~a.y 3, 1961 . ;o 87

�1 ? ' .. 3- in 1 b r ol d in 18 c whe b r or ot t c1 r tt s in qu t on bj c to +"orr 1tu � ( o n , hi or u , t t .. pr p tit o for r 11 0 hirty- y rio in et on 11 of publ c c o. 11 '� 1 cru co 0h i thi ea 0 t p titione son ly !11 d r t1 1 fo r on umed o ly n y- in of t th rty d 2?' 1961 'W n p ti of r on nt 1961 !il d h otioo or r con 1 ation, 2 ha � It e o ly on y 1' th h c iv h tion to r t n, o p rP 11- 1 g (.r 1 t r .d th t tio for r v 0 ' 1961. l r cei t 1 is d 1n i ut d ( ~ otto ..ul of Cour , � t rn q ip n t~ .) 6 11. { ) c now to th in :t � rr (f) n ( -l) of S cti n 1 63 r th vi ed i 1 r tiv . Co , u �h c1 h 88

". �CISlO cc o. 1 7 - 4- ... r J. j r of h . ~t l" ) ~~ - ju r ' f-i ev~ d Q X r tb 1nos- ch i' " thr. no p ,f: ' r 1 nrf�t te .. p t th ci-� r . t: c r o y out tl Fh:tlinpin ' h r� e ul~ . ot n 1.oportation or tt pt of 1.r- or r ub c . t ' to torr ttr nd ... th ~,r it " 89

.. �7 - 5- 0 r (f) ( ~1) of c o 1363 of i Co � 10 n hy

... t. 0 I : ' �1 � :!.1' ' � ~ c (.) ll. .:. .. J h led tfJ t1 C ut "-- . Jr ~i . c) � y i.h~ " .....J.. :;....~ ..). t 7 ~) ~ ulrl 0 )(: fJ ., " \ .. Hr ~ !' 91

� D Cl 10 c� c s � 1 7 - 7 .. r 1sr t nh - (e1 ) ( 1"1 t � � � f 125' ' .. ""t � _40, 31 L cr ,y .,., ... ~ a 11 .... ',... � - � .! 6 , 6 " 7; ' yr ,.;C s rt 1 ' ' 531 t 7) n ., by 1 .~..., 0 .a. 1 :l 6 t tj , ... ..r:. r...r 10 cc (j t: e ,_ h ub 1 r:; .. r ' � ll, C!" t nc io t y 1 nt c � - t1v 11 0 ci ar tt cul ' r -- -� - . �� 9 2

Q � .� .p . -� . , -o. , 7 -- 0 lr { 0 �h 11 in � I 0 CO ID 1 � ' r h If , 1 6 � 11 t .lf 93