CTA Case No. 2157 (Decision)

/ 'lEPUBLIC OJP THE PBlLIPPINEe COURT OF TAX APPE.ALI QUEZON CITY /� -- t c. � � .� 1 )7 f r1 .~8 I 11' - - - - - - ....... .... .... ... ... ... .... .... . or � t "o:~ ~;z... .. t: 1n n Pt"' .. na,l .; ~ ~..3 ' jt.J4-. ew n ">' .. 1 n " y 7 19��a, t;'l' .. ., vad ~! $, ~tu 'l~ s X ( ~ ) i .ric , i' 183

t� ' (" ) t .. '"tOt al nt '0'' �:. 1. 5o t- t <. � t 1s �t I .... ' 1. 3'. , .. r� ~ ., ~~ 18 4

.. J �� t ' ... '( . .... ��~ ~ examiners and ~. . .. ��~ ../ !.,; ,�~ 185

�� ..... ..... . . o.. ) to � t o.: , l < J j) 18 6.

tt i 187

.,.,,.,. . t; � � � <.' � � t , ' 188

- 'i !.i'�� ~� t 189

1 P,"'&1 nt�s: ~:i;tfki - t V4 :'3- $" ' ., ;!SOO*oe�. ��t,oo �.o �n~ , a, )_. oo Ji~l' b,.otu,. f.' . bnpoa.a v.� � . �a-n� v . f.lllowlti ... d t �. !.;l.;.~nl."!l d tii.l .if'r~: -. ntho� ~~S.n,jfn� ita a. p r ,. 80~$ d.. 'Ql.oo � � ...1!1 ,3'71� 00 ,. b. ot~ -, a. * :r iP ./~t''lifl1~tf'.u.t.or �s �� � ~uetttm .... , � .. � � l , &>o. o� l � ?ov ~ed :$f ual-<! , L t.u.~-a Q a. ll~u1o !;n ta.vor ot .;~ra~o ~~~ . :'iatt:ld fi"Ct. -~ a19_!_1.9� ,1o<tct�t-a!t�.,. s.t C41 _ u an t n~J\ ~ ,_i l (!Jf . .. It � ,. �.J!! � 1fi � � �~~~u.;~ :v~ras~ � � � � � If � � � � .f2tl.2~. cQ pe~ h~ctar 'D "-~ t tu: 01~~ i�;1.(,-~t Q�"'� f.(lt" dAl'el~tt':."'atton, t~ . -l< 1Uf:11tJ;(;U1 !;s. h~l" . l=l' Moptt,ih 1$ t. �Old..~� � � � t � �.fat ~ u. CO PGt' rc c � t'~ 2r..d '*' -� .- it2100(J., CC . Olf1,\.$S .-. � -. iJ fl , !}(;,()� ,)~ 3 tl � . '� {,t cltliS.G ct � * Of the ~*'CO J! d in !\lr.:s . �t Bs:te~�t t~ !nV�S t!J;a't.1r.t:~ r �.an ~3 ~~~~tr~J:H" 'GOPd�'tct~! !l oe~~~ ltt$ .~"tt-o-n thtn~� oi�.. ~ ., '"~a~ t.! .r~ � ~Y ra~t<>:r~ tn ~r1vUt'l� ,,. t �tho or t Lr st:"Jtr~t�Jt 'f.il � � ;;., -.rtGn 1-o ,n-$ 1n q..lO!~ ~t.r~n, rut.mtJly: � � hiJth~t'* th~ r~rtll or tb~ tisrtpond.s ro - =to~p o � � ~ .� 'llc;twt. pt,Jcie o V04"acio~ li$.h w'i:t1eh c �t)pct~a _,� wt~.fi th - ~ i:U ... t ,. t {b~.r:;.;� } ~n ��afi!;~ U1.�d.Jl~ t �~ toed ot~ �e.~ l.~tt� anlt , tb!:Jte::: �f.!'tt t t'>t m.p�,;rg ttl 1:� l"'�~th . th~~ fit'~u noe of s � t � ta"s � fta at ~~~ ,,:)�b~.. � n.,;~ u ln the t~L.~hbt!n;~!� oo~,; t 13 � 190

� \. ... 0 � � � .. t � � '' ' 1t - � 191

... - � 192

. . � ��� � ,�. �� '� � � � $p:la t~<llll;r pt.-~ i<JF~ '' a $t ondo �lu 1 t /%:, t f I I l?a:/~ nt i rtt ~!.~ . Is ... lt- or . n t ..� � �� 193

� , I - ' t .i ~' 19 4