CTA Case No. 1401 (Decision)

....,.. REPUR(.JC OF THE PHILIPPINES ('(1t : R.T OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY ---- - . - . .. h i .10 �f f n� ,, 0l � 1 ~. �i �n ..oun 'in 9. � O!l)~ive 0 1 te, t~ t . 1 ~� is . . ,. L.iru' lnc . ��n Pac� � c T � 1.. n �� h ,t y l " �l~� ri t1: � ~ � l i" of eo ol .- t c 't � i f :!l ial �.. u w 1. ca4 � ( li~ h . ,�� f J � ' 161

l:i.J.t ~ ' citS ~4 � J., 'i 1 �Y t t, 193' t �l!)l�6r (b). �� lt } i y .a.t: V f n n � Th f.li t"' l.t" and d iel ' el 10 th y0 over f 1 .. .. �� 16.2

... l -- � n fil nc .... c ne t 'PO t�d ..n .t�in a G I I op .t 5 of � c .' l �~ . I1 . ' v ar-el . �fi$�;, ."' I. 0. 1

�1 -- � 1� - � 71 � - n 1 .7 .~ 4, � n c n 164

i� -. - i 0 ( � ' � 165

.... ...... l � �o. 1 ol . ') L th r 11. f i �' ht N�t1Vi d it of � xclu$1on f 'tim � ti loner� � .ro �s. . nc � � an l � o llQw � a.s patt of p t, ton .t' s '"�o l � e � u je t to 11 a i n n .i it in it (l j 0 c;:l ' z sult.l 9 0 �ensyl� �" - .a. , 7t. , � � 3� () -.';. '� (j() () t 1 9 i s lo 7., 19; '! t66

167

� - T nc ud � � X� .1 � 0 n~r ,.,. 168

' . l '. .' c a � � ( �~ f!. . .. " .,. � � � 17, .) ly J 19, i �. fo low l 1 ........ c l L"'::;::::;:::::::;: ) h th l' ox c *"' U.i � itt: . 0 c I~ } of oth .. ,7 169

- .. v ju ; 0 1 1 .. 1 n 0 t c1 1 � -. 7 01 l� 17 0

-1 � 1 I cT � � � � ��� � 1 n � in � !� 171

l� 1 () 1 n c f: , 't l it.i.O X h � ate l ly n 1 om the!' d :tlv �~ th Fh 'tl y ~ .... ~ s ,, n al oc 0 n� - v w1 �n n � pi c; a h& v. {.;! . � 0 toal n� o. .t..77, 1. �� y v. � c:il �1 ,. J � f!' 197 �� � .a~ o. l~ ""' ; i /I. 1 . � Q 0 � ., � 19 \ �l I� 172

f' � l 1 - 1' � X0 ~). (;! c i $ an ne f 'I :r; in s .... t � .r� P� "�$; st h I'GCtt P.tj]; h: ill /i. { 1 CJ e n 1 . � ) ...,f. a� 173

� .. l � f 1 � f1 ()" � � c.. � c ( t t � � � .f n it: c i ... t .&1 I�ithin i 1 il ..omtni$S10 (! & &.aid ina o al 1 d at � !� 17 4

� l ,i 175

n a all 176

l � 1? ... c b in l .t n o� - r n en d f ... () ..tp � p� f1 � 1) � � � � �� n� 0 0 ' d $ s0 iu � ,&. 0 n / cl � '� / 1 i. 0 0 ' i0 c 0$ on ) n t � � � h y� c i~ 17 7

� Ol - c of i e n � .. .. .. � " � J c c ""''l � � c n � ne � 5' � d .... ~9 � ~.. l i .. 'ti ( f 0 f n �� $ i t l, �II c c .. h1 e .en l c h� f d 0 i jl t78

�l l .. y � .�. 1 � 1 � 0 s c � � 1 c � 0 � .._ l ..... -1 nl -

t � ~0 ' r, � 1 y p� ..1 � � � .. ~ 180

no v l u 1� i , � � � � C: ft j; �18t '

~1n � p t"E'S V j o nd e u� � � F~TI itG � ) ii" lly of ou ' 0 ".".. O:e ~- n n of ' �1 the t ' y I;~ c:h ... i ..il t r ur " u � � .. � � (lJ).� 6 eh l.1a.r1tteit /\c 193 � . �1 � l � -::t c . ; � L� � 1 (LX � u t % 1i in v ... ppl'ova of - 61:' l 1 Q� ". 0 t c purp xh. ) rnin a 1. to ll - na$ uj e nc t unt l ~'~fit Efin foz - � u~o t ti � .: � o�e.ratton. ~xh . L�l, e ~� rtf t h) .ia 11 n i it f 1- t r 1 8 2 il . ,...,

� t �� � l h - � � � � .. J. �- 0 n � e � ;I 18 3

ltl � ct, f� d tl Q � 1 0 xem .. o 11 f � �.t ~. ~. ( �C 1. ' Cl\ ft in � � o. 19'� ~.� \..X � L� l � 11, '"T I Q � nb ho t f v t'\ JO fl t nn~ i..,u p .rt a i zt :l'�1 1 t "�-e in :19. � .�. �e iJ1 t~ t for ~� '5� (!\ 0. ctel �.,.�..r.td .t xp. . 9 �. .. . �14 fr in '"~ l l i f.; ~ CJU � Je;ti.t.!onrot'"" opexc1tion in thE ,Jb P.P ne <ts. lte,., .i � . ... J'l lti� (j ,: 1~ . ' J.n 1'5 c a!J ell ; � 1 '.18 � . ) 1 )p �:til ifi9 .t!; "~ i 184

"-:-or 1.1 pp n oc Tax . c� z.e~: 0 l.Lf .. tl50,86 . 7 PC> t L� ' �xpen i } i l,o �r f i .u <. � flc . , n y .l.ll "" ~ nt &'" 1 tt y nc ll n fi � ' ith- u~zcn _, t ~-/~0'2/Z~.c fj� ~--~~- 185