CTA Case No. 364 (Decision)

.. . . ' ~ �.,t'h !.', . OP � .. )t;<' . TH'l! lA' UPl lP. ! .Rl "lU' f . N~ I !J ' .' � 'fAX 0F &UNU...t .. ' .�,,, , 0 h ir f\~'~-t' - SI I ~ - c . r. � c s � 361+ vr u ,po dent . X� � - � - - - - w ~ - X .c1 l u a n ap 1 by p 1 io r t u l ~ . 0. t on or he s t na io l in dn, fro th cision o� r Coll oto.r ( o 1 .� �io f I t rn 1 8 tat ot aid th r 1 / f 1946 ' 'jQ 19 �? 1 th n 0 '135". �'3, 11 2 6 . 9 1, r :p h0 in 30, 1 95~ il 15 195? in t o "72 .77 an eompro 1 pen l t1 s o 1 !'111 � n - .d (3) rG 1 quar � � o 0 19 �.o .; nd '+t�. ' �; (r,) 5� or 19 6 nd h 19' 7 in th 'fL 1 1 n h a u 0 inclus v or c . r 2 .o � Ori in 11 h r an h ir ich $ >~l -.th r or o h r 401 .

... 364- ?. 0 Coll tor (no. Co mi � 1 n r) ot In r 1 a nd coll -et Q\n t of t tan i " n t s rt, 1 u �t 3' , 1 ~58 , ..1 ld that s i ly, t.4 l from r ... t a 3o!n d rro e e ll 0 c .. thr� i su d in l u ntly, spond. n 1 .r "' e1 0 �� C urt whicl ra ~r ed our d ci ion insof e on o ~he cell ct o of i-nc-o -� t o! 1 7 n 1945' 1 (G . rd � of th e o u for' r r r ~roc - 1� Oour , h h 1 t�d c eiaio w1 .h t r th t id nc � 1n cor , ro i ues l t ct.s p rtl en '!I t t s ollo t ~1 0 2

3 on y 23 1 1 5, rviv by b1s w ow, 11 1 � i .fte n ( 15) childr n .1 on o 1 t , on 0 rn it7 of t a. 'I 1 � nt of ate I ug t 301 19 5 in tb n1 � ur a tr - inc t t roc / � onduct � ta or r t 1r1 t h e tat � c/o es lu:r 1 ) ., whic � el n. ~ti- , �� eo 1 ar � r r ... - � � � 1,722. 7 di - 2 .- . . .-- . � 2 2 port d 1+6 ' 403

-o. J64 . . !ni.st io 500.- �� not ��� . . � � � � .. � � br reb r. � tal due a t� x (S � 11t, P� 1 , I � � c�r -� � � 708 . 1 6. ' . 3,0 . oo ����� � 1,ooo.oo ��� {$ e �� d"' t 1 r por p no h record 0 th d" le r cord ot oth 0 ce nd i 0 tX ur 0 h f1 't .g. on An ust .!'.: 4, 1953 (Exh � 2- and � P� nd ., 4 I r r sp c iv ly) t for th '1 d 19 � . 404

DC - c r pond n � 1 o s est r l st t d l t . 1x .x f'or h 4th qu rt or 19lt6 d b. l ol 7 r o:t 19 7 d r s14 ne t fo t lle �� ne a�x� �� 405 -

,. - cD CI . 36 6 eons1 .f h 1 1 cont s co � t1t1 r t t t c f. e .. � li a� l .... 1 t - -~-�� �----~�~--- d Y~==--L.~==-=...:=--=-=:.....:.:=-.::..::=...::::_____ - -- & --~~>I."'.U � t � tt. 1 1). :1 1 y 1r r by t ot t is cont ntio 1 on t d due 1b1 t OJ' J1tlf.-JecL!t/tf,1 �1 fk� iff.jc,t.Je . c!tillm {/'th --"##c. . .... .. 406

- .,, $ 1 ' t , ' c. 2 7, ' 1 � ; �� � �, 2 407

CI8IO ... ~c � 3611- I c rr Co 1 n r. 1 I 31 ro � I $21.)rl to h l lo d b1' onde ., 1 � o.-t. b :i!"o.inc �J ( on rrat � c lli or, c. � � c 11 9 D � au, 1 55-> It 1 - st d 1 p: t1t1.on r t t th ur- sou t c ll etc � 1 eo qu n ot w. :1th th1 ion 5't( e ) of h X t l th e:sta o; 't ,~ s 1 r t :to 11 q 0 t in � h eo x.J 7Anont X1 t e so 1 th ineo e o� th est d riv t:ro t 1 � r al ro rt � , p 1 io ' rgu ha th ta canno held 11 b1 on th round that 1 t i not per o a not 1 t' l �� t bu 1n th t a a p 10 n h, j 1r1d1c d in 1 xi�tenc ls ithou u.e tic � And th fact that sol 1 �c r1 408

� 364 ;, 409

4 " \ t . . . ~ ... ~� I . \� .. .\ ....... t . !.;~. . jf) tb 1 n , wit o p o:i 1 a to o .. I co c I ,, 410 �