CTA Case No. 226 (Decision)

��� �? � c ' � � I �

.. 2 ... .e 2. 1 t 1 .1 "� �<~�- ... .'. ' ,. 2 'I"-! ') ""'

.n~.ci~-.J/ . ~. i ~ .... {;~ . J\.. .ffJ: ~~ l i(: .. 2?6 ... ~ cn:e t iul._ ... .-..vi � � ., ' �~ :l(:h t:'U� �;hit)s~ . 1. �r:d t J " .: .l t 'tf~~ ;;: ~.; ;;. ~. )ll.~. ... ;e 1 t: ""C , { o:r 'l!~ VG r :� I y?. ;:- t'�; ~ rl or tl.o :t~;-to" ��nrt corrtiflt.W�J~~l" up tr.:; tnt;? p~~F!:;e;;�t tih~t t~18 t<tr::.eien�:!?"t rc.:r.tur\�~ f l1~til: bevn rlovc'tod ) i~;!P~lly to t. � r- ~o ~ueti t,;n "f ~a�0~n~ �~� 27 3 L .. itt bt ,

.. � � ...... � 274

) �. ..!''� �{ r :.' - j ~~� �~ . "" (~i' r; .,:;. llC. ~ I 1 � 275

I � ., ... ----- � � - � �� � 276

J J ..,t' t ...... r. L 1- - � i u �r- � ... � t f c 1 � ... l"� ) I. � t H ;i.� ~ � J. t lO -c: � �

t � - � '� 278

. ,. t'4t, .. .. n ,, 1 l. � l 279

I .. ~ . 11 ot - i c 280

- � nv lv � ' t. .~ �n t . ct. � 7 � d i:J. t t� c ,. 281

.. .... ... l �1 � ... - � � " � � u J t 1 � 282

t (. .c.u - ,-. . .l of ati .) t ;cJ 1 �x i �y � h :c� .~ r l"'=""' 11: ;. \'> 7 t :, -� . .~ r, �. ... ,.., l ... -r- n c l. "i�� �. 1 ~ >(;' i .l(l \ ro - 283

~ ();..;,(: l "' 6 { . ..&. ,) -l I ~' j c: n,t � i � t 1 et (;C' � ll i -I . l ... t ... .. 1 . c � t .. ' l � �.n, n �n

.J.p �. - J ly t:: i 1 wa ct' i. ttl 1. . Y� -. � v� l.l 285 L

... o11f. f � �~ J n- "ts X'f.h i � - i i ~.. $: l'~� ttn~r for th ~:r.v to. Ju1y r<f th t:rnt i. en t:h ~i:~1tu a \)a:: t.n.~ r~ hip o Yt:�~ 1' will d~t t ir b' l i t Y :f ~-- 'in~t l9l"'t1 � )~ '\ti:ulltl I I l ' ' ~i.\ ' . J rt 0 . j ~b;� th12> :;...;].cr i!l' nc:l.�}�L:r� ;::. t .hat. :.,.. '"�t .:rb.At f 286

� {.C I� ~- ~ c.. r. r'-� t,;; __ ('� ~ i"le. 2?.6 ... - 7 - 00 r l"" , ~ r. ' t~ . tax- !"fiti' o,.; i I!! .. n i J'." d 1: t a h ~ t.l ny h, i i di �.. r d tl n l t .~:rtn u.,..s city. ......... n �t .,. wncn t t -Mt 1Q t r1 JUuici� 1 p l.' ... o� � �t c c vt~~ . .. 1, g v-v~rnJ.r, <J g.. r (;t .+r t f<,ed i .,,r e '>}'~ ln ,. ,, ~ 1\ ;t: t:lc �. \f .~~\~C . I t i '� '); '.~i L.t ~t -~ . ~r�' c- n int ; l�g .:~<1' L: ... 287

... ... � �s lJ ~ ��� 1 ~. �� < 1' 'I 'Y � ( � J' ��e r . 2~>':1 ; .; .r. q '1' 1 ... s- ,(;, ti.l\1.!~ ' t . t' 1 1�-h c . :l.t ln .., ::;:' i z i ~1 '." nt�l��.c ~\ t~ t ' r- ~ v� . iu . l' t :t'() � l . "" ira . r:'!ti . i . .� 1C !....4 � }p nt 9Q\ n .... j<1 ~tur ' n �~ .~ � ~n c ',l. h v � i.~ 'I 'L .;. ( l~C t? t. '-:) � 1.. 28 8

........... PU61.1C OF TI'ffi PHII.JPVlN ' Ou.RT OF fAX APVEAl'- I.ANU...& t� � .~,.;; . ... - -- I 1 t - � � � i � t, � � 289 "

.. ..: ~ - f h p t 1 c .. n� � � l � � J �-uz. n 1 c ct 'o 1. v t t f1 t t 290

-" - t 't . u. t pr~t ... fJ Mav f� t\ n -e e '1: .. -~ou~ ~ h.il ppit o- . st. � ... ance ($ a �.pu l. ~ 0 t.h L 1 {.) :i. JU .. s. f 1959). .u. t . iV fol �.1 t �' ~ /1! b� tiC t . tha " or � f t ":((>!... i 1 {'; COi.l;t-t 11 c � ~ .;,1 f r t . ' �' 11 . -nt did I t } . statu+or,, porto of fiv '\1'1!' wh h t JU 0* J: c 1n t'� hav ~.n f:Utrd And if� h in p � \'lhiGh 1 C . ju of al � � � 2 91

-- v. .�. .' " - ,.... � I'!; l , 9 ) .. .....~ . t � l~ r t� 292