CTA Case No. 9 (Decision)

..... , 1\ilWliBLIC OP THE PHILIPPIN.ID COURT Of l'AX AP.P.EA.LS NANIU - - -- -... �� � 465 u < ...

� � � - � 466

. .... ... �

� ,, 468

' 469

� � tl7 0

...... � � 471

� l \ � 472

� ., 473

. � tl :J cf 47.4�

47 5 v)

' 476 4 'l

� V1 ta � unt 11 � 1 ��

t 478

479

� ei~ht 28 480

'. t 481

~ ,, . .:� ~ ... t .� �~ ~t 8 2

�1 � :,f_' I !} 8 3

�.a J.

�

z;. te 486

.. � � � ~ %' v � 'f'i I c p } ...... , 487

.., .... ' .. ~ 'i � !18 8

489 II

on � � 490

491

L}9 2

� -

� � �� � � � '"�'r " t 494

.~ - �~ liiii!!;Pli.I:SL1L Of! THE PHlLl.t"'PIND C.OURT 01- L\ X APPE.Al.� MANILA !I I " ' � - � � - - ~� ~� ~- X .. ' 1� .1 7 ", 495

\; \,>:,, S. th �t' "i~ ,.j .�....-4.1 ~~ ,. l'f ,:, ff \.i< "<;f <~ h,~ i r�~~n � .!ts;. ~.~ ,_ .: I 'f .f ,; ' , .;.. :: ( '\ ~ lt.a. 'l� �": 1 ' -i;.~ : '''f ' rl ('~ t" Ll9 6

.,. ... . � ~ ~ ��' I '< .r ~- :-�i I ~ ,; '. �'~ �a:� ., 497

... .. .' 498

I' .... .. ""�� 499

J, , ~� s�.,. . '" f- . r (. ( ( ~ i;{" "' :1 ,- ;e -. t ,~l � \"' t-- fiJ.l l J.' n 1.� 500

... ,.,. ~}