CTA Case No. 2630 (Decision)

REPFR� IC O"F THF PHILIPP Nl.!.b ( llU ' t TAX .\PPEALS ou~ .zoN en v -- .. 03 '1 t u~ ' t p - 1 l ! n- 1 s tf - nt . p fr f () - t i t� t ~t1 {for. 0 p .) 0 11 t ... ~ 0 l, r 0t 0 .l � �' P -~) a 209

.. 6 ... ... op r u ous o .. - t� c ... td 'h or C I'C f � 1 tot 1 d XC g. ' if " T 0 f ' t to 0 � ~r � ~ .i. rn r :r .� 0 h,., . (. ~ . ')10 r-.J

� ,C t! I O � 'c � -- t1 0 r 1971 r ~n . h . .. ....... ' b ti n t <? ~ CC>r( for rn l v u l7 r � oJ io on h QU t- ~l t hori y � o. � c il'l 27(h) of hr.- " 0 it r w 7 r s, ' t n1 b s0 nt . ul of t ,.. n ' i �pon� t ' ;ort 196 t 1, l 7 0, p . " 1 t 0 t r tor of olf c uri" nr r f'!tat.., on I. l 1- of c nd r c0 � 611 � s :.ST�7 ... t 197 J n t0 t or ""h 0t t .9 r x flr 1c v ,3 c n1 ' 1 cov in: a ol� 1f 211

� - -- ... ��� � � .7 ,? .~' 0 � ... � � � c� � � 1 175. 7 -� � ��� 0 11� ]_ � 3� l 6,52 �

.... o� � A� � � �� . 96 l3LE � � � � � .t 0. ' 73, ,....,..,.. .1 itl - D in lb.~; . tt .... hi d r by 1' a� l~t r t u.u 6 , 1' 71+. ' o fi t r spond t' ni 1 t io r ap l d 0 o rt 0 ;. 9'74. r on l. s t' y p .t1t1on g.in c $ dr 2. t t 0 f'. t og d . .ss; 3. 91- a 0 d by h~ � t 0 .r ct n ct t X l t ll 0 in of i c p .f b , oh .,. ft r .4. ' 0 nu c on i t f'irs t::ll j(lC ( t r .. nt n ""t 0 r cto s 0 213

tox o .� 11 rh f l ,, s t r.<p r . �v ~ :J: ii r d r J:.- � 1 ,� L'Jl nr r ll a- i t'"l h1 .. i O r l; n � r ' ~ '" cl -r our 0 �':& t c , th 1 t ') ~t II ,,. - - JL

.. 7 - o rh.a n .. n to i pr v th eb x fol o : 215

�6

-. ; - � -. t ot r

63 ... t ' �i bt 0 th 1 1. / c8 l 1 1 of t b 1 Co .,.. l . t ll c i io r� Pb1l1 t 1 tt r b eet t th i d bu � t 0t ~� th. � t to � vi i tl"" 0 t .ati�� .. 3 { X � } c ll XI 218

..o. I I 2 \.. CA' - t ' � 0 n. r 1- () () ') 'l 9 f.,.J -' t

.. 0 - ... l () e :r . ( ch h bu T :ill a -r r . r~ 1�~ ~ t 1' i ' 1 a.pp v � t llo 1 i ... tr 0 t 1Y h=J bill r ts t 1 Y<> ~ . � . � 17

': � 63 - 13 .. ' 1 1 to . ' (o. 1?8 10 . eo ( �.,G � ) h ( 1-.. ..II ' � il ) �. 221

... l~ - t th v0 0. t (t. � � b to � c rt 1 t h :xt t nr1u'11nt ~0 b ' ti cti 191- � rrt $ tb tit 0 1t1o 191- ely v toe t d, tb nt i t out 1 b 1� th ot u .... id ct1 it � ti t t "1 th t0 20 c1t or o to ' :r r t b r c - e tr t c ic r in 1t 1t ot l t otel 0 . () t e !'i n t a it i b.t rt th ev lo e t o h t ls cb r .... tlal to 1 t u t � or t e 1 n. - t1o st t r th Co itte () d of t for er ot re e � c ncurr wit it t1 t 1 t� 'hot t1 d d 2 ') ') - (-v~ /~ �-�

.' � - 15'- a1 � 1 t sy 8 t t l t1 lac � al rt t 1t � 1 t t 0 t '1 l ?, 11 ( � )I 223 ,.

.:, .... l .... e d f ry ..�.ou .. , ' Jtan� <> � 9?2 . c rti �� t �on pro~ n c .1 c~ . �o (l of t 1 res1( ent ~all ~d i .io !J . .i�l ' c r 1'1�3 ' t�o 1 ;(' hat on ��t o f \ ' bill ro . b ,.;;. h t n~ �l c ch- of a s :.~nr' h ct -�S t c cu wit by t chai � n,. ~o l i tin: u.,. c es t th t only h 0 .. . I ot 1 , +:el ~tho s 1 d 1 f 1~ 't ' � .... 7, l r co:rd) , t be �.V f h~ th":! orr ...... c m..

- 17 .. _or r t 1 t. r ctio 20( of 15 t .0 t nl t !" id: . t et ill r y rat 0 i� n n :rif bill � hc tio of 1 42 t 111 � l 739 w r er h ta f 1tte of th r 0 1 s th t nl th \0 . s ~hot t tel r oul b d let d alt ou the latt r tb si of ri t et o . 611 � 2 . s 0 t's h n1 t rd h tel , ot 11 E t e- tion 191� in .rte ~ by � 17 t 1 ~ itiv ly ~th ut o 1 b sis. 'd t 1\ th r id t ' v to es 0 ly t t"ds '�hot 1 l, r ~ .... QU If 1 ' .ct o 191� i rt d v to by th resid nt. t u t do, 1 ite o v to or eot.. o 4. ' s to I � b only th o d n t lt otel9 rast- ou li e delet. d n t . tha eti n 1 ot v o d. I t d r s1 ti �1 ) 1 t t t d 1 te only the ot 1. ot l r stho s 1 to Se tin 191- .t h 1 nt .oUld

� ')f. 63 e sily d(J :l so bt si� ly st ti ' .i bi. ve,t,o m �a:.> t ~ tlP h tel , , o el , r .s ti.ou jn 1on 1 1- .r v cr ' e... e. "' on�~ ._ il. r .� h t t is .. urt c t ov r 0 lt ' ~ �:ion 2C , () - t h 193? :o st; tic �h' 1hil �h .:. r s n~l t �t . u �101" 0.$ h as � hf!'!... 1 0 . �Lc or.r ctl '!'0 n d 0 "b r~~aoti ion� t h ul .(." 11 ~ . t .i on tu ':i.(' � 1 0 j ~: 0 t ,:m ..r 226

c. � - 19 - l it us 1 10, 12 31~} fb e1 11 ,9.,., 27

o.� 26 0 �- ill. c t l"' 1 t t i t v t or d l c r 1 bill r in ' tio v nue o t r1 i l l. ll t could t to a d . nt w ie 1 t co .... t lat d l" v ot it ,, prov th ' . h h 1 :l 1 ,, t if 11 r "' rn it d hi j ct o s t t e u hr t �(f, 4. 1ne t a ted ab v t tn .ffic o'f* th si t h onfi 1 t s et1 o. now ubl Ul "''7i 9- ~t-~�f R 611 M. . . . 0 Q� c 191- a one of t ~ ction v o - th t 1 hi eto e s t t 1969, v t 1 c ta1 ction of tb ( � ), 1 be n h th t b r to s 0 rri by the r-auir d n ber or vot 111 ro id 1 ctio 20(l) -rt cl I t o t _ 1 wtion. 1935 c t se do ot how t t two-thir of Con e s voti.n e a re d t v reo h P esid to r � es nd t as n t v t he r i d ' v t 1o c sol t d r ill as ov >ri lll1 r o� vot f veto bill � I s u b 228

�6 he 1 t 191- 1 �1 l � '0 ' 1 1 l� ' () t l I rn l iV ; . ot sc tn lc 1 t () 1 it1o r t 1 il 1t t t 1 so 1 th nt oul.d t to opo 'P Vi of r v � 1 ill hieh 1 not ol 1o '- or t �� ia t a!fo ... if t t ss t d u a tr in d 0 1t rV1 0 l'"V ue 111 � ic s to h t. 1 1o t t: ff � u ' o. 1871 0 se ti e t � 611 c . 1~1-� t- w ' t n 11 1,? f' e .. 2 ') 9 w f-...J

�6 -2 - t o, 977. I c:i. t 230