CTA Case No. 1942 (Decision)

'lEPUJ\UC OF THE PBILIPPINE.I' CO UltT Q-F T.AX A~PE.A.LB QUEaO.N QT'W' ..'), �\ c1 1� n of 1 c- 0 s it ord th ':l ,� ... ne � cr . , _ .. f. 1...~ , one of' whoni r ar:i �r � 2 ' 1967 ' j lv �s l'i 111 �1

tr., . i .. r e�. � .t r 2

� .::J. ., �� })0 1 r t 0 ..... h r 0 a .1 ,. ,. ic r ir t. t v n 4pr .d 1- tl� d or t (!! C,ll~ t ( t'r .. t tr. "f. t . on ill'd t;:,o rr:-.v � Ut r. t 1 r 19~" t r 0 n<= t hv o� s Jj ct t pen en t 1l t.t

��~C S cT c, a ~o . t942 . . � !:!~ of' th pl~ -i gs and c.u t m r-cor ( ;p � .- t . s . . ; � 25, Cl r ) Th. sole i ....s i vo v in this case 1 w t r or not t j i t .ney 1 que~rtion s su j ct s ollow ; .... - c un~ r th af r , oted ...r �Visio of law two ( ) co. d~tion .S to j ify the for- f it re or ' otor v icl n ely: ( th t he .. ctor ve icl rl . a.ctually u c1 n . co veya . oe o r iol s ubj ct to o fe tur�. un r th T iff ntl C'u t � s La� t:l ; . nd ( } tx �e th o er of h 4

-�.' ... ~� f~:'' ll~l ... C , CA.::�� ~ () ., 1 . ti."" � !t i - to Cod � � o tus 1 it ollo 5

r:e..: nr) - e�, ; c .: , . ,� 19 ~ ' 6 v y 'lg � 1;u s al n th Ot � �es Jtrrmary t rne i w ~ a~.re~c dnd, it� w a c ,s .~a .. d V'C~; , 1 o ll s .ul r t t' ( p. 1 � ; n� � 17 Pt . f:-r "t Vi w)� ha t Jr.. .... 1' 4.1 .0 t ... y fr 1t � -� o t' r 1 th t, ol'" 1 . ot a 1 .a 'I 1J ...? . <p, 1;i, th v� !13 u ctio~1s to ' -~ ll driv no to .e J1tn. !J 4 1lf: 1 (S 16- 1? \.. zto� r,co . ) . r e .b1. a v;� c 1.1 r . �n ; �1..... 11, Ci t y, to� e r:1 o 1e ' 1) ox t . �t. r-� r ct�v� t .:1 1 h . c . c. .t illt:'d ( ts, t 1 th . ..flt11.,.J 6

Hll f!O 12', fMt� �-1, t3.one:r it 1 1 or th~ ct~ of !tL dr V(!'r,.) �n<:'-. r 1mi lar t...ti'Ct t.S 1 ~ovlrc:~<r'~'l''e lt,_ t!� i.S .':'JtU"t h :Id :to t~i.e eatte f ~ ntonio ~~ � V � vic! ~n C"" l?ld-dt~C(;! dta~1 a~~ thE. t.t~ l' ~- 1 Sht.1d 7

D?l.t l J:%J~l ... ~ �1. CA.. ''t � � � 1 'h 1! l 1 t ... 1rt pu ll � �

I 1 n t' . o� . -I rli ~ t � y \.1 ! 1 n l 1i t G 1t r '"' ~ f b,c lS'J~ r ul 0 ~ '� 0� ... 0 .. -g

. ....�. no r

1 I � Costs ag inst petitioner � � � � � 11