CTA Case No. 2149 (Decision)

& ... Hf-:1'1 ~\1,YC OF TilE PllTLIPP!:'<ES �7 CoL: H 1' OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY ~IDY w � , t ; . T.A. Ct\ � ~14 .v .r , s - J. C: r L ~t,s-l:;v -- - - - ond � X . - .. ... .... ... ... t. l. hJ. 1 n f h c 0 f yl t r on f .a.n<: l t 7 . ,;7 -s n� r po a i n in h' n c UI n n i 1h at 1 f 1, � n J' l 5, co �let 0' c 1y n lt ... ni ni h 7, a ing x. n Jn � n tho c jc c ni tX 'ti 11 1 ., ec on lt in J.a\o c. ~ ' i n r f i<; nc in Xn u, v ..) 7 . ';)7 � ';,.), (p 2 ~"'"'j' l '

u -~ ..... - - n r t d Jun "~ � 1 7 , p titi n rot n� u 0 cou i Y r on p p a1 �ni 0 t n ly 1 � n o. 7 � un � n y ~o. l 7 f r J:i 1 0 th r , r. .r d ci . l. - iss in a % l ac 0 dlC c 0 on h id .I t ad y t n rn y .I I lt d y1� 7� on n r r"' d y u0 'h 7. 7, - iciency c arnin s n i t on r y r c i t of , h t X ul .nf .IC d ht u ovi y 1t rc v y iti n 0u 0 J1 , ~ 1 7 , h in n a p a t � 1 9. n �17 � n d . die on , is 0 c0 11 n no y t r f n1 ci on on 0s f i � n ov � b r .)!�~ . 7 3

u -- ... - ... 2 t l 7 � hi c % nie "'h i ,o .on, nol i.ng th L n of y � l'.J7 . �' ..ci on n � i i ot ( OI a - t � .tin t n y of . C"' 0 io .t' p 0 h8 n~l v nu n � un l f 11 :.tl.n;) con i lOft; i of 'tl die . n n, t sol l. u n it of th"s C"' l v. 'th P' iti n�r -h uld b subj ct to h -.I e t � on h 1p01:t d ai.r condi io ing - i 1 n r in q u un 1 �o c 1 0 1c in t .. pw:su-.n 0 'c. ion 1. i .r lation to s .c i n lL..J , of th � ti do Q u I+ h.- n 0 ,,, c. 0 i �n p h

... 1 n nt I -i in a y 1v v c- c- 1 , lO c n c y X i � 0 l l' fo y i n h ot u c u - cn c- 0 i � v c

- ... �ar enthe tic lly. i~.o ' y * cn 1a rom the pr: vis � n oZ c l o, . "n ject . n. t .th artie co~~en i X 3 ~ �h icl �u jec�;;. 0 h a X n ~ Ia Vt'.nc. sal 5 na 1 cti n �0 l 6 o. the ev nu "o� (: � J.h :ra ' of ax .r w e s .e altho ~ h i . i b e cl y on la �d cost \ 1�""hou ... r.1a.t1~ -u � l otn X: .t .. icl n ;.n sec ions lt.4, n l o..., a c nsi e.:c ~ o d n.;ry rtic . \''hicl J::e s1. s.>je ca 0 7~ unwBI S-ction lS Cod � Sine ...... ~ oi �C ndit:c in, un't , an ~ndustr chin .ry� sr l ~ chin xy l i ot x un cr : ctions l 4 � l 5 an t ai � eo 1 itJ.on n unl j.s s c� i �- , i 0 c nclu � � .a j ct to' th 7 com ~nsatiog tax una�r _ c :t n 190 in J:E' io 0 J c �ion 1 6 t h (. ~ud J. tl i. na:r1 s �t >0 n~ h y nn � v .rt l s;.il . �� U$"' yi c 1 co e ecific langu o� i!l 76 1I

... 6 - . T f � ir t �J ar .a c- b of t:i. l ds I Su 1 l d t . coll ct only on very cb r . ... i ila to, t her �no rt t tX y l) p ic - .to in m n y e sold, , ~ en t x -eo by nu:f ac .t er x r uc r; x X n !h c n'-4 eel. 1v le- l p v sion~ � {c) \ir� � l oCCen rd. � ' i.t�c mut on� n � � J.th u ny ccpt o s ion ~ .n y h 8l al. �conch. r xl nd J: 5- � the 0 t l 9 l .ro� .� s n. n � pee� f y:~.n "'UC u i '~co; , u s . e ... c. .ruci 9 i:r� ondltJ.on rs. . � .1. h �t ay 10 l�~ v � d in-e.ro~ l 9� �o 9i 1"(; Q brief 1 � sto.ry cf l . X vi ion . Tt h L9 ! no- f i 0 c ssify lJ 1 '-" ,f i c di 0 i ng . :<1 77

.. t i�luxur� c 1 of T a n�l 1 ... u � c. 0 l ..a1r� ci �l .e s ri no of . ' ( 1 l' ) ... i ., O.t ble. ck i (l ny h U�COI 1 i n .r. �nl wi 1 t on l - c Latar. ; ongse s s t c;i . e �t ( � t h- 2. 19 ). Tb. in th d l c� of c i p 1 n "' e s s 1 t �. ed t~ .... u .ti u ) l l -condi i .ni equ'p� . n u l. iz . ni e� .. . t 1 june r � shoul stat c 0 t rn n 9 E� u1.pmen and ~l ply y. -�.a an c -� ... 7" .J I n in na y " � Th rn 1 �v � Jun ... ~ . 97. r th . .rt d �C n 1 10nin , nit p .t Ol: ce .t,: .� .ri f t us n co :.t

� -- (c) n r c -c0 h c y c y y� � c 11 c. h � � ~r-c t nl ,, .� 79

- - .. n s nu � y - Ai l � 0 n l i i n ni s .r v c or �/ .. 0 ch f r cn l, 'I 80 I '

- ... 1 v Th h u - �n n n- nu c � ' 0 � 0 (' u 0 h.t.ch t nc l ai c c� � y 0 c c � h � ;> 81

... - ll - i~ 82

- 1 i ic �X � � � � 7 ... c �� . � 0 ) I' ... 0 � � c zon ��i t y � J 1 y l 1� { 'iP ;, 83 '