CTA Case No. 1878 (Decision)

-- . Kf"UBT.IC OJ' ":Qi~E PHILIPP.INU COURT OF TAX APPEALS 4lU.EZON Cl'RY 1 . . .I . E� - ... -- ... - - -... � ~ ,~J~ 1 .... l 6� l n t. ,, 170

,l ~~~ ,.f c1 l ..,.. ,;;7 ,, 9 ~Jlr� ;; . n lt r "."�,., .. Qf~.l:l '� 1 on ' i..i- trl�! ,., 1. in 1,t 0 � . ':1 ~ Ot tl r C! t � 1 :;, l'- 0 Ml 0' ,t;h :t re a '�l .. r l. cr. rc. r " -.:-t . iii 1 '� a ~: 171

3 In l. tt t J n .( , 9 3, t ft ion l 1 � tor �1 >ll - �0 1, t r-- t d bi d.JS~ ( d o ... J !' a no ore:)� r ly 2 ) , 9 3 1 or 4, �o not ot e 1t ' 0 'h.. r. � of or .ry t or n � rn-l a en c. of lJ" 0"" D r t - 0 in i ' .re,.ly CL~ 17, ~ �aua~r 1 ulr1� u.t s.till ~tl - s1 t 1 � ~ rei 1 ~ , '1- o~ thfJ r "one 25;1; ' ;,;.; .t ' t t2q\1e t nsaional Dir ctor l.tl 111 r l , 19 , he t O'l 'til r,' t: e r <.:Ot' , of' � 1 c t'o tv fir l 10 .. On l2, r. ' tl

�,..... ,;.; ill Df�i - otQ., r t c �e1 to qf 1n ht~ ru i 1 ity of t i'!)osit1.on or r 1- d1 or t 0 ro n r tn 1 h t .. ( ~,..: ) (.1 a s f rom � e1 . "' he of, o tl'K 25;;t su �,: ,hf..t'U .. r .rec tvl ~~ ttl.i l ott'" r on~'~ r o r~t 5,1965, . t1.... -�c n n in � '1 r 1 er l0 ' 1 � th:. r r-po - t� n ;~: ll' ruary l-:..;..,. 1 o~5~~.. av .a r th~; t i J:p ri , � 9t;-6 , tLe ctri<: ot ,.. f 11 t ' 1. l f r t- 0 l of .. .1'\ .g in t .�.r uh t:: , ore �h s 'Ll - ti t~... � l � � ion . V' ':d fro , �fl ~~ .�..~... 1�67, p"�titioz ,r e i.3 1' �or r ezo. tt~r 1 n e l eo 'th l.'t 0 �,lvO., l .s 173

.. ,...._,.. tJ. (..; M C-t,..;~ l'IV. l (8 15, 1 "7, en. t. eolle~o:t 25 surcharge bet r~ ,'0� c 1, n Ju.l ~ 1 , t 7, t p 1 1o r. I' on 1n ~ 1 c ,, . 1 "o� t t~ t. ...r: t z: r in - ~ l tte 174

pone � cont nt � t t 1! t! .r r t1d 1. r~ot ��..,.p or r nntt., t~ .tJ 10 .t � a... . ..1p t. t. pr t .., t 1,; p 'tltion fil- t 0 ti ., tit Ct "'l', f r 1 p ' t , . it t f'ut th ... .. p lfl .:l...,O l!!iO � .,. ... : "~S �o ~::1tte l l.nl �5' t it t tt 1,;; t r :r cc ~ � tiC-. l of �'e, ru. � r.:t l l 19 5 was ot �etl t .�s tt "t ~qu.. . , r- 0 � i onl)' 0 &JUly 1<'') . 7 e1 ~ i n .... 1 for co 1 ction "I h r a_p01.1 em in- t.f) 1.1 el ~Oil t r '4' .. l trtt- day r 5, .it r.'i � "~ t l lte -~ /'"1t p d~ct �I ~-~ d, 0 �Pt' ar'i .).' l' .... ne ). 0 �, l' n� 1 r 1 ' .. ro Jula , l" a � 1967, to mruo.n~� ' '.Ug4~t J .l e l)i} l �"a fiL . in ' bi, t;; ".o r l!t tio .. c� ~ ui .$ ll&t on ~Ui l ~$ ' <3 ,) (_� ua~ �t t on d r ' 1 not 0 inion Ot t ...o - ;i.s 1 .r 1~ t l .. tili.V<!;I.nu .. , uot f~ 0' l ~ ;;)>Ill'- ..D cto u. x:� 1� ~� 1 tn c. ...r aet :t or c 1 dtl is r- 1 ee t i on (.! no 17S

7 h;.a~ n 1; b'l l ,. r>fl .re ... .1n r it $ of ri f:.. .. ..'. t 0 s .. Coll ot t" oJ� .�u :;,r i_,.l ~. .ev nue .. - (-l ' - � 1217 .... .. !"il l~:r'--2) h ' c as "f1 ... 1 n ..ts t s .. e- ai .. 'lor, n . tlti;:,a.-r to " � on~- n t.lJ 1. �p .. bil � +..�. ~ . ia C- .., ""o ()tion 'Q.;;; ut 1" h at h .. ~l ' 1so !'.: �.nd . w.~.e.. tf' ) .r>r ou �y. L.;--t t" 11' { t or ' on!ll!J .."' tto11, h:w n 1(:t tl,u~ ~H" �tttonar lle .rd f.t"OI:il a ... l;ti7 oJ. is - ot Cl" '" () .. Orll ;; t1oo ll �d ,.rabl" f ll . 1 mc.mtt t tt ... r- ~ clsio 0 "19..:.. j 'o5 l.dl -tl- �~ 1 .!'o ..coo~� � t ',t f:;:'O nt tl Ci� ' .u. �-.era 1; solut y (}f' nt Q 1 br 1 o~" t�' s .~.oti .n fc,r r c n 1 � ... ~t on o:: �~hru.a y l 1 .. 5, io oth1ng tt it . t -:\ c. . a~: b 'i 1 u c� t1o tor Ol nt 0 n l .. 176

,~ rj � l. ' . , "'"1~ . c. ,. 2 I;' t 0 , ~ L~ 1 , ""' n ' . r- ..1p or r icn o' < . r ;; ' l9 5. " l (.; ) t .� Oi J l L t lo

,. '�". l 7 r~p 0. llO t 1o r:s n d 1 0 1 1G (; r �t r C'"' te - r co l,) ,tion on t �Q! t.� a 1fi .... ov �ore "'! :11) t (i or - ' � r. q t1 ... .s ts '01" 2:Jr; $ i� ot rr t a - cr r� or .1 ra. 'ion or 'a Ph ;lg� 1- �� Inc. ) � t I.. J't l 11 r en' r ' .,1 tner 178

At � ���14-ittUt!;llJ JLJie* Jf1fll ,_. .� te n � 179

. 180

f .) .. 1 oon , 0 1 . 3 ~ l 9. I 12 . --~- . tI~--� co 181