CTA Case No. 369 (Decision)

l'.PUBI 1\ n P riLlPPIN~ COUHl l At'Pl!:Al.� rJ.AM LA � � 369 � veraua � �-- ------- --� -� CI Tbl treat� of an .tty � f $ � 31, 1 � a f o t City sa S$ ~ to tax t tit collec- tlvel t. tne'� .o$p1 l l � cated In Tf ~t t henwutu. uly 24l , 1~2. of os ltal operate t � �t u1ne' uazon , � ... ta. 1 h '� P� ' � c.} . t1t1onezoa 1 nt � ��tln .~:eal �� the lot, 1ld1ng and Z' ove c lain the osp1ta at.I: that the � d fo~ cha- rltable tar a.n purpoa � or ~ al gaJ.n ( t ec. � ter in- .. 1��� apect on o t � �2 , PP� o� pre 1n � t1 tu a careful 506

latt f c; - () " t�t� �� I (12) f t �nt � t pe 1t ,. . c f t� � (a) t () re ya ' splt�l f 507

-- � 9 ( y .. - p tl ). t�e 1 y �n � 1 c� t HC 1 1� t W1th1n t p ..-� ..... 1� t c - t 1C " s 1, �1� �t �tu at � or 1 !.ng, 1 tl � � ont ch 508 5;;

.. 1�� -.-- l, ... a � .. -1" �) ... .17. 1 � .. -.- � 7. 1� ( � 509

vr t 1 d nd nt 1n t 0 c t1o 1 � t n- 1tl� tot t In u or t �~�of , t 11 d( ) t t f ct th t t pltal t ty ( } ft t � 1 vel or � c:ollec e � by c it� 1� �� ( ) t a c ll'

I � -- the or t hp � pr1 t � X' t1 1 ro � tc� � uc th !t 1 P r 11 0 r pit 1 for 1tJ d (c) th t t tS.on of c01 0 tc 1t t :r tl n t h1ch o prof � d. t rc tt 1 xclus1 1 d/r Ctt 0 � In up ort tl it 18 dl ( ) th t no r ~h r - ct p I. nts. nd t tv r h t1 n nt th of. t ont:: fr t inc 11 cl f py u dt 0 plt 1; nd (c) th t t tl 10 r r 0 p1 1 f 1 lc � rlcc: pn r� r. v 1 t 11 to t tX 1 c. 1� nd on 47 (c) o 1 c ct fo. 7) . 0 511

� - 7- �- 1 � � � y_ � 7� 1 � 1� 1. � 11 t � �' � � � v� Intr 11. ~ ). ), 512

� -- r l Applying t � c nee 0 .. f c. ln S CIS t f tl 1on 11 ~� re f S t P1 e 1 pit 1 t f c1 - y � 1n Cl a I'V1ce, ha- r1t tie � cl not .r: t 1 1ld1n ts 1n ct d e J.t 1� � or 1n5 nt � � 1t � so s t � t 1 h yw ~ � 0 the 0 :1� vry 1 � f; dt occ py � 0~1 1r � vU � --- 1 n r1�ett~ t � pro rtl a cl � t 1. 11 � � pr nt I t1 n 513

� - To h lt 1 15 x lu 1 y, tl co t 1r 1n - t f 1 al 1 t h- 1 � T 1 n ~ ., 1 t 1 n~ �c rty 1 �- c

-- t.nct �pita � c� � f y v. lty )� 1 �1 Jll �� - � (c.r� � � t r 515

� 11 - ��tined 0 UclS.ng 1� l~..lf .IN11vU1ble ( � � 516

� 12- ��.. ty /r �� c X� f � �� al T 0 t � If a , tly ��� t � A r 517

-1 - � � � le � ty t v �� 1 f ~u1 t.t � �� 1 �� t t 1 z . ��� 'R~- Gt g k-" Jaa..1!JJ ~1� ~o, 1~\ � 518