CTA Case No. 1634 (Amended Decision)

\.t<;f' UJ'J LIC OF THE PHILIPPINF..h COURT W' '.fAX A-PPEAL& 'U&ZON CITY �1 - -- � �� t 0 � ' / 3 29

C,lSlv ... o. 163 + 57 , fl :.~ d 0, 1"' Q t n� e .1c was ai 0. 0 p ic ' t ~ �- d l' ::.f ' p n rt !' t s(lr �ic ~ ,: 3 3 0

Joy . .n J L 1 nt1 f e1 lt 0 � w s t e el i 1l al s ' u. Q tio or $ i s 1 � '~.J" t .(' p r.tod Yt 195 r, 9~4, ~ L ..d in h lt ot J " , 2 co on c .rri~r' th.- �on li n " por- a oo tt e t1o s old by PAd:, o . "o. l i n ~ po t1o r er t o r to th lc . ri d on oe {E � 1, p � 1-3, rcrc. � '1 . 1�7-19, t �. � � }� f'i'l ~ . .e 1 for r r nd o ot 1 � mount or t 197�.83, r nr e 1 r� 1d on . tee b .t ef' c U�rY 2'.. , 331'

�lJ).~ ... 16 , 7 171 1 . 6 5, o fo ( ) ~ ard b to:t' co l! � ae on !t clru r fU nd, p tr f'1l th pre nt �1t1o t � ~ r 1 , 877 .<)<: ' i t. .tw "n .y ' 19 3 d s' , 1~ � 14, 1967 ' titi.one 11~ 1ts t1.t1on ot1o . to t .� revi w bJ 1 cr ti1ng i.t e1&� f'Qr t:' .f'Ut'l ��o ..._2, 1 , c . }� l. r . solu 1o :;..ti o r's 1' 1c t gr "' t .includEd .in r � r I nt r n 1 �G'f.f 11 .an 0 3l n Ol" .to� () r�a:r� 00 ( � .l;. .... ' c. ;.. t i' � n�rtitor , 1 1 e:~ only or ti 1 n r 1s 1 t, .2 or t~ f ct. th i� - Thr '! n t e bt:~ .sj n a.. r1 � tion or n t1o!1er is. Phi t 1' t !�' 3:32

c 1 - t 1 t 1 1 1. r ( � 0 t ... (� - .. - ' � � �( .. -1 t ). !� 3 3 3

A. ;}'I)!J: D �,CIS n1 ne , r ... c I c . NO . 1 t 6 - t. - ' t -1 ) . 334

I l . 7 X { (1 ��� 335

() II ,� .., . � G .ral ( 1) i' 336

1 t 1 :, 337

- c 1 -4 � 1~ 10 �h(' �r 0 ~r, ~ "'"n c r I l�' .. � 'O 1 :.1.. .' � .ri ( ' ~ 1'1 { . J i1 .... *" s , �1 i 11 0 �1! . ) L,r.. tr t� 1 � c ,f j r 1 ,...... t -1; � 11 -11 5 .0 ., � ':1'/5 in ir- ic � ~. ) n . ' c ~' .!' 3 3 8

\��AI".',: 1 t l 0! t- l � d:fe ur ,. t 0 1.: c r.l 0 0 1, h.0 pl �t :1. h hJ~ t!n � 'l: the es t c nt "h nn c 'W � r: h on 1 l in ot tar jl � ,j'T'u i .. ........ h n p() tim 0 h t () r ; 1d 1 .( s,al, tl �0 c t0 0 t ct 9 a ith ' 1.

0 ... � 1 0 .,1. i 1 0 1t - 1 � '

1 -1 7 . �() ' ' - -b, ll� e r.r1 a y 1')' ... �. ) . �- i ... 341

1 n no rr.i r. C"ont ct 9 rp 0 lc {l od 01.1 1 ' � �� � D� � - ., Ol" , t et, th 1 !n n (5' t� i s t 342

1 t I"�GUU>G~,._t n:J . rr l th b t ' ... '0 ep ' of 343

' � � ... e�