CTA Case No. 1805 (Decision)

JJ '. ' OF THE PHILIPP'! ~EB REPUBf.TC COURT OF T.\X 'APPEALS QIJEZON CITY 1 0 � e 1t1 r , ru c . T�� �1 10~ 0 IN R. � n n� - ---------- -X II ru 1 0 7. 17 . t 0 t u n Oc 19 - io u ..... . tit tic cor- ni n � �n nt cturin d ro in . tC . II 1n ro uch or. v - .t �or. t r - II n 0 '� li' ct � 1 a t. . ,, titi un I or t i -. ly y. X. l.C 1i 1 in n c u 1 0 r _ion �

c �l 0 � .. i () , 133

- � - ) l ir � � ( � � � �7 � - � r� n/ �� 134

- o ~o. 1 - �- r r a , .. n h iti 1ft - in 1u 1 ih - X ts 1 f x-r ly p 1 ""'0 m !n 0 7., 17 . � i0 h cy th � ~ ond t n i i n r � cl 1 0 i ht -1 � 1 n 0 n h i l n co 1 el s f 1r ctly ~~i th c re o er n ctu ll i tio 0 p t- io � 1c t n n t i,~n s. . t " w v r: , :.u�.- i t n vid.nc t.o re u �it '>n "'" ' vi win � ~r e to oO V fl 0 - t � 2. t mount. l ... ubjec to t e 1 in 'l u �� 11 ... n t nt rt "" . y. ~ ip "0 n rp se i ct � l� 135

- D l I �1 - v. c y r i � ( . '� 1 1. 0 � 1 � � i n � c � � �� n; r 7. � r " r r u t y v I'i 1 '� � 1 ( � �1� 0 �� r c � ' � .. 7. � 136

.. - � -- � � 1 � � � � � �� '� - � 1 �� � � �� �- �� � � ~ IY u 13 7

�0 n 1- � tl l- '� 1 � 0 � � � � 7� ) 138