CTA Case No. 139 (Decision)

l 'll I OP TIJR PlllLIPPINEI COl.JH1 01� 1 A.Pl_,&LS MANILA - r ' ( ti on r, ~~(f 6 ... ;.., . .. � � - � - ~ - - - - - - - - -x !i I 0 11 an ' � t -- � ... n rr ----~~----~-~-~~-~ ------.--- 1 ,' r c t ut t on r . �l � 222

�1 - Il u � � al (i p 'tio. r � of 0 h prof i- c� h co r ct- aeas o c ct � �� it ~ y s ry or c 1on . pr cr 5 0 r on n 0 � e ah 11 p rr t � �� � � i nl f ct � :1. ...,;,J �tO Xt r � c or � on Yn � d p tn nn , 1 1. 0 th' " i� 223

�1 �hall t0 � 2 2 -l

- � - .. It l �~ ' � ... t ' n � r ..ry 2 , l ---�����-- 1, pc 0 f r . fro l � () 0 et h c pp D � - p rt�e l ost � nly � � ( � 1d - ee er 8 , 1 � n " . 225

h of t1 � � Ac f 1, nt , ort J �1 l . 99 � � r ill not 1 �n h of th of cp � , 1n l ct o. � v p nt o r c 11 for 226

r h f. to t 7 � " . 227

� - .. a'! � n � � � .)' � � 229

..,

. . ....... � 139 -l ce 1 not 2. T � � c. ot 1 _......-........ r ) ti � n r t t 0 tl 0 ~r p rt. o 0 Ot. c r 1, ' rr nt nl t ort c p rt r 1, 1?47. t X Yr n vI r r 0 c c r .. n f nt t r, l � 0t r. (; 0 � "' c i 11 t en c r, 0 l upo , h p ren or 231

r � 59 - 11 - pr ent d tn to � at he n� uyin n el in p l jew lriea, pr nt to ~y h 1' �

- �l , .. 1,.. .... 1, 1 , ltl d t i n, 1 � 1r y 0 � ort ,, ............... � � � rp nh rr .. 233

� � .. l - 0 - 1, � s 10-11, � � � � ... � � ., 23 1

.. 1 � n c f) c r 2 � 1 1n n n~r i I t- t X t t, 1 1 c - X � 1nr dy t y - l t't 1- j c1 0 � �( o, -� � �� 1 tor nt. � � n. 1, � � .. � � 01 ... r � a, h .. "c l 1 ct on 1 e n y 235

- -~ - �c c pvl ' h 0 1�� or fr 1 n 0 o. X �� �� nt , 1n 0 tX y ov y 0 ny � � i h en y er 2 36

--- - .. �0 1 � n y c � 1: d of c ll c :t' - un [l r h "� 0 X 0 7 t ' � � 1 �- 237

11 � - � 1 !en o ....h y U.-0 I n fi 3'.1. . hi h c n r t ,. !. , ol- �t ' , r lV \ � .. 23~

- 1 ... y y nt r l �h 1 I � � 0 �� y u r X0 - 239

7 .. l � � - � �--�-~----------- 240

- 1 .. ... __.. _________ _ -----------~------------- � nt � .. u �� J-� - 241

- -- �1 -. flte t h c � ce I ) y .. 1� y ., 2 4 2 � rr s-

�1 - ?2 ... t 1 "' r 7a 9, i hi nd nt .. � 00 yr 1 1 ion r .. �� 2�l t ..h1 ppines, 1 . . 243