CTA Case No. 5380 (Decision)

HBPUBL IC Or.. THB PH i l. TPPIN'EH o:::.~:r lR'-:t�� O l :;o .A �p _pJ:�:A.I .,S ~f A f.f 1 L A T .TRTfl~NTH DlV1 Hlt')H TOTAL :;woo COrtPnHA'J' f (YN . r t.1 p r as ~:Hd t:�d by :nw rnn t I M. . P ~ P r ~t:d d.u l .l., liJe l i l \Git~� t ' n. . , , i-tA!~;t -~ .~1 ~., 1r ,nd li }-OFILENii . H O )lil 11 1(~lf;"!f~'J. A. ,j,l.: 'l'fil:.! COUF(l' nF 'l'liY. APP'Efd./:1, l;!'f I-ll.� , Pr ' ll>llll j.;lt ;~.1; R ~::8 .f: H.lnd� �J J J ( ,,, FEB J l 19 7 / J:L -� '1�."' ........ . I TUQUERO, // t n . ! .1 11:~ i-� �::- l. 1 I t "IJ t cd .:z~t 1. 1' �t .r l f� l ,_,1; i � d ' i c n ,,1 ;.I; . / �r nh- nd fl.tm.t::; cq.J (). 1r 1U I tl ' .~ C:l)l\ r l <'l f T~1:x ;t;. t � ~.; .:; h.:. F i i.i p i ilu "' F'J p <zl .:u td F'ut11'11h l'' f\;rt� <>t '<-'11: .in�t . .1nti (~"llilHii-l~:> i r �n�:::~ � �.d.' f C u ~-� 1. )I 1-:.-:, f >t1 t it :i�.� ft�-\r � ,,[ .:~1 :j J0(! t:rql;l � t .~d i(� �, plc .:t.yt-1 ''t bdl. l ('t'-;-:;po n tiet d : Cl�Ul t 't.� I.., .� ;''J ) R n :1(ol11t 1�.11::."- t}.�11 r,;.I ..l� .t ly 1 I 19 96 cJ ti d ~k: t.�l .:ud "'-' ~i l 99 6 h�.-: ~' k." i .:c r:d d ~::~ :-:t _: t<l �i n J .\tt.l.l u r r. .u n:-.H . -)\ i tl i l<d-l tf.t t J, .tdlJHrt.-. u J,.,l '� ~~n~L, r ~.\1 ~II Ill :.: t" 1 '"' !' - i ~~e:.t f;; s-e u pu ndt:: t; l ' u I ' '-'! j[ i<~tt - ~,r' l�:.lvi;;;;~,; in r:-n~ C.:;6;('\ N' :"i3HO" .!l t'll..l "that l� t;t'J(.} i(t!J fi> t.:d rh,t<�:l ri Hilt�:d tell'� ,�, ( flt :l lit t dd�'d. !;0. ~->(s , Q p .tt_,l}jltJilh~i�}l .iJ;j\llit.:J.ic)lj o:.l'\d C! j)\: f,d i11d \o:'l'"}' r.ua 1d.�::lt� ~~ry ,, dtnt< ) I i . ��It h"-' i f:t~~ ll e d d u .,.; t L119 r 6f.~i-' '-'t~<h:: rd� (\,n u t. l c: d ,;� ::l .i ~...;~ 1 r <~Ill i u i [' I ~-' n6 i d .. li'l' .1 i t'' t'; f 1\~ i lt�u ~~v� d , ~.H~{ o 1u l'. i unH ~ n�l l_lw� (~ , �IHtH 1 1::1": .i f�H�:n � u I, Ct.J ~~ t l)Hl;-~ HI, � 1 '�' U t J~~ .Jt.. !"tt:l th e~ liHp h�<l H'.:rd �:!.1 ! �.:rn , , f I ln;< d l) p i::.-.:~1 :. <l dt:<; i i::i l �)il � ,f 1: it?.< fle c:n::t.dlJ' of F' itwlll :C d~d..;;ri ~ r.ci 1 8 . l_(j9f.i , :ji ll� �~.,.. : l o e: CTA c.,H,: :.:. r~'�' ~5:3RO" r. t . 1 7. kc..d 1._, .- 0 l 'l !d Uw �~ 1}' I 1 i ~"] w 1 f -It I� I, ��e ,=iup't ~.\ lll'-"' r's ��.1 t I , l'P:�� pt:: t i ~- J ) l l �~ .. ,,, - r�~" 1 r 1 l;,>(l �1 u t. 1, 1. ~ nf i;:OCI :i d C�JU ( i d d I s.:d f.t~i'l !J !;l:l:Jtif.,t~l l :. i) 1 fl �.� '. c :, f er���~ '-' � o I ll 1<:l Cw rr t f r.� 1.�1 <.ljY!I d=t-:ttnmin�:t i <�r1 d rJ (I t..� d f 1~ ~I l ,(�;. j I !{ I 1' 1 U' f.~ I I i;l fl l f <:' i R~~v l;~..-, ; .1 .1\�d.:�u.i..... l' :i. 1 t rd t j v.:1 C i ~:��) 1 I i!l r � No . l-9~ tl . l: >i<l Mo)" 1 tr, 1 _lr!5 , ' �,\-;~:;,1.~\ 'Pct:f_i;.il. iO i i r T o t ,... I 2 fll 0 C �-,q;l"�r�;:;d'� i"n {T1d ,"J I :!.0 ( .f���r: ,', \'~(,~<~.}!{;( t;__y). . i ~ �-:J thlfll ~-:lf.~ t - ; CtH .� nt�i:J t j )fl llJ�:'i~/11< .in f. fh:l "-' bYJ:~ft" ~~~:.tf.J . � of .i rupn:t t. if i!J fll'lCl L>::e l l :i ll[:! 11S-UtGI1le� Ty l t1 r tau l � Iron S i 1 P i.P'::: r; �':�n rl f' �i 1 J i nu f;: J:t1111!..!!l.!_ lUJl ; �-~li bt' ea &�. pr-:lv?.l.ilit r~r; po rvh)nl f"' i l i i-d nu P i p13 rt nd Futmdry

,-: f\ �- (:' R 3P J�:. . 42.::1HO ., 0 :; l. 1 ~3 T 0 N � t'i .. .. .j r,_ , r 1,, �t .::t t j Cijl { i l 'ij i !'t<� f-' j t �~�: l't�r )q�:,\/! i i') l II .L�\"W.h:~<:' ~. d ' �lt!tH; l i t; ' ��' tl }' (' � 1:1 i� i � \f 1 . i d ::'~\ IIJ �:I (It�:~l j ll I 'lr VJ br.t:~d 1\ .,: ~,;. m.�Jill.l(,:., c.: � ijt, i ll~l 1: ,~ ~:. 1 Tt� .1\r i:i�.ll �1 P :lf"=''~ ' 11d F:i I I llt~J;:> \J .i_ll! 11!-VJ Jii l(lCJ.:{ ('j 'lJfl li"'U 'f�'.i!n�: fj]t:<.l (.l 1-Ht.ft:bl \{tilt I.IH; :o:~t�df( tW�e rd uf.' F'..lli'h'''~ :fi;,F} ��!g.:..lltl.:d ' f\, �.d ::;_~_lflil , ..:- llt; U �lt�u 1.li .:.d. 1 '1.>;: L:d . f~:,r� '~:> ;rnt"q� rd i��'i <~f IF:�:--w.:uitt Ttl ~ t '\.i!'�d 'j ( c�i 1 ;c!<.� .i i F I ~. :.!l:l �":l 11\l f l 'l. I i i'i~J d -i d I!� :�� :l h1.l1 !' P '�.HI l'oil tlj i'il"1l"H �'"'iitd n::q L~ lit '.; lul rd . i�lll <.li :;lGt:l j.,,, :)r:��, ,.[ l.i'l" r 'f'.:n �( f ,';tl 'td Ci l:o i. '� �I!Jo~l C� ;<{ 1.;' . ;,. :�J �'1111" Hd ~�:d li '; l, i li!J ' I j i ~..... l 'I . (�t�d �~;:;! .� fit'>F J,_\t,:t<.~l.�i> l .'/ H' � h~:r f,, F' �I� : (l<:!clHllH:>. li � iJi,~� ltd.1.t.' t�{ .L-J'I.,,,l ?��r~r : l l 'i li. �Jq ,q .:.n:t .11 �,,, ... :: r.. ISFr4 dt �t: ,~i_a:;;d, l.) u Calltl\fd �..:._: �i<H!fll" d i:IJ:;.I ; ;~,,;. ' " " ,, ., J;,.dnot::*:~ t:l:<r' !,I ;Hl( iftg t>l i:;Hif..��'l -: ,:llit :l, ; hit it �l't!t<\ti r�t H<> .id pr , ,.:) ;j , : i :3 fr <~1!1 fl'il'l:Jd l�'''t'"' r:>IH] l.lf:i i\ liir li..'�l(H: I Tui.al �;(CiCiO [�l>lil ' n t .� -dt<l Ill. i ll r:<Jit(>tl!tf. ��:l.j!liv�:d<~ ' d L �, lwJ� �,., IJ1n �.�::; 1. iHvd . b~cl d\.d l .,d;],., v.7l7. :.: ilP�<i Yt:::~.f i t � o:..l(:C��t� dr.lll t: .l :� ,..,ii.L r:: :.:t t<.�H :;qn '�'L Ll th T<il iJ ( �':!lid C~u~'fh�wu Cnd~:� iT\~.;1 ;?.nnn A<..cotr:IJr,.J!], T~..t .t�� l l "� ' r::d.�-~�1 i:'tt ll 1--.J I.lf\l!_ d 1�.1 l;,\ ) f!Cl f'u ~ \ JiH l:l�dt~�~ll� ;,-) ( �f.' :il.~~ i.tltl".lt led� \(�\l Hr~oil~<>Lil� �. Filii.'in :� p�t�t::. ':;; i�t� ,ll��~:.-:1. "'�:H�i J:e.d' �:>t. tf�: d I , i:'IHJ: Tot i r t (' .-- ,,.nt�d ~ ~� :: illli ~ird�.:l ' i (:UrJdl!i';l_t1d .:,, f,'il'!ilh J lf!V�q'l't !).:-tl'Jdil t':litd f'\ ltd.i<.: hHr.:l'r.iJ!)t> ih.:':\t<.'l'-il'l 'f1J(l!.'"t').;:>{tt;,<r , v Cttt:d .nnn n ElHOi;;JII.! H 1 T ~ i ~� f] 1..10 (I J u �ll,, T.:ll j f { (~( �IHm l ,,,tl I ' :�i'� ' i 11 hi~~� .1.:-d 1 l.:ll 11.-~ l t"! �rl' '.Jt<m'htH �1 :'"',, �1 9'j::,. ~ :t.1h1 d 1 I ~~d t. h . � 1: t:i :l lll!J HI�l l )d.cd.. i�)H n Ct ,lftflllt~ I.: JorJ �� ,:~ r<1fi�-��r� i. <J l l n) ,f' wLtlt (1 thtii'. p.r:iv.:d ., i"f��~�< pi'Jll. dnJ I 't~ �.t nf..o~ -d l.�~�� dit��w .�. r..>f:��ii' J"1 r l.;J .: I<; C� f .llii.:H i t . Ti I t,l d�:,. . u:! <Ill <.l.-1 t t�:d r~i.''� j '! H '! 9fii) I II fl.t d . j �- Dlt!IJt"d r:~j ('\nc~l!-! N<� "if'l -<�1''. !.'i��'F' H:-rt:t� , .f. t> i H�Jb~�tl~ � ~ F' d�.' ."1'-t.iHJ~��;� r,,Ul!d 1'1<''.1 r. ':( ; ~y:.:; n t� t ~~ �.:11:1( "'� t u �... i ~d- u.t t Itt-' 1 �1,l1 1 1!.1.~:� "~ nd , .,, tl'l :.. l ,, ;:,;.' 0\ ;�~ �.:!' I h1.::" 'j', 'l.t it i' (.( i!ltiJ!lr.JU tr.J:t ..:u11.l . �-�' Ill"' j . !:�11 i�1~1 ,_: 1.' 111.1 j l i 1 >ill'' t 1.; >!Jt~ t I i. II j llU dt .l!'taf.� i ,',~ HI l ! I<; ,. t l�IP ( 1.1 i ,':d �i �f! q f l 'il..l b j t:ll.?~' , � . t < 1:0:~ ~~ l.i.d f .il' I u j I l!J f (. llll ;.::: i 11!) �':1 .(10t' >::-. di11 ht: .)Si\ '��iU( .(.; ii<ll l)\ ;�; l�:~:nd ur: .-.! l.d' t' ll�J~ll y dL;;iJdi~~~.;."�::d ! �L;.~ fHI.dt,:)l �H1 r '>"i � ."-"l�ifil;: n�h ~ c1 l;y litH C,�\llllll.i~::,icoil i1 1'"' P�~~ t � I i. ��::; �.i ..,..,., ' t �u 1 rif 'Jt Hil(~�d � �t I h l ~ d' n �. J l.: ; 1 ; I! t� la , ,u �J 1, C\..~,u t ��tilL' ��!. f~1e::rt~� 11 .::lJtJ,tw ~ ~ .it t::t, t N� ) 'J �,; ..1 ---~:tf, d .--' \-<� I i\ t �r .1 l ~~ri, 1~96 t< :r't l Ct.1 !') lj!J.,":! )~; l" II 'i C'utnl!! l ,,<t�.; i "I H �:'i rL: y r.~ t~ ') l .;~ ., r �-: r r J,. , .., Nl'..l ;�_: t.d q'J'i,�a\ :-11 !; ,�jft)f�.1u ����ii.l Lit.<~.!t :..:!��il . f'11 :tfd'l" P1 .i l�.' ~d '" l't' 1� -; 1 j, �! I (�t fH\/l�''\� �., t h 1. t~, na 1 I] t �r.-:~. 1~1 t I fP'J!!.I l i-3 <1 ( :r:lu:: ! ,:.d t'n:! CTJ\. r~.c; t,: l:t t�k � ~ :jfH) ( I�.\ I. a�::< "}' .. ; T) ,,,, �:{r-:<~r- >\1 i:n-y R.,: ,tq� l '' dt~ Ch.~<'lU�[H' ' 'll L11orh.::, l t u( f t 1 ~~�1 (~ l�, 'im �) ly lw.d� i1�u t r . d'itn ui:3~3 T�Yt��.d ~wnn j, �l(, r .:~d. tll.::o~Kl in ht-n::'k..h'~:J !lh'' dJUilii t:~:- :,~�d �d !"ltt~ i�t.�l il' iu!~, {'r"\'tullll:.J '"'' lh.~ f tl� 6 C~i� .ttr i ,-,f T.:u; Appf.;<?!u f�'l<:h.r:l .)IIi .1~-d t'-t .i>dl .r'.i>''- t' l l1 iS\' t.lf�pF.!ctl 'jn:(. riti ;�.�(> Ifni d f;:l:i:Jion 1.1 l'ln � r;, �,f'' S�:'>.!G't'~t � .I �y ('1\;1:~:<; ll \. d ;,JH L H,>.:"<~' dnwft.i I�:J dut y ( t.l.Ji1H"'-::C >: .r.; ";{ " drHJ ""l.r.��~;. �,, f.,,._, F"Jl� t�� .� L� i'lt�1 ih.': , ., tP�.lU..i l" tf>lf , 1~-::� �l ,. 1. :~. .�, . 1." l:h �:' u:ol1 � 111 1 u~r�r , ~:-: �:.t. ".r", � 1t ,., .:.;;.�....

:A-��G . H f-H'~ N'n . 4;nso l) g c H 1 0 tl F'�, t .r.:1.i ; , , r ,., , If' L'I H~ Bl Lr � l.'~��d. l .: 1f Ct st�d " ' '';_: 1.., i IIl l ' i l.l llii O: fJ t n... lli ct dec_: h..;;iu t l i. n An i i�--� l.JU IJI[) i ll!J (.r;~. L.a:: ;:~,_,:c t ~::~ l a t y� J () - q(:j . dt;; O c brnpC> , l.l' t J1 1 (ci j Jtdu 'U f<~ f~t;>t d d .. I f3d ..lil!'�~� G , 1 996. 'ir.f' ,.�r li! (t-CI t l tl(;l Hltt ��~l~:ti.l u, .:d i t: l;~l , uu l d cd 1 o~-J I htl l f �-' U�::lrHl (If Tuta l ~~ O nCJ 'r.: i Hrtk �l� tc'll. i or, un I ':~u:::.; , ��Ji lt t~:~ - "~.1 ..-H .. , �.r ih:. 't <'J d bt t' 111 ult ~-~ y� c "'up u I t:l n 1- <l.ii t� lt o 1 i 1'. l "' t:: l Au 11 A "J " ) l'ltt .fl ;, , ,_,; 7 , �Jc;r_J(, _ .l-'tlqli sJ< .I P i P�-' f , -1(-"'j .;:. tlH�I� ,,�n s 1 ,_, ,-!IJII �~ I 1 1l iL:; l' ':d)l ! <ll l _. (Jl:;r:hi.l l ~} Ut 8 iffl _ ,}llt~ I�TII ,,f it t.! C urttt ni:::::~ l� ��r�c-:1' ut' Cilt'lt� -�tn�~� a~; t' i:tU l "�'ndnr tl ill c:"�t~ (:.,,_.,.:: fJc � :~~ B() p.,~nd irt!J rt>.~.~ .. -~~ t i�-�n '-' l :��:cJ l �t wnl i (.t l l _. 1_1, <.� Fl ;t t� <.\.::tu n l Cillc�!lu!W':i d ll� ��;,~;:� : d ! l aJ r,�:d r.:~d.t'-: 1"' .. t T(.I _ .~II ,!Oil()'~ -: 1111l"'rl .:d fUll {�' ! l"Hil �-:l nl; -t., t.'ltl'> '! lt<..l (l.t'l:3)itH:->I.I 111' :- � l t:lCtr~l.-:uy tid (1._-:o n iF tP . vri. l_h� � tl �i 1 l� r.�rd : (Tt~J <h ili.J[ �.tli\_J !."''' ' �1 .,r , (:(llJ;: OI�!�jH�' tJJI ii , .JH1:t r ( ~ . 19 9 h . 1�' 1 '! l j-' �j I ,._-. p l f.:n:: l tid ('I til� .. I t' ' , , J (I { (~') ttl ' ' lllj-' I ' ' f ( !�li.lr � l: dg,:~il;:'c:1 ctli l l t <''� if:.Uf''�ildG .tl H II> C 'j'A (: ,. ~,-.. ,: iJ,, :_",3~~fl .~dt d l. l W�it 1 '�-' tcJp(:i:�.: i.t vh .~, -,iiJtd�.' l H ' I'll.-'; Cl;-:i(; ftl� '�d >'t l't Ol lt ( n.Ji \'j.-, ll 1--.hi<.:IJ w<.t�:> ,:�IIJut!t-Jd l� i 'I\ �li:.J :{ tiCll (1-\ ttl�.;-'' '�"-� '' L" d ,�-i( I "f-1 11 ) On c'J ul ,t� 3 '19 96 , (~l t ' f � U fl<l ��J(If. Ct d l il i AH il cl .\ l l n tl ( ~-~ L .':lt;:ltJi" i 1 0CI Or-dor d tH !}!.ifl!J ' l '-�tC~ l 2 0!10' 1'> �Ht�l t ! JI:: o~:Hi'f IW.d . ic, n u to di urni::n'; _, co py �)t 11dtlC i t ~"~.1r: JtH.:a.- l\; �.-:( l hy h.:n~? .l rt p ~ t- l l. lOI' H'H' or� .July 1~'� , 1q:l6 \Ai tft t:.-. " N"i T rt a n u tl H;~ t � or d RI:' o f e ten <J.;...tb3 , r :lt;,; l;.-�w\�:� J JI- C�n lr I ~J t a.r d ~Hl F':ilj p i n o Pip�;;t ' t3 i!ll)t.lu.l c l <.l <:'IH;t';; l l.l i 'l ll:' r�l't 'td)<>ll l�y i t tc lu ding t.h t:; cc.mr.uid;"'; j , �,n .:..- <)[ Cq ;-_:ltil(lt' ' Cl;�; ru :.! fH .lltddn l. -t.J l lol o-r� d e ' i ll ~) lt l fH l (r d 8F.- :.i t� 'l_ 'ft�ml ~tl upl <"~ !tf':� flt irt!J li te .-,pp if:.<_.;d t1d d eu l t.don l HHl�.l J nu f :in d. l th::d.8 t' t n in .~ l jou t.;f t.'l!>::i Cr:.li.'lfl 0\ lu H:l:i( I 0") 0 11 , l 1tly ~( :~, 1.lllh , Tut,::tl ~~}(II) CIIJd l h<::! OH(_-i fi l t-::d t l n::d i� y� e:::l l� t:c l . ] vt~ tn �YI.t.,_JIJi:::i fot- r-� � � ~<:.. t tt:qd;:-~ra l ~ ~, ,- , ,�,f ll tl!:. f .i .l bi l. bGI3 i:t i1o d I.H"d<:: r . 1.:�) ~..-lt J. t: h F' .ilq.� in�.� P.tpt, ~cntbt n il . t: &.t~ .i tH '; t.l f' �:�IJ i l. h .i i"J ( (Ann<::.><Ot:: " P " , "C!", "R" ol 1d " fi " ) O n So pl.. t~ t tt~<'H ~-3 . 19 'H.�, r ~,, -; f." J I :� I �'Htl. (\.-tnl, J ~'iHll ';:;l JL.:I ~:HJGU !'!rl �~cf:l~.>cd } ('cd <>l:" �:h;r d tH l i .!rJU i.I J._.! m.;d �i <Htl':! fot� l'~ t:.~G (Hlf3 i rl tll- CAtl � J {l .. t :fJ _L:.J} ' c_;f. w lll l~ l i t..y,wit� I � t~�~ (:t~.fV~1 t. i lt)l p o;i! i i L �i 1. n er Tut.~tl ; non Ill'! fl �~� p l. t:< n d..� "''~' �1.. 1 9 96 (f'\tiiJ.l:<-:..: "T") f.Jo_j l_) (ii� d ~H � id U.� dtHfi�~\{,j 'f�'[ } q .!l�1(> [-' i1J $ ' <:! l!ll �J!. I U (I f(lt Cl� id.t;}fii(JL .:.Htd ur�u ,l_,,d Tol.:-:1 ;~O (JI.I'; ) .':Hh'l ()f.!tJ' ~_. lnui� �_iotJ~~ fnr r::-tt; onf id ~ -r- .-:t l i c� n c.;f lh,_., d>;;.:;:iu t� L tdi:t 1 ,;, t 1, � (~c.l fllfJ ,_:di"llt!>r' f�f f~IH: :�t on~~ ': . H _;'>'ft)V6 t , tJ(�l ~�l'lli~ > L a Jtdt!�:J 1. 1~ 10~ ttH��� I ,,f l.l~~:� def:l.i.r.=; L or d ,:r , l l H ~ ~ ~ ' )IUtnir,:; ;::_: u , ill;ii.' <d . C! t tt-;. L.. til <'; �l h:H.l r � H u :Jt:':d t l' > �i lnfd <:;fll{:: ld' 'l_ l tt ~ �::~[�1-� >'�J,_:d ,~ d d~;-; c i ~�� i�)l l 'Ht<'l I �. � .:diu.,,. llt f.l n':~ l t"~cll.;e of T �>Lct l ;~ nnn� w ltop(�rt. .:, l J ,.�n Ht< l �i '�- ' , t: h 'Jf3 f '~d H . lon ~.~f Tnt,:d ;1u fl , ��1~ 1�:1, r d j I.Jfq_.,; t. l' J<:;! t:so l t: .i ::::-�:.Jqt:J of ~�-tl 'tt:> L h~n en � uut� r. ~: ~ 'P� �- �n d. Ht d' r~.- ..,~, l (j :'3 j u r :h:l d j G 1-..ion f: 1. -1 -:.t h t : ,-; vgs 1:i ~ .~) f .l .-:~;-. of d n .:q �p<:::.'::l J Lt :rlu t h o d.a : i tl.iO H l.)f tf. ~~ l:_1~ej)' .. l~tL':\.t ,. of f-'jo,:\f <:t:' t!J H!lli:--;l :lll!} fpf J,':l �.: l of tWJ11 t ct lJ i (J l .t:�f:il Lilt<d urrr,__\ �:: l f�Jt:, ,_: ti (� fl :i :l O uf J. 1J\�l c.:.. Tar i f Y: ti 1,,_1 Cu B t (llll -; l l;) , -~ d C:H m~ r11-.l i' �1 _

C}:, -� 1':; R . ;:i l-1 N' ' ,;l ~:l;:-;n n n y�: r. r ~ 1 o fJ ,-.... _ ll t ,n " lJnf.i J.ll .) i rd . ll ii�' .~ <) \1! l " 'l'.::o >i A pt ":~�~ I t-; h.-H,, Pt Xt':\11 1:-l l t,.�:l C!. pitt.d f v l t .Jilt J;.Hl i� : L i�lll ~ HHtlii!J , �,1 hf�lt ro.: !',I V t.H �.h :�t.: .i :d. � ,rn�> u 1 ( 11 '�. Conmd :�n:d n l, 1:1 ' �11 t :1u:,d ,�,o,u 1 ,., ' :,.:, !.'.1�~-' P j fl 'VU ) '.1 i lli { ., J 1 j a fJ i) fl jl l t d l i lttll'. UI HLI <J1tl i i-1; 1, fl'.:t- ~::-.! , 01: l' ,j lt<:l f !'!lUft f.�j' f~ '!J .ctl'!J" ''~ { ~~ ;:> -d~ :. ltt' l:.�.. d�.�:l t:n d I' HI <>t i'<�Jl,:: .::o ��l � : �d pt� t �p H�tt j ~�tffu�: l u .) ll'J t~l' '"~ hy ; (:rs llfli> !J f " tt: ,f: : tllu n IH t ri lJ,�~ l l ll : 1 1..'1 }I i -~~ ; I .I llliJ" ' ;.: d ! II �r "d �d i \IIJ LJ li' \1 " i " ; -1 11 1 (4 } irr ... ullpO\ t ll V!I ' Il~f !-.1 hi j ;J l ii(J Ji!lltH t tit:< T.-:t l .-J!Iii (' ! q': i ( .IH:.> r~ 'k : Ill' t.l lr�'.l l: l.�n.,�,.; '-1 dwi 1 iHi 1�n ud I �J.� i In : Btn ' ' �:>~ l ,.{ C:t�:: l � lln :~�: ((f~c~': r/. 11 A 1t :~~:.::i ;. ,-, jl i l IJ '>/:~ t� , i ,~<:i;.; t LHH, ~ r,f lltt) �j, ,,, . r:h,.~t' n l rlt I�' .,f l�' i~ h'"l i t� ~t': t.:i tit -1! .: :��; t l o< i !lil� "�' i I i. dU!ti}'ilig lit' l ! l li lld' ttt V t:\1. i ll ~j d td y, c t Hd l l l d ld <lfito�ti (I ! ~1. ,/i l'll:; � "!~I :J {HJ ~�JIJ e .t'l'l t'.:: tl �: ] t .J <�lt! l f ; l �lft I I J ll ~tt ;:~I;'H; rr : J. o. l 'f ,�,f r ' .lti <'lf ll : t o i t; r:: d v .. � t dt~ I " l� l n:~ l ox i tt:O.}'IH {Vi lu o . c ..lllj'HHtd itll!l. u(' T rl;( l ..:;\�J iJ I!d .]tlf i H L' l tnl: ,iill. :~ � . ;} Jtd H ~-:v J:.:ol f1 .'32:�)) \tJi l l1. r ~ �tt.l (n::c i I ,, dt~ : .i r; i�d H~; n l l l'f�:.' Fl .... t :J' t�; !.�;u: 0[ Pttii''J i' f( ll,1 lll oJ d :i --�dlilll i'J l lt U C i~ nr:~:.cJ, 1 1 h-; H.i j,lt<:�G : .dy l H 'tt VJf h :Jd l�.r' 1r~n-J I. lt .:tl ".:!1!.�. ~~illLLLt,~ :!-!1-'1 l.l!:LU.,L. !ll~H: stl~ l!.~3.iLL ~!.!l i. 1hu ~i.!H!.:WLL ).,!L lJ1u ~l.1.UilUJ.Wl ~11.l.L� l .u Ulf::. CuUL~ 1:L Jg.� lh.!.b~..0..2!1.9 . In th d :ot.-~ IIP':. l!l~l!'l ft< :ll" a 1H.'I '" il lin i'tn ~ u . m ~l f ~>-11 i �� ~ JJ pr�l��v i ' h'�l f o~ I�}'' }.:-~ w i11 tlt o I' �'H"'' 11 f <:tt> t ��:o1 ft."h l d l:.l1.1 1;~ iu l t uf lll u CufnmiH H i PI! J::H f d e tuc l � 'l il;:" ( .7e<~ :~ 111 ! f l , TC~C) n:'1fl t,J i i._., t Jw1 f' ctt'~ l li J.tl t 'lll:� c:q� !!l'1Q JBd (! ;~ t!\li ic�l! o f l h t� l)nf' f:h ~.l r iJ I "I'Y ll'ili "�l� lf.>JJ 111 1 dHntplliU d � tl y .. t t':ti l!OII t l u t d C:u iJrl' ct CkJ � �; r �t,;~ d juritK!i,: l� io~n C�\n'\ r Filip.it11� P.i1H:> 'u t�fJt';:;:JJ <t'i t� l (~'T' i~ C<::t :{(1 Ht j nu [ �'h:t Uf ' fl i (\p l; II <..:li :1 "'' ' i ~.�.'jHf'l ' ' ~� d ('I ;:: r I) l . ) (l~v!.'i' ~ T\lf'; itnt �'�d t l..t .. n o l: H�' l l - lllll' t � ~!i l ..io.n u'l' t]J.U fl [ l il l ~j d!l 1 i1-::l dt: t~i �~l:~<1 hy ( !, .._, f'; ::n t ni �.. .~ f ,�,f 'P'i t1 on �: l-': �o:x l trl i m1'1 ~�nrr�H 'd >:id l.. y UH ~ ci 11.111n l lll:li ur"�� r �.�r c:11 Hl .,rm-1 r;:,1 h �: "'i t 11 n 1 , � �.: I i.tl l1o: ,,. " � d h ,., t HF--d t 1.;; l t:J e1 i 1.� i rl-j I H H.l n r l 'I p �J C:!wd.i'llll f': (. .:nrJ ��t ld� }, c;,:::� ldhi u.1 p .-:-n t nf J,:n., �~t dll! .i JJi 1:~ I e .t ���t.1 h y 1:11 �~ Fh H n.::lll l ,l .f I .ll U 1: lllll i:l ,.., 1'1 t)r�r~ v i t"h, ,J j fl I l _n~; .~ f jJ ;.) \j l tt") t ~oj �l St...~i.~ l i t:H � 'i' ( ~! ~ 11 r R t::l(lldd i 1 ~ A. d . 11 ;{!1 ( j� . 1 ::1_ Hn l l r�l) ' i1;tl t.dlr�"' ''' ",, l h u ~ w 9 11. ~t l-< ,:; il ~ � i lt~J und ��t lh ~-: r.�\11�1'1 P!IH' T.c1\ �1 ll ut l t��. f 1 i;�\11 u.r tt.:t r t u I 'I rn�; 'ot dHI lIt 1 r d t.-H I�. \( I l;y f :n 1 ]� 11 ~ B t.tt H�lil ,, f � C i tLi l "!uH" � �Ut nl 111 fh ,c: l ~<Ht '/ ,,f H:'.: f1Hl�1 ir: f, r: t Hv 1 1 ~ {~:;- .t rli.':.:n n �.>lt i 'r' i .. d t'w i; �; i�.ll �t'� ttf !. It >:� (~( l ll iHd t->Ll i.r.1IH ~ t 1.d ' (; u ~:ll (J tfl ~ct I'H1 tJ('~ l I 1�1�:1 ! l . n l d fll..' t �< t >,-/j , i <:: !t 1Jh 1Hitl f ! f .�lllfl i d ldic : e l <~ q :: l F: ~c~~'-�pi I�}' lii <:.t :i ;,J' tlnfl} ;'aw:: ll l 1110 t� lt ; th.�n~i ; :d�� l't of UH:' ~k. c : r d nry .,f f'in�:l!lr :t: . 11 11:, CCIWi u .1 H :: ;ifi\H:; f o l' f':Jo '~ ! <�W U y l h :H.'l j'j (l , ,,,, h ct l' 11 ,, , f'll ! l ,� , ; ,

CA--n li HP N1. A 23H ( o E: c T n r n N �r,,, r r ., I d j -� <I I I! Hf II iiJ ; : �:'1:; ~J: -: �,,;. j�, i C h �.lll 1'1 .i t) V t�; j.,! t l!]Ci [ (1d b y 1. tu�; i C:uiillfl i ~ )<-:~I'd 1 ~~ ;, d <.1ti:<(~ 1d�� d by t.l' '" H~~~~: rr:l.l,rJ- �� I' F.tlld l t~ :�.:' H~.:H.; ::t c'l"! rI ' 1 .:.; .d f.: J ' �r ,":C:} 1\JJd , (.� t� f' l""'�c: 1Ji ~ : .:d l}' 1�1 uv� id:�1 <l i 11 i-f,r.t:l' i�.:;u .101 �.d ' 1.1 ,,. ., T.-j 1 t f 1: ,:, nd c ,u .t , �iln. 'i l � ~.f..t .!t) l �t..J (!�lt~ :-_ .; .: " ,_~t fJ.Y , ~J0Y ~ ~-~\lt:~( l J.'nt t ~~ ty Ht".. �~ I �111 s.':1 'I IJJ~ 1 .~....b. _ el Al.!i ~C.11! .-.......- J ...,_ ,1.� o f t.jtf', ..... - t ""f. �; p.' l:.�l'll_v_ t;.. �\1!!( 11\~n~l. .... _ _ .d.......l..~ ttl.iJf-~ , j qo'":J. d.tlt v (-' �-.��!,-I t- t- -�f-f- .T.-.a.......:i.;J�. - - -- i II t 1..,1 ; : �Hi !( ~ 11\o l ( i i ll �: I' ��ll 'd '" i t 'I :i. n I o") In<..: I l I "1 I I { ' � v i l h ' ., J.,y 1<����� <1"1 I It : . , �,�.n::, , , (" -i['!" \�.<\ (j ��11� �l i P < dt--:<: );:"1 .1<11 � , �J!� t.IP: Ct;tt~.iiJ<�: t lii ~.J , lllo..ll >�t ltll ,.-,, tll<'!l 1.11<:; <h :jr,j?, l< .lf i 11/' 11tt�\ f1 .�J r:_t ~, 1 �Jt y .. ( F' tli -~d , < :~: ; lid> - , ~,, , ;f CTA ;':,-,,~�.:� p.j,, ~).~jFH1 diH 111l l?-t.H1d lj",, ., t'r ' " a-J~ . f i l r �;d I� / I:Uil l ll' \'i d ~; n l "'i'lif..�ll ll � p j llf~ .... ~J .':i I II ~ d ~. ~ l d i ' 'II�-~ I T" t 0 I ~~ fl tJl . t 11� j. ; u i lj; }II I: ' I I i H .. <.11 !.1i!p i II 'J .-f , l j y �"~'Jn il 'p;!: 1: l1 -1.;: l �1 (: I tn �'Ill .-:lf' l " �'' �:l �i l.},i,t ~'l f r <Jfl! �� .1 t l o J l.~UfAllt�t��.:ll l ; : , .. Ar I .j.,,_,~d i1�Jl l i tc' . 111 ;::H :l: <J :t d.:l tH :h ��n llt l lt~:t ~ :: t l.~~tl. r j l'fh. lf' ' ttf ~.h�-!(~ t�. f.(..qi :�~u1 { f J tlf" l.ln�) "l\:i1 i r r ��-tn ,J C l! ��:l.i',lfi;:J C1tdi'-< Tl1u U f''i .ri.' f h <'�� ���"t d " u lll y" 1 11 ::kl i d ""! pt <~vi 13 i <.�ll 1111d t��C� i! ' ~~ .: I. 1.~:1 1 <�t ~p l .>1 .1~ l 1. \ll.'< in I �'J I d I " l lud I �'l lJf.'fh:d .1 h�Ji�rt ~~ j i l;: ~ ~IJ I t t " ' T.':l.t t\t' l' ') �"> l '3 iiJ �:tllf) �-dlHi iJ �l li U � :IH:: Hi�:i It :� d, d < : i; :<tun~c: :.j f.l .l�c' lh �,f' fh"l. !i ; ldl:}' HHin� t�l <l'l\J dtufil Jl!"I !J <.\ .1[ J.l-:t:l Tlili;> d(ll �\ ~ ; itnl llw� �~~- L I P .�W��: ..-,,y _ !. l i e I Ct:u:,:p<..11 \d.f~ l'!l. ~� l �lipl!Jt) Pi[!>.. i:'J v~ i l. l t �:� tc l. . .~ tl.'i t>;l!l>:; iJ 'i' i"r��IH l. tlH rl"� :�i r:3 jnrt "r �II J:.; ~):? <=t ��d ..�ry .. r F �in<'��n�.: ~< F' i l ip!11o� P if " �" ()(�ul d l 1<'\:H �:'l �'Ll>it(1.1utl lu 11,:."= P1>JJ.:-! td>:: ul w i ll.l '!Fu' c:: t n l t�d .. r ll ~�.: ;! ~..)t.:~~~t �1 \l t;~ '~t:z f.;. l..~I t nt f: o l ;-., , l aJJ ~:t, l \ r.-J ~, t ,(.J (~ff : t:t � =~� {fi,,t: I .. Ad w .~ nd"' u f 1 qt:r7 l r R. � ~ �,:v� ��n.:!H .- , 1 (:, :.ut 1� t":i l 1;u St!:t;r .,: t� ,_ r 'i' �.� Fi �� ~"ti~<:.:~ .:t.Ei i'i� ~} -i$fl �.i, (:;-!, SCP.i'� (iH, ;~cl!.l Nuomd Ti1 t rc:r n.:d: 1 �. 11 1 ..:-~l � ' t �=��I inu r� ' Cor p . Y'"!. H,--;1 I <li I. ll Phi 1 Tn d : w:h i ��d c .. f C:l\�-(':J H ~p flo 377!16 n.~~:n ~t d.�r.l t::J. 199ri , in t~ UVl "��r 1 .t tl �~~ t l ~loHH' I. i nlt ,,f :ur i 13< 1 i cl. i un 0 \.'tH ' l:ll t'l i't f' {JO�~I l in CTA ecH.ll~' N<.> ~~i :JBO T l iu """�,-�i !ty ln I P d i:t , 1JUWi}: \:f-; J l."lt r.:!l i ii l11)t h !~t t ~�H-~D t1 nJ �1u�: iHJ<>trl: o f l h e; S:'J1~l (d .:1<' ) ' llf F" lfl .:ilJt !H t-Ji .d�J� ~ �d � (l � tl 11? �':'tppt>..:-t)H l llll'J('! H o:: d diil!l p .il i ~J dll ( i��.< ~l ~]<.'(tl' l y , il. Jl:J w.,. ~: .:� �:Hl"l1 1�1,c1 1 f ( ;t t. h i n ttl1 ~:H1 i n U tt-" t ' k o t ! J)�:il rtd_o:l:t fi �:SL)Oit.-il Tr.:c~ dinu ro�l lll 'l)' rd ')1.1{ 1 .-:.:H �Iu t l t.�d ''lh�;: ; �cti t l Cu 11 .t t. (tr T�) �~ 'tl t �L-"'��:d n '' ll,.;:;. nt �vt� c,I�~� i (.d.-~ jqd i�:i,�'il lu)t, y l,(3 l'��~I Si:l I I LJ<1t"l I h H v.:~ ) id i i '( ,oj �:l{ l ut dt'tt' ,,f t li u i..-lt � � ~ ~ r~ l .:-:lfY ( �f F' i, "�11 ...~u . ~!l!L~:.:u:E-i.!..J:l .:HJL..L-:�!~.!IU.r!..i.ld !.1.u.Liu.r::::. " f11 l :~t\il t , W<o: h �:.f.t l lt n l l< -; t�� t�'"lH f �'�! t d ' C~;t~tl J �l' :T( n jq rJ.iJ d. i :.": J� I'.I I J ! 11 l l"d H �, . : ''Wil.f, ~.�: t i,:! H 11[ llp�; �:"! Lil 'O .:d i i i i'~ T i' (\~ ;::u_,: N" .�i::;H O ilit d , ! l u-n:!!l�� r l":, 1.;1tH iu tJ:� d:t' j II WHJ~: HHFCihC. > ~-'U iJ�lfH!f.�-, ll t C!t.tlli t ' ;) (lt�h~Yh d d l l:� t i .ft tl j� 1 s,,,p! '199() .a nd �::: t11l;b t ,::J . :; q�.Jf) .:~.~: ,., m�:V r:~ ~--~SE i i c' ~'' t'l :~l5:T AS J nf.~ A(: � ~�Yr d �: 1I ~J l -z~. .i wigw �=:.tof i ,., h;�.:�r ��by (� :!lid~.} r< d d '>l I H' l l j (:J t l'i;o-> d 'i ~.>Ji ll i 5}�l<11 (J { (t:l. ifJ ' 1\Jd� '.~ f tl t�' i ! i ~ I I li I l p l I' H �:u t< I p, ' ' "'dr :t

CA-G . H. BP No . 4 238 0 n �r:ciSJOH (\"J r� p(rJ"(t i.i .�n ' G ap pr:Jbl l in CT1\ CtiUt� Nu . 5 ~180; nv p:r� n1r i b j t �i r e .~qJonde n 1: Cn u t �t f ronr t .:11<i ng cogt, i z o n r::�:t t h 0r <�:of ; .:. lr,j .'1 1�r ..:~ c t .i ng r e:..1 J.)fnH�l�:�n t CerruJJ� i ~.;: ;:;; i <.l i"'lt''l'. of CuBtumB l..o i trt p l t �(m.!ftl. l: ll i~ dr.s ci8 10n ot tll e b e cr e tary n( F' lih':I. II G8 l .-;U~ d 7\ pr i l 8 , 199fi , in Atlli -�Durtt:�in0 C.:u:-: e: Nc� . .1 0 �-�96 . WB ~CJl.fCUR : ~~~.~~E:A l\ ::~ :3 oc:iot e .J n sticf;~ 1� e .1u s t i <.::�:~ A'rT'F�:.9"T'A "T 'Ic N r h .:H ~l;y .:.t I. 1:. ::; t.: t t.i , .;tt~ tld t; D::�c j :3 i un v/cl�) -r '-''-'t <; l r?. cl ' afler l l ll d <!<�,n ::::n l l. ation '-'111 ~< )ng th e M�~�mli tw o f tllt:l ' DJ vjs i un iu ci G no rc:J ,,n (~ ('� w :ith l lt 1?2 pr�.-� v i ;-:;; j, �q , <d ' 8t'; o.: l: l .>II 1 :3 , Ar ti c.: l0 VJII 11t' I h �) C llt ~:!. .i tul- i u r1 . AT. 0 . RASUL A.H:.r:" :j at(~ . lr tr~: I. l t';e r h t~ 1 ~Hh DiviHi<"lls / AGT J jl:v I >