CTA Case No. 427 (Resolution)

1lE.PUBLIC 0 THE HILIPPJNI!I:It , COURT Ot .l A APPEALS "-A.NlU I. t;I 'c/ �v u � ca ... X "'� . . � .. � - -- -.. � ... � � X II tt c. � � �~ - - v r u I 1.,: X c. r . l� 'i.l -. -- -- - . - - - _,_n� I ' � �� c . ' - . .. ... .. �

, �� , -t t � � � cru -- - - - -- � J( � .. .. � .. ...� � . c� � � -... ... ��� - .. �7 . . . . -. -. . -. . . . - -r � . r. � - .- -. . . . .Jl � . - L 1c ot c a .r n a c .. n .. � 0 eu �� � � � i ~ 2 '

. 0 c. ~ pr .. f 41 -� ... tit.i r nt r .1l 1 t nt i t i� y X n th ol nt a t c �c l df !nco; � t X t c il n- l::t (; t fo t 1 � l � pl p t nd tn t~ r T1 � 4J c t up l ... t c .u ) t. t 1 ot f � .d 0 th ',1 �' ' 3 -- ...........

34 , 4 7� 427 to 3 .. c s. ln th con l c. t th Co\Jrt iS not 1 cl!n nt .r d i to y . to P.rov c .t:OJl!S g nt Co nis o er of nt rn nd t pu � uant to cti v9 of h i '- ion 1 I t 1'0 1 � v n Co � 1 p .r c th :'\:! 0 �r o nter 1 t t co ro..�.i 1nt rnal r v nu ....n9 v t a n hi�j xc.lu !V ly, PP r.r 0 n n c ss ty for it .tJPl:'OV 1 by th! urt.) .t \t YE t d w t t, c f � ty of r pon� c.e t ho � nt!t � ' t' y 1. m s e i nt as t c st � � tla, ?hil p n , J nu ry � l~ � 4