CTA Case No. 445 (Decision)

UBLtC OP' THE f'HIL1PPIN . COURT OF '1 AX APPEALS MANU... - - .:r. ... � � � � . -.... . -... ---� ~ ' 1/ /1Jf �X .. .. � ls � -l . � - <.,; 0 l ,. � v� �9 c.}. f ..., , � - �p 1 $ � t l� n 389

\ �. r u ct pn1 �"' ol top t ~O'l . 0. p "'t on, th ti.... of ts or':. � � ~ 'tf. � k � ccrpc.r -.to t � v tC r .. � it1 1 �_..s oy other :tm.Oe- . 1!1 (� � op r t1r ~ .!fl t i! 1 on e.1b r / frc11 tn~ t:uz� au o � .t orG~t ... y - t!!~1..... - ViO� Sly .. � r! .. ~ ,1 l 1. �' l(i ;r-5�, n . . n t ~ ' .. ;. p .. il"' vm:' m ..~.n . r �~ -t .:t ona op r ...t~ lumt.> _.;..-� c t !;/1; ;r: J~�~:, ' Cl sly . .. ' J;.. ' 0 ,..,. (Jfl 1 A ' :� ~;.I . 390

391

-- ~t c� �{ t � c no - a t � t t f � .. ,' . - t .l 1 c 1 s:

.. .v. :~ .=' - .. 5 � -!:n ~t '\fl 1 en of � e�- � .�~. 0 u ' th th ce f.O u ha r.o urts t of th f , � v~ c H>d fl von ntly s y i)'l 0 f~ a:,; in. v lv t� pn ~ nt: 0 l{C w ~a two t.o h 111tH f �h Pl:' nt pett 0 e 1, 1957. t:. e ~u�p n Q - j '~!.I c 'i: ' �rt i<: e ~"l~' ~ v n rl �� . .' O{ t .. � T X ��od c ons uct � ht ~r . o, t ory J 0 "C 393 397

� � � {j - � u s~ ft l ys 0 1 � 1' n f n oh � s c. v. c r 1. , � � .&..� 1 ~. l ~ 1, � 394 J'f .~.

� y - 7- - y - 1 c.r , 1 �f - 11n . �t. � .. � 1� 395

/ 1 l � a- x: X X 396

~� .- .r.. te rent 1 .� {Und � tor t uppll d.) It � den f o rn u .... t1 ct r pa � � . y pet t on r . o v.. . , r� s pend .rt c n"e. d t . t he y w .c .- n t p t n r p c .o � ct� r of er sh �t 1 ut thy w p d tr r on of th t tmb ;;: c ooces('! ons t a us"�" n nd n c :r 1 .�~us try ., a .d net 1nclu t co x � t t t or r � \in th v~c fo t. il 0 allog , t h ope A. no. t- co. c .. i.O s ts � 1. ctJy �1� � to , .s u.. � n. of manu actux: n pl o d l and veneer ~ sheets for export. .l c nt r t i l 0 thll t h ~ er .! I cf lt t.t. r cone s d �r ct ly re l t d t t. manu � ur -. 1 an v n sh nts for exoort 1 1 � lh. n p~~at� f t c �� �-~ not tn ect r..O 0 ' �U url� 1 w od p n ls rw v ets 1 Ci tt t iS St c- nt f lt p cto... y� hi uorne y t h f 't that pe 1 :f.\) �~ in us ry a .be n a lish d . d ! 1 u~t y o � nuf c- ��Ul:" ply oo panels and venc r ets. has n op r t 1... 397 �I

�4 -1 � c1 ly l nd 1 ...5 h - c rh� f 't' � n 0. .0 10 � 11 log r r 1 ~ c f c n � � td c 0 vl to t y ,� � � 1 r t ~y n .,... 0 uc p 0 cf 0J0 39 8

h c -y d p 1 t;;. ..... � ly. t X :r �x�"'~� r - t �. c c 5 an 0 .t .. c ~l f "' "�1 X s. v. J � e., . ol ? .t .. '0 n . con � .. � h 01 0 t ~ .X "l' nt Q 0 t r "' n v ,. 1 I .." .. \t . ~ 1:: ... X .., i '. 399 J'f/

.' � 1 t.hE$ i mart "' t t l l :l l' 'f ! 1 -. 0 I --- -� 400

.. � - .. X.,. - � d . .... 401

~' ll . .. �� .. . c .. 1 .. n t l n�� )(lEI t . of II y n., c j � . 402