CTA Case No. 2611 (Decision)

t' I <_ll'l { ) � ,, y -- �� � 2 11 � ��c � CI . I \11 I lin � " t 20 � fo I c 2 t ) 0 co Ot ti cone r 1 j ct 0 0 ur n c �2 � �l 1. J u I" c n n t ,. 'W hi C s- 1 d a i u .i.n h 1 w. r. 1 E� b1 0r i. n n 1l 1 0 r: c 0 i} 38

� :! .ll - 2- r 0 c� to. � p w v .~ .. l 0 fil r . ''0 1 0 0 ~i n ou 'i ._ t: ~ n <, b., r�� ill t 1c l 0 � ti i � nd t t:> -� '!0 t n : 1 .; .:n ) xi r .. r h~ 7. l 7'), nt u- 1 � ~.t:'l� : loc� 0 1, � ~ � r �1ft l 72 r ~t'()C , 1 J -, .n 'i .. s . i I Mi � n~ r :. n 0 v it 0 yi f !0 It li � J:n ,� � .n 1 )I r 3 9

, Cl .~.o Ct'. ..A; E I � }.t �l l - 3- n 1 i'l i p u po�edly in t ro uc � t 1 hi .i h u fu l n c ully u 18 r u c; t - 1 of w1 h - M1 ; i ri c n - s t ~h l 1 t~ 0� " 1�~ r. � tl 1 i , .o cf u a ro nh u0 1 . 12 . 1"l 7, n� rp th "f ~ u u0 l cr � o. ln t� 1 � � ei c c. : .~ ~- 0

� ti 1 h ,. p rt 1 to J - cp r tio .1 Sllbj c t. 0 1' t" i 1 o�t .. fr d1 ,. M rc 01 nd w ich y 0 � ril � 1 7 � " f� - l n r b 1 n-r 0 - t.n ~ r r .. iona 1 � r r l 1.1., 0 � � i ,1 n � 1 ot. l s '� o� io f) '1 1 l of i- n tAl r i ion. �t pt or v i 1 l h un ~� 0 i 1 t1 r.o i dn t 0 � .let � r ) 1 � �� ( � a t c nd r "-� c n 23 ju c r � 1 .�.. h ~ "~il

�1 1 - t l' li i1 r 1 � 1 � t rc l 1i t)'Y 42

c. 2 11 cri d 1 c i th r wi h ' 1 bi 0 h� 0 0 ion. �n v r ha rt � 197 of �.c� in ti n d or 1 pro- t mpl ..t hc t ion r r 11 n1 r . t t X X r ... 5 �, u ing our o � �1c i: ve tur�'- imil i f nc nt � t XXX r 0 to h X iff un 1 1 r o. X h in nt � tition fo r i w ho d no,. nt.e illl-3 t1 0 1 t "� ti n .r p t for'\� r thi r io �� X X '.- 43

lI .- Cr '� - 7- ' n r� .1 ~ 4 !J

c 10 . '2 l l -- r- in

- "' 2611

� . 11 ... y Fr . 1 i 1 er- o. 2 � t� 1 o. � 0 wit th 1 Qi "' l t. v n ct- .. f) � ( � n 17, 1 �� � �- 5 � '� c >. l t' n� li � v. Ouz -n. Phil � 1) c 12 ic 1 i i rro 12 1 h .h i n 1 io h r i l l in 00 1 co � r t1 r. � 2 h ,. t � � i t J . 0 ~t t l � � : r 1� i to

xo ~ . � ?6 1 1- 12 : � r1 - . ts 1 ti tiv th r . � j 0 l n~ c te .tt 1 _i& !' 1!8

DECI C' IO - CT CASE NO . 2611 - 12 - featur nd t -nd coll e c t i on th to the h r o u g h t e i n trum n t3 li t of i d d m det. t h ri ff nd C to c d ; cr d i 1 III i o # I � E o t T r i f f ; in e t s c t ion 51 4 , 5 1 5 , 516, 517 a n d 5 1 8 i n ~a i d c od ro i d i g f r h_ 1 vy. d c oll ctio of d t y o t e ort t i f d r od ct"' th r d ~h re in, inc l u d i n -� t r .,:. i th th ch r g d the u e u o tom f cti f g nd c o lle c i n th- rt d t � ctio 1 I th d c r tt i "ta ' l y that p lie c t No . 6 1 2 , h i h uthor i z d. -ch i m ~ i t i on o f st b ili 7 ti n t x on co i gn n t br by t he c n t ral nk thr u ny a t r i z d g_nt b k , i r peal d . :ni s i o n r Cu tom.,, ae ' I , h d of t e r u o f Cu t m , u n d r s cti n w th h rged i t h t h uty f ro u l g t in t h rul s nd r 1 t i ona c s a r y f r th i mnl n - t t i n :>f the d cr- , b j c t to th ppr 1 0 the 5 c r r of 1 anc � i cc rd n th r - t , Cu s t o s A nini tr t i v Or~""er 0 � B-73, at d un 28, 1 7 3, as i s u d , s c t i on 1 of w ic h ~r - vi . 'I

-� 1 -- ... ii .i � 50

.::I t - ~? l c - 14 - en t r :tn�.t. in n fl c:t � 1 lch au i - r1 iti y h.C n Ci n X 0 e rt n � r- n r vok � Co "'n ly. n � IJ � 70. eh r c 'j ro- 0 .: i ih c :n t: r t..; t e i 1 .c w � r-0 � { 2" . .o. 1 � 1 if it I rovi ing f rt h rt iut.y ci c- i �r � inc he Pr a 1� nu � u j. f hie � l b 0 0 u n� e !ll

- 15 - c J. n f d u. 0 h i n v, r yt y n lli th h oc r- Cl'1 n p Ut � c l ... y� c;: r: �h ol t re ly rc fQ r� in co e n .a col t 0 � ........ t h dl cr r: c 0 t �c :1.v 0 � .. � t�nt � "" a th rot -"t p 1 i nn r r y t rcul � h l s on or Y' ct .l r 1 . ue I) he ev J . s ~n c i c0 uch n in c l (.) ns . r f�ll h! 0 1 ul 1 ppl 0 th 1l h y yh cn ,11 ;if: I �

- D.... ..CI 11 c - 1 .. pro t th J ul net ,l rvt h x or y. .h. h e t -r vi �i n o h, � ri f � n�1 .o e . s 11 th ll l r1 ;, - 1 � , 1' d. 12 i t rl ro 'y b ) 1 1r� � (Q) a. ai tp t 53 53

I- il � 2 ll - 17 - c 1 � -1 � 0 � - n 1 i � of 'P 1 J. in � ti 0 ly hi nt n 0 l=i \.1 j 0 r: 5 ;� �1

'1� . 2 ll -1 h_ t t ri n i nt 1 cr � 30 � 1 7 n� r � ly h �.r.~ - � t n re~ d n cont.~ .i 4 hi 2 1t t d e te ( :.<h . �t.l ) hold- n r

-- � � le ly t- � \ 1 \ 56

c - � 2;11 0- c: . i. ... �o c ll c h � Co 1 "' r ..... o i ... l ll � v c1 of cc .y i t i i .. �) 0 5".:J 57

0l 0- o. 2 l - 21 - ';~ 58

�2 1 �2- nl -1 ( r - - l :1. � 1 � 1 � i ). � � 1 � 1 ' . 59 �

� �l ... 2 r� f l n ~� t 10 s 1 " .... i .hi ' c� en c Tl ,n r to f e - itc i -1. o .... ti Qi 2 � �v ti � f dllit\1 n �i l r 1i r.ib in c ~i) ) 6 ()

II - to. 11 -2 - n a on h r 1 � i or� . c i :;>f ""oll 0 0 oncer e or if� por 1i t dir tl r c 1- 1 ti .u � t " c:c r i Co 1 .Jt; n<.> 1 0 Co rf �~ y1 � 1 it juri �1c n f.r .~ o.t � de r tr c � 19 c: �' ""' � ( h l 1 c . 2: - � g 2 u�~ t 1 .} a c ... 76 .. � 0 i �1 h r .t. 0 ,, 61

'""l I � 2 l.l -2 co r 8 n olv n h c r bj c 0 y 1 n 1 0 t T i .. n ..... � � l.n i 1n r rv i 11 � �1 �o in etit on � 0 0 0 D. � c J n arr """' l e ! 77 . ~M //) ci L~A1-~\.~J u. - UI ~ ;.?