CTA Case No. 131 (Decision)

J ~ /' REPUBLIC OF THE PIDLIPPI 1E COURT OF TAX APPEA.LS MANlLA , c. r�� -� X � - � � � - - � � � � - �X ; ' p slo er o o. 1747. t � f e1 � I~ � fo ty- 187 � co - � 91 �

....... J. . ;;, 31 C.-1 - � -2 ""' n d to t (; ,c 0 fl "5") f a c v r .... by bill ad in~ -" . nd 2 ) �f a coem; rcial in oiee {2Jehibit u ,0 ...1.. tt ~ * '*) a j G~ttif e e 0 0 . it ' '� ad a tt') ~ onsu a ce ) f;. � l i:t c ..o. ~... g ~ 1 ...... nd . "} -hie: th '"�1 nt as:: 42 case oi .~u bGt' tc 1.:~ i i i � an- a ig �O i e"" n L .... ll2 pon ~a: CU"'t.O. n to c s la 101 i c .il ana r t e , -ti t:iorP th ti $ (' ee J.H~ ; o. � A it n r i I K'! 188

c. ... 1 ... """ c .t: c ly th - � . l ... t ) u ., h on- o~ ca. 5 ' ,i 2 .rrty...nine 2 ) :J{ t, nt.:Lr fox .... {) (; ru �e boot Wtd:' t it ei.f ct 0 �~e:r ��ic ..,.t 0 t .\ {1 s . ly !$ t.l"' th - hi ~ nt of saict -;,-o s (l boot } i n rrcr., 1.ohe p t.ition ,... e �!. "!l d � po ~it>l fo t.t t. r on tt � n . o r 'll#';U'' . 00 "i c �l '0 h :i"J ots or la e ru:! t"lap X: ~ io~1, t t �t t' 0 cr , lt. on J y ~;:) . l:J!i4. ls ~ 0'1 y s u.l �t or o. i l;,pl rc�l c f t nt t1 nk J' se of \ and �!iecti up to u S:J 9!:14) ., 1:?. of t J ndic. l� (, l l s. ' l' ... () � r ~ r ly". IW 189

� ( .re r n n�d i � 9} ,rti �r ar .-,J. an 1 r or {� � t s. "' Exti �c d "7 J� b irrt. i fo :rs. "'tl 1 2 c�lls or ar ru� v ~~ .d onl. .. i : !'C 1 � SC or ndie~.t iff;! :6! �d �a of in... lusio r ~m:i cl ... e . 0 ~r b 0 1! u ... us of ,ine s.- an .X(: 1 ' e ...l l o~; ,n �i. y~ o... 1 '' .ta an~ cnilol:' n .. su to tt z of t. n {13} 9$ o'f :ruu.o � 0 ts ;.n n or e r 1el -f u ldij ' t ci.a '.} ... �n i ' �i re~-p~ct 0 th ~� ~a"' .;.i.. t.hG f r t.) pt r ont n �o 't.:: t i oul l for e i!< ro:r , i th i n � 1') 0 c! s con ,ti"'Jh his l~tt~r is tli"t .~... \~ �~ . . tior1 Ci the .r +'�I ..all l~fl~: 5 ' j, ..... t in t.1 totes. c ij,f r n� � a�� .'}.. l � . n.. tt- ) I� ') i f 190

t it t ll n Co � !ora iOt '"' "' .C. 1: r. . c 1/~ 191

.- � � l?i 192

-- . � � len ~ t ic i i 1 ; � �._ l � 'I t t t< . � 1r he al t at of good l � In � ut i h. � " 'f ' � y c $t j fo2 � 193

1 -� 0 f l � � .l 5� 19 4 IP

�' ; .. Iff 195