CE LUZON GEOTHERMAL POWER COMPANY INC. v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE (Consolidated with CTA Case No. 7279)

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES COURT OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY SPECIAL SECOND DIVISION ********* CE LUZON GEOTHERMAL CTA Case No. 7180 POWER COMPANY, INC., Petitioner, - versus - COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, Respondent. X- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X CE LUZON GEOTHERMAL CTA Case No. 7279 POWER COMPANY, INC., Members: Petitioner, - versus - CASTANEDA, JR., Chairperson, and UY, JJ. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL Promulgated: REVENUE, Respondent. MAY 16�2019 / J/ 1 : JD li�AI � X- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X AMENDED DECISION UY, J.: Before this Court are consolidated cases remanded by the Court of Tax Appeals En Bane in its Resolution dated May 28, 2018, pursuant to the Supreme Court's Decision dated July 26, 2017 in G.R. No. 197526, and G.R. Nos. 199676-77 respectively entitled "CE Luzon Geothermal Power Company, Inc., Petitioner, versus Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent" and "Republic of the Philippines, represented by the Bureau of Internal Revenue, Petitioner, versus CE Luzon Geothermal Power Company, Inc., Respondent", for the determination and computation of creditable input tax in favor of petitioner.

AMENDED DECISION CTA Case Nos. 7180 and 7279 Page 2 of7 The facts of these consolidated cases, as stated in the High Court's Decision dated July 26, 2017 in G.R. No. 197526, and G.R. Nos. 199676-77,1 are hereby deemed incorporated herein. In the Resolution dated June 28, 2018,2 this Court gave the parties fifteen (15) days to file a written Manifestation, alleging any supervening event that may have transpired which the parties would like to present for the Court's consideration. Petitioner filed its Manifestation on August 13, 2018, 3 stating, inter alia, that during the pendency of this case, it underwent the process of dissolution and was able to secure an Order from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on January 12, 2016, approving the dissolution of petitioner; and that it likewise secured the clearance and approval of the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) on June 25, 2013 for the closure or cessation of its business. Thus, petitioner prays that the Court orders or grants cash refund of unutilized input VAT in the amount of at least P23,489,514.64 for the four quarters of TY 2003. For his part, respondent CIR failed to file any Manifestation. 4 In the Resolution dated September 4, 2018, 5 the Court resolved to submit the consolidated cases anew for decision in accordance with the Supreme Court's directive in G. R. Nos. 197526 and 199676- 77. Hence, this Amended Decision. THE COURT'S RULING After a thorough review and re-evaluation of the documentary exhibits presented and the report of the Court-commissioned Independent Certified Public Accountant, the Court upholds the computation arrived at in the Decision dated July 20, 2010 in CTA EB 1 Docket- Vol. III, pp. 2268 to 2285. 2 Docket- Vol. III, pp. 2361 to 2365. 3 Docket- Vol. III, pp. 2389 to 2394. 4 Records Verification dated August 28, 2018 issued by the Judicial Records Division of this Court, Docket - Vol. III, p. 2403. 5 Docket- Vol. III, p. 2404.

AMENDED DECISION CTA Case Nos. 7180 and 7279 Page 3 of7 Nos. 553 and 554,6 and hereby finds petitioner entitled to a refund in the reduced amount of P23,489,514.64. The said amount pertains to the claim that was duly substantiated by petitioner. The Court likewise reiterates that the amount of P3,084,874.357 is disallowed as shown by the following details: Reference (Annex to Findings Exhibit HH) Input VAT Total ,. 1. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by pre-printed TIN-V invoice. 1st Otr L-10-A12 3,987.81 2nd Otr L-20-A12 11,114.74 3rd Otr L-30-A12 9,705.17 4th Otr L-40-A12 6,932.15 p 31,739.87 2. Input VAT on domestic purchase of services supported by pre-printed TIN-V OR. 1st Otr L-10-812 ,. 47,391.56 2nd Otr L-20-812 47,128.98 3rd Otr L-30-812 290,452.45 4th Otr L-40-812 146,532.34 P531 ,505.33 3. Input VAT on importation of goods supported by a certified true copy of the IEIRD. 1st Otr L-10-C18 P153,61 0.00 2nd Otr L-20-C18 238,536.00 P392, 146.00 4. Input VAT on pa' ments to travel agencies. 1st Otr L-10-G2 p 1,100.18 2nd Otr L-20-G2 531.98 3rd Otr L-30-G2 550.09 p 3,246.07 4th Otr L-40-G2 1,063.82 5. Input VAT on Overseas Communication Tax included in payments to telecommunications service providers. 3rd Otr L-30-G3 P201.19 p 224.73 4th Otr L-40-G3 23.54 6. Input VAT on DST and local taxes included in payments to purchase of services. L-10-G7 p 0.91 p 211.42 1st Otr L-40-G7 210.51 4th Otr ,. 7. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by documents other than a VAT invoice. 1st Otr L-10-A1 630.31 2nd Otr L-20-A1 76,465.48 3rd Otr L-30-A1 3,572.90 4th Otr L-40-A1 2,004.53 p 82,673.22 6 Docket- Vol. II, pp. 1015 to 1041. 7 Decision of the CTA Second Division dated April21, 2009, Docket- Vol. I, pp. 478 to 481.

AMENDED DECISION CTA Case Nos. 7180 and 7279 Page 4 of7 ,. 8. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by a VAT invoice but not an original copy. 1st Qtr L-1Q-A3 3,533.11 2nd Qtr L-2Q-A3 45,990.26 3rd Qtr L-3Q-A3 77,137.56 4th Qtr L-4Q-A3 12,615.58 P139,276.51 9. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by a VAT invoice not issued in the name of the Company. 2nd Qtr L-2Q-A4 P2,187.04 p 2,187.04 10. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by a VAT invoice not issued in the name of the Calenergy/ CE Cebu/ CE Luzon. 1st Qtr L-1Q-A5 p 4,759.33 2nd Qtr L-2Q-A5 109.09 3rd Qtr L-3Q-A5 1,354.55 4th Qtr L-4Q-A5 1,074.99 P7,297.96 11. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by TIN-NV/ NON VAT Invoice but stamped with "VAT"/"TIN VAT" or the word NON" was erased. L-3Q-A6 p 409.09 p 409.09 3rd Qtr 12. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by TIN only: TIN- NV/NON VAT invoice; stamped/handwritten TIN-VNAT. 1st Qtr L-1Q-A7 p 7,084.64 2nd Qtr L-2Q-A7 10,558.08 3rd Qtr L-3Q-A7 18,127.70 4th Qtr L-4Q-A7 63,668.51 ,. 99,438.93 13. Input VAT on domestic purchase of goods supported by tape receipt but without the Company's name and/or TIN. 2nd Qtr I L-2Q-A8 ,- 484.60 I ,. 484.60 14. Input VAT on domestic purchase of goods supported by a VAT Invoice but without invoice date. 4th Qtr L-4Q-A10 p 43.64 p 43.64 15. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods not dated within the VAT taxable year. 1st Qtr L-1Q-A14 p 104,573.81 2nd Qtr L-2Q-A14 13,103.14 ,.117,676.95 16. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by a VAT invoice with changes in the name of the Company. 1st Qtr L-1Q-A15 p 190.91 2nd Qtr L-2Q-A15 152.73 3rd Qtr L-3Q-A15 8,035.53 4th Qtr L-4Q-A15 1,995.21 ,. 10,374.38 ,. 17. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by TIN only; TIN- V; TIN-NV/NON VAT; stamped/handwritten TIN-VNAT tape receipt. 4th Qtr L-4Q-A16 125.64 p 125.64 ,. 18. Input VAT on domestic purchases of goods supported by a invoice which are not SIR-registered. 2n Qtr L-2Q-A17 28,782.47 3rd Qtr L-3Q-A17 62,836.64 4th Qtr L-4Q-A17 21,028.20 ,.112,647.31 19. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services supported by documents other that a VAT OR. 1st Qtr I L-1 Q-81 p 5,589.40 I

AMENDED DECISION CTA Case Nos. 7180 and 7279 Page 5 of7 2nd Otr L-20-81 89,282.49 3rd Otr L-30-81 20,105.49 4th Otr L-40-81 17,333.13 P132,310.51 ,. 20. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services supported by a VAT OR but not an original copy. 1st Otr L-10-83 1,939.81 2nd Otr L-20-83 10,893.40 3rd Otr L-30-83 1,284.42 4th Otr L-40-83 19,191.45 ,. 33,309.08 21. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services supported by a VAT OR issued in the name of Calenergy/ CE Cebu/ CE Luzon. 4th Otr L-40-85 ,. 9,860.00 ,. 9,860.00 22. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services supported by TIN-NV/ NON VAT OR but stamped with "VAT"/ "TIN VAT" or the word NON" was erased. 1st Otr L-10-86 p 38,098.07 2nd Otr L-20-86 22,426.71 3rd Otr L-30-86 5,054.71 4th Otr L-40-86 7,621.82 p 73,201.31 23. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services supported by a TIN only; TIN-NV/NON VAT OR; stamped/handwritten TIN-VNAT. 1st Otr L-10-87 ,. 3,449.09 2nd Otr L-20-87 13,942.00 3rd Otr L-30-87 1,680.85 4th Otr L-40-87 20,387.09 p 39,459.03 24. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services supported by a VAT OR but without OR date. 4th Otr L-40-810 I p 136.20 ,. 136.20 25. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services not dated within the VAT taxable year. 4th Otr L-40-814 ,. 1,471.91 p 1,471.91 26. Input VAT on domestic purchases of services with changes in the name of the Company. L-10-815 p 557.45 1st Otr 2nd Otr L-20-815 4,175.00 3rd Otr L-30-815 2,558.45 ,. 7,290.90 27. Input VAT on domestic purchase of services from previous NON VAT suppliers but which were subjected to VAT under RR 1-2003 supported by TIN NON VAT ORs but not stamped "VAT-registered as of January 2003". I L-30-8-19 P 32,429.95 I p 32,429.95 3rd Otr 28. Input VAT on importation of goods supported by an originaiiRIERD and BOC OR not dated within the year. 1st Otr L-10-C3 P235,075.00 P235,075.00 29. Input VAT on importation of goods with supporting documents not in the name of the Company. 1st Otr L-10-C4 P30,759.00 P30,759.00 30. Over-claimed input tax on domestic purchases of goods/services due ,. 3.38 to erroneous computation. 1st Otr L-10-E1

AMENDED DECISION CTA Case Nos. 7180 and 7279 Page 6 of7 2nd Qtr L-2Q-E1 8.60 3rd Qtr L-3Q-E1 15.36 4th Qtr L-4Q-E1 484.25 1"511.59 31. Input VAT on purchase of vehicles with engine displacement of more than 2000cc. 1st Qtr L-1Q-G1 1"141 ,272.73 P141 ,272. 73 32. Input VAT on payments for printing services supported with documents other than VAT OR. 1st Qtr L-1Q-G6 p 818.18 2nd Qtr L-2Q-G6 172.73 3rd Qtr L-3Q-G6 2,167.64 f" 3,158.55 ,. 33. Over-claimed portion of input tax arising from forex rate used on foreign currency denominated purchases of goods and services. 2nd Qtr L-2Q-J1 162.98 ,. 301.03 75.05 3rd Qtr L-3Q-J1 63.00 4th Qtr L-4Q-J1 34. Supporting documents not available. 1st Qtr L-1Q-F 1'"232,910.24 ,. 812,618.87 2nd Qtr L-2Q-F 187,863.52 3rd Qtr L-3Q-F 83,320.95 P3,084,87 4.35 4th Qtr L-4Q-F 308,524.16 TOTAL In sum, petitioner is entitled to a refund or issuance of tax credit certificate in the amount of P23,489,514.64. However, considering the SIR-approved closure or cessation of petitioner's business, the Court finds legal and equitable basis to grant the requested cash refund in favor of petitioner. WHEREFORE, in light of the foregoing considerations, petitioner's claim for refund is PARTIALLY GRANTED. Accordingly, respondent is hereby ORDERED TO REFUND the amount of TWENTY-THREE MILLION FOUR HUNDRED EIGHTY-NINE THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED FOURTEEN PESOS AND 64/100 (P23,489,514.64) to petitioner, representing its unutilized input VAT for the four quarters of taxable year 2003. SO ORDERED. ER~.UY Associate Justice

AMENDED DECISION CTA Case Nos. 7180 and 7279 Page 7 of7 I CONCUR: .sl.~c.~~~ JuKNITO C. CASTANEDA, JR. Associate Justice ATTESTATION I attest that the conclusions in the above Decision were reached in consultation before the cases were assigned to the writer of the opinion of the Court's Division. :o"" <;Z............:~c. Q.d';::�. Q. .ffiANITO C. CASTANED.(VJR. Associate Justice Chairperson CERTIFICATION Pursuant to Article VIII, Section 13 of the Constitution and the Division Chairperson's Attestation, it is hereby certified that the conclusions in the above Decision were reached in consultation before the cases were assigned to the writer of the opinion of the Court. Presiding Justice