CTA Case No. 233 (Decision)

J\.M'UtiLlt. 01~ TH~ t�tiiLt.P��tNt-1 COUHf 01 1 \.X At,.PEAU) At"JU...t. �� � t!ti ner, -r - c. r. � L � 2~3 ~fr - -- -- P n nt. - - - x� .. � - -- �X 10 np 11 - nt 11 e 0 1n n 1 d in tit t - ti t 0 il � ino n 11 h rive rd �I r n- I rr at 21, � t lly CUI � ens a � t ion r at the rate 1 re f � by ,, tpt �1 �� �� � . ee. ~ In v of t � ac � �� 9X il$1 f he c atego.ry t lch itl er's long d en incr aaod 5% to f

� .... 3 t t l v lu r � ct on n tin .< .. ~1" , � t t p .. 1n c� L107

IS � .r.A. c - -� 23 �� �� f �oll tiona � n xt day i c 1 r ceipt (Exhibit c d1n::~lY t d n epte b r 22. 1 � 1 d nt , v r. hl t � f ht h d- te 1n 1 of h"s 1 y f r t h e ensatin tx d th t f ctual nt. cc~ in l y, n th prop 1t1 n th t t nt as in f et f f ct d S 1,1 � th t of c nt t o: t p avail ing on t d t hnuld t tion r ' s e r. t M nf h ( xh it ) e v r n t y nt t tin t x, m r p t i� h h t th s c:on pt 22, l d pp r ntly � n v th r to ~ho b t h c a h fl h t r ct!c h ~ 11 - t .t' p. � 0 v col� n er '. h ny y r at p � � d s nee t t 1 �- 1 1tness� � ccul sttll t in 1� tlti r' � nt �� v ng n in aec e it ~r 2ct!c � n ct, in the t t ny y s it tv~rn r1 r in- lpal the rec�iv st tee! ha no � ial nt ar t i c u l pa nt l'e1n eferr as av!n � n t lly 408

l � � 27~ .. <G - yh ��t� It a ee 5at!~fact ly 1 � that fo an � p ~t r or e t c:ust . y the f ll _ ing ~ � � foll d 1n t o r . ' nt nod. ~t�~ � � tu cr cuat � entry end d 1 t on Cus a 47 � { X bit 2" , P� ..... � r c.} n r � ,� of ...ntt~nal en � . A. c.) , an \& t ata � th t l n te ere � , the afM"� �� t - ! th �� c - l v le f lad1n � 1 ��� c :t1f1 ate and � re then .. f tnt n �� n ft � c ..,pu ti duly t 1 l~, tho d. eu t a.r n sn ly l't ped t � entry. t h, f at 1v1ai nd ith t he au rt zt t ffic f t � Coll ct ��1 n t1 1nat �o t �� ex t109

� -- 1v1 on. And fth. th � t en rz aght h v1s r tl r ma f � t Cu eg al f t t ut 1 It � t dt t nd y- ...nt for cu t n int n 1 rev n s � ot nd �c� � ntil t 1 st at cc dd y a I in t t t nt 1r t t� !nt n 1 t � t � ax c n rin av t v 1 r� ,. 1 d .. � 1 th ln fact r � 11 n tp - n 1 .� n "� 27. 21 , t 1 1r ��� � 1- 11 1� ns X ld rate 1 n n ra � 0 ' 40

19 h ld r � nt lt. 1 � ich, at th - t, � !nt nt � ff c r � h lti- ply cr y t r te f 1 � H v r , inc t dy en cr �f h .) 41 2 tfr)~

c � 233 ��� -- c 1 � val! xe n Y he ia ate pres r o d n 1 ct o. 588, ch �f t 1 te. ut t f et f ah i1 n t ve n tt 0t t �to ����� r ... p.l nt t c! uh with r r v 1. ly . � f t d n pt r 2 � l 1 1 ly h f t n nf t 1 l 11 � hol ec r ln 1 � 413

.. 414