Legal Insights

Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.

Showing 48974920 of 5,609 articles for appeal

Ombudsmans Discretion When Courts Defer to Anti-Graft Investigations

Philippine courts defer to Ombudsman findings in anti-graft cases absent grave abuse of discretion. Learn from Morong Water District.

CBA Extension Protecting Workers Rights Beyond Contractual Terms

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on CBA extension beyond stipulated term and benefits for employees hired after expiration.

Reasonable Doubt Prevails: Insufficient Identification in Drug Sale Conviction

Supreme Court acquits drug sale convicts when police cannot identify who sold marijuana, applying reasonable doubt standard.

Finality of Dismissal: Why a "Without Prejudice" Order Still Becomes Final After the Appeal Period

A dismissal without prejudice is still a final order. After 15 days without appeal, it becomes final and executory, barring revival by mere motion.

Interlocking Confessions and Kidnap Conviction: People v. Dela Torre

Explaining the interlocking confessions rule and how it secured a kidnap-for-ransom conviction in People v. Dela Torre.

When Defense Falters Distinguishing Homicide From Murder IN Philippine LAW

A Supreme Court ruling clarifies how treachery elevates a killing to murder and why alibi fails without proof of physical impossibility.

Reckless Imprudence in Vehicular Accidents: Negligence and Penalty Rules

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on reckless imprudence in vehicular accidents, explaining negligence standards, proximate cause, and penalty imposition under Article 365.

Malicious Prosecution in Philippine Law: Probable Cause and Malice Explained

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when a failed criminal complaint becomes malicious prosecution, requiring proof of lack of probable cause and sinister motive.

Delayed Baggage Claims: When Airlines Avoid Moral and Exemplary Damages

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on when delayed baggage delivery triggers only limited damages, not moral or exemplary awards.

Pacto de Retro Sales in the Philippines: When a Land Sale Is Not an Equitable Mortgage

Philippine Supreme Court ruling clarifies when a pacto de retro sale stands as a true sale, not an equitable mortgage.

Recanted Testimony in Rape Cases: Credibility and Victim Protection

The Supreme Court clarifies how courts evaluate credibility in rape cases, including the role of recanted testimony and medical evidence.

Navigating Reasonable Doubt When Conflicting Testimony Leads to Acquittal in Criminal Conspiracy

When a key witness contradicts himself, reasonable doubt arises. The Supreme Court acquits one accused in a murder case, clarifying conspiracy rules.

Balancing Justice and Procedure When Technical Rules Give Way

When a defective notice of hearing cost a man his appeal and his liberty, the Supreme Court showed when technical rules must yield to substantial justice.

Orchestrating Death: Conspiracy and Accountability in Murder Cases

A Philippine Supreme Court ruling shows how a hacienda overseer who ordered killings was held liable as a principal under conspiracy doctrine.

Service of Summons on Corporations: Due Process and Jurisdictional Validity

When is service of summons on a corporation valid? The Supreme Court clarifies the rules on proper service, substantial compliance, and jurisdiction.

Breach of Banking Duty: Bank Liable for Mortgage Fraud Due to Negligence in Identifying Impostors

Philippine Supreme Court holds bank liable for mortgage fraud when it failed to verify impostors' identity, applying the last clear chance doctrine.

Credibility of Rape Victim's Testimony: The Requisite Standard for Conviction

In rape cases, the victim's credible testimony alone can sustain a conviction. The Supreme Court explains the standard.

Reversion of Fraudulent Land Titles: The State's Right to Reclaim Public Property

The Supreme Court affirms the State's power to revert fraudulently acquired public land, even after the one-year indefeasibility period.

State Immunity vs Personal Liability: Defining the Limits of Official Authority

The Supreme Court clarifies when public officials can be sued personally despite state immunity, using the Lansang v. Court of Appeals case.

Protecting the Defenseless: Upholding Conviction for Child Rape Despite Claims of Unreliable Testimony

The Supreme Court affirms that a child of tender years can be a credible witness, upholding a conviction for acts of lasciviousness against a minor.

Circumstantial Evidence and Eyewitness Testimony in Rape of a Minor: People v. Torejos

The Supreme Court affirms a death sentence for rape of a three-year-old, clarifying evidentiary rules on witness credibility and circumstantial proof.

Child Witnesses and Acts of Lasciviousness: The Dulla Case Explained

The Supreme Court clarifies when a child can testify and how acts of lasciviousness differ from rape in this 2000 ruling.

Protecting Childhood: Supreme Court Upholds Conviction in Child Rape Case

The Supreme Court affirms a reclusion perpetua conviction for statutory rape of a nine-year-old, clarifying rules on victim credibility, alibi, and damages.

Unilateral Rescission Limits in Philippine Contract Law: PNCC v. Mars Construction

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on unilateral rescission, contract interpretation, and damages in PNCC v. Mars Construction (G.R. No. 133909).