Legal Insights

Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.

Showing 721744 of 806 articles for abuse of discretion

Proving Guilt Beyond Doubt: How Circumstantial Evidence Works in Philippine Criminal Law

Philippine Supreme Court explains how a lone eyewitness's positive identification outweighs alibi in murder convictions.

Election Disqualification: Why Strong Evidence Is Crucial to Unseat a Winner

A dismissed disqualification case shows why clear, credible evidence is vital when challenging an election winner under Philippine law.

Unseen Evidence Unquestionable Guilt How Philippine Courts Convict on Circumstantial Proof in Murder Cases

Philippine courts can convict on circumstantial evidence alone if it forms an unbroken chain pointing to guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Senate Electoral Tribunal Your Sole Remedy After Senatorial Proclamation

After a senatorial proclamation, election contests belong exclusively to the Senate Electoral Tribunal, not the Comelec or courts.

Habeas Corpus in the Philippines: Understanding Its Limits and Proper Use in Criminal Cases

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when habeas corpus is proper in criminal cases, using a 1999 death penalty ruling as guide.

Ejectment Suits Staying Execution Pending Appeal in the Philippines

Learn how Philippine courts handle stays of execution in ejectment cases pending appeal, including the rules on posting supersedeas bonds and the limits of appellate relief.

Deficiency Tax Collection: When BIR Warrants Are Premature Under Philippine Law

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when BIR collection of deficiency taxes is premature, and why the OSG must represent the CIR.

Credibility in Rape Cases: Why Philippine Courts Trust Victim Testimony, Especially in Incest

Philippine Supreme Court explains why a rape victim's testimony, especially in incest cases, can convict despite lack of physical evidence.

Safeguarding Suffrage When CAN Philippine Elections GO Manual

When can Philippine elections shift from automated to manual counting? The Supreme Court explains in Loong v. COMELEC.

Unfounded Misconduct Claims: Protecting Public Servants From False Accusations

Learn how Philippine jurisprudence protects employees from baseless misconduct allegations and requires employers to prove just cause for dismissal.

When Courts May Reopen a Criminal Case After Evidence Is Closed

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on when a trial court may reopen a criminal case after the parties have rested, and the limits of that discretion.

Reopening a Criminal Case: When Courts Abuse Discretion in the Philippines

The Supreme Court nullified the Sandiganbayan's reopening of a criminal case against Miriam Defensor Santiago, ruling it was grave abuse of discretion.

Reopening a Closed Case: Abuse of Discretion and Due Process in Philippine Courts

When can a court reopen a criminal case after evidence is closed? The Santiago ruling explains the limits and due process requirements.

Reopening a Criminal Case After Evidence Is Closed: The Santiago v. Sandiganbayan Guide

When can a court reopen a criminal case to hear more evidence? The Supreme Court explains the limits and the due process rights of the accused.

Sheriffs' Breach of Trust, Integrity, and Accountability in Philippine Public Service

A deputy sheriff who failed to remit collected judgment funds was dismissed for grave dishonesty and serious misconduct, affirming strict standards for court personnel.

Grievance Before Strike: SC Upholds CBA Machinery in Labor Disputes

Philippine Supreme Court rules unions must exhaust CBA grievance and arbitration procedures before declaring a strike, citing San Miguel Corp. v. NLRC.

Strictly Observe Deadlines: Why Missing Appeal Periods Can Cost You Your Case in the Philippines

Learn how missing appeal deadlines or filing late comments can affect your case, and why courts may relax procedural rules only in exceptional circumstances.

Due Process in Employee Dismissal: When Can New Evidence Be Introduced on Appeal?

When can an employer introduce new evidence on appeal in a dismissal case? The Supreme Court explains the limits of due process.

Certiorari vs Appeal: Choosing the Right Remedy in Philippine Courts

Learn when to file certiorari versus appeal in Philippine courts, based on the Supreme Court's ruling in Asian Trading Corporation v. Court of Appeals.

Dismissal of Court Cases for Lack of Prosecution: When Is It Justified in the Philippines

Philippine courts may dismiss cases for lack of prosecution, but only for valid reasons. Learn the rules and limits from a Supreme Court ruling.

Bail Denied When Evidence of Guilt Is Strong in Philippine Capital Offenses

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when bail must be denied in capital offenses and why trial judges must summarize prosecution evidence.

Payroll Evidence in Philippine Labor Disputes: Ensuring Fair Hearings for Employers

A Supreme Court ruling on payroll evidence in labor disputes, protecting employers' right to present original documents for fair hearings.

Court Discretion and Deadlines: Why Philippine Courts Can Deny Postponements and Cost You Your Case

Learn from the Pepsi Number Fever case why Philippine courts can deny postponements and declare waiver of evidence rights.

Writ of Possession in Eminent Domain: Why Immediate Government Possession Is Key

Learn how the Supreme Court ruled that courts must issue writs of possession promptly in expropriation cases under, even if the government already occupies the property.