CTA Case No. 1143 (Decision)

/ m II"t.H.: 0 T E PHILIPPIN.blo OOUR'l 01< TAX APPE.t.Ul QUEZON ClTI' . � � 11 -- � .... ..

' rt . ,I .. on tttt ... i. 1 w tl ~ f � .. 18

., 0 11. .l. e - tbt'ti et!U'l. .~1 ld , ur�u:s � i':t'C!' ( .t.:.l . ) I no . ) pr. a, u a k lu r.!cl:l� 't l, � to '(');.. 0 I pc ti.t OJr. r"" .Finance. n, riods fr 3�1 , ) 1 ;_ ~~ i� 19.

I .' 1 ;E 1t p: ti . .y .' or " ci 1 (.lOVr< in d �, ?'1' � ~o r ~ t . l t 1......,9 2, t9:;~~ t:o J' ~ry 30, 1S'tSOt r 1 ""tf: 1 1 ; . t <.; 1 t *: . (.) 1 t .. .a . 1.d r t �on .. rt.1~1 � 1 6t, �; ~ 20

-~Ji':n- 1 r� 11 J r ') v' 'h- t r !'� i 0 ~ .i f t - n h ri ' 1' 5tl .~..;:� J.~r ".n l1 y 7; .r, '<'t1: or ~w ~a ., 31 , ' - :i tt +} -, �use: ' �et on I. .t . 1 tb t -.. . ct '�� aid l a .� � t. -th . , _. ri.<l r.

.. � .. 1t � � � � . ' .. ;; 22 r

�-n� .:. c i th d ... . .. ' - t1ot (,.riU"t h�'1.'1 . ! 11 ':;7,.an .~...f� 1. 0"�'~!1 ) ) . ,r� t.x ;). "...",' Ql'.lft Q tt( ..of ti lt .f~:r r ' .. 1n . d~ Ju 1 21t f ', t '1 1 ,. 1' 1 f l t Jl'lo )! .tnt ,'j, r... cr t n t:1 H ur.;t , ' 26, 61 ,..� 1 t' � r,. r1 ,.. .. d tot .r ' l"'~ q .. r r� '- f.H t ( L:l ~-ourt .... ' c ~:t \ 23

~n� ..... " (?~ *"o t ,f .) r ~ ~l~ttr: t\lf r .. ~ ;~ 2""' 4. -

(t ) .' .. : �.. c {. if 25

... \\(�. 114 re ipt ~h , ~a;y , �nt � � ot� �' th t .l ~ d ~ Cl I 19:9. , , 1.9j~ t r - 3 , 196t. , ,.. ' f. . r ; r.~ U .o 'r t: U#.l. Oov � .r m r i ;~ 26 .' ;

� t ��' 27

I. � � J ;~ 28

�1 r ..... t 1 L ' ( ) h .. r (' ' -~ 29

� ot �j6 � u 11 . I tl ll n C\L ty .,.

.. .5 r~ !ne r ' 17 ' tlac .. 168 m tr t' r .. nd ""fld t i n ~t;;, ~ L"' ll ttt tl }''., $ tv y r �f> er t l Cflm"' or� ~� ~. ~.. r ..... "" c ot ~ � s r:r

,� r . ~- h.- ��� \.. . \t-��, Lf' �, :~ 32

� was evidence 33

... .. ' � ' cause of action) . 34

41rl~J! r�~ - C.u '-At~ tl .. ., 11 4- I rt~G~,. 0' 1 t .. t J�~ on 't'l f '*"t � '.~� [ ... ... � l:t t ...L.:n to �� 1~ t'l'fi ;~ 35

... / � - ' 36

' 1 / ' - 37

.~2 tn �- t tlo:; J:~h P t 1~~ . . � .' . ." ..,. � .u.." .....d "' ::n th c-.-<' ... t ue .on r "'h 3 1 95~ .:r � l , ".' t t� ... \ .a tl"CU r;r l'te t . t�-"'' (! �t~ . . . JA;.. \. ~ ... ..,l,..... .... ~1 38