CTA Case No. 215 (Decision)

I - .... '-.. -... t1 � � � �� � ! J.nal t, 1 � 1l �y f c � a 1 , n 11 78 1

- .... ... .. �., ' t i f � IIDIItmUHJ , R� ltDUt� 1 i I � � � t la 782

- � 21 -- 1 0 p1 c n � � ,. 783

� .. �� - 1 �� f c 0' n il t- r Ql ti Xe f I r ") . . .�) . n l � fo ' � � r, � � X� � 0

� . .. c �1 0 � 1 � � 1- erpaid as fr n- c , y � ll gh ' � r j 1 � i v y ~ .I 785 '

-.... � 11 l l ( v. t -�hil .. � � � � � p. � J. 1 � 1�o. � l 5 North C r1 Lv:m� ... l � 4 l tv} . In lin .,.oi , :au I 1 l ># llYJ r f, of fn � � l H ug. p t1 n c n l i fi st r 1 !si . of a wr .tt �or ri h t etition r file ~~ p l, l "" , C\.lu t 'O s n t h Vt t cl o 1 rio , by oxcluct ng 0 t t& :la:rrou by � h \ � er ..... rl. n ,~c:tion � � <.~ of t 1t ,- !on to cons:t.Cl nly � 1n � t ... 0 � �1 \ ., .. 78 6

. .r ' ... 7 ... X de ion n !... ne ad c t ""t ;;;,t} 0 th T ' lie a 1 1 t . Ci.S � n this sane ts:~u &V& d liear f r "i i � lytti$ i"'n cf . � ""56 in 4 to \: ... n v nu t . t tit h l' "n 5t 'l" chi e etx 'i aid an not to th 1/ f the 1,~ :""at i..,.pO$ � 2~' 6 , �� .,. r 7 8 7

X I 788

- .. :r. X 7-89

l: .. T.QnC e c:;onstr 0 old e. � &t! inn ere11"l ubj ct 0 th a. it\ X ., . .l'..tt 1.) "\.4 ec 0 2....- h d ~nd t ~ .,, l/2 v ",;,..N \,} pr �o:: in ... r (..,c -t f~t o . 1 I"~ er '!. j d �.l~'t!'l .... ~r by r n r ct oyir~ t. nt- t the ....... ... u p~lo ll p au t ct:t..!on 5 h l lot it n r v G � it. . ise d. �-th (; st ttr .... ti ion � .l ~ n �1 , � 'Ve 1 .�

. 6.hl'UBLIC OF THE PHILIPPiNES ' COUK.l' OF '1 AX APPEALS 1\l.lAN ll..A � � . .. .. - J � ... �v 79 1