CTA Case No. 2415 (Decision)

REPUBt.TC OF THE PHTLIPPI~E8 COC RT OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY , .c . ,. ?~ 15 � / I \J '") - X - ... -- . f;' - r ' .1. r it 0 -t ; -1 0 c � !' 12 3

l C:L 10.. ... Ct ..As�. � ..) 5 2 'ly ... t 1. '11 , tl1 r n- d t' ' bl I !' r< 1 C1' tl f' '

3 ~:r hun tn favl")r nf h ion fo r c~m d r.t~o .t Jd -c1sior pr�Y ng () ._, , _, ~' 1C'')'.:...). th CcJ:!ll!}i ..don .it" J! ,t,.stom a .r{:f0d~1'�d ~~c1sion ~. fJ m-� 1ng th ('; t.n {,ell"' ttl Cu 't .. s t'Hl ., b!� y 23, 1971, .t 1tio��u�1;:r iltt - �.oti.on f'or r .eons1d r ~ 'ti ;rl . " . id si n, '11. ~h r;o ion H3, 1:7?. t<~t:~ e ! id c "l~-' r c v,.,d by a, p t1tlonAr on tay 1C,17' '&".' � X 1 2 5 !.�

ur c :r t; th bl� G cj.,. r '\ e� r i I .. f. ~ .l // ',i\'l tt 'l l r\ � v. c ~ � 0 s b r1en h �� t r u e in . 0 :� 126

D~Cl~I.d - C'l' CAS , l~O . 2~1 5 th<" . hi ,l /, , h I' tj 't: - 1 'id !.eeasp1 () tr t>spor es . J :r t'i!'Jh a �tat th ' c&n Ci:Il- tt n hluo ll til t�lgti.t'. ttf'!.S a ..'" not sal tPd r . s onl;rl .c. t th t . t'o wh~n !.Ct:!f.l$ ~ wan ipprcht"..,n i'l by tb l t . ort ;�i stat(' that ~'. h d pr riot !$lY ~id"ned fl. r,obo n t tc> E... lo� 'bl-- . Q ,nl ci"n!'.ett r-: to 'bA lor:dod r.. n ~-h~ V(:!1.'10l � on tlte ; g 1 c1 � st1o:: th tr bl.n ,; r.a,l, c1~ >~tA '1 ' tes , �:.,:p i lllv~ a lHff~t"P� t v1.ew ecn- s: .r .nf th ��tt~ndlilnt o1 roum! tnncem �;f t~. t1. easo . on �s in qu,.,.s :to 9 "' ' ' .v n aJ r t! for h .. 127

(.T~G 1 :~a 0 + ..., CTfi Cf~,'\1.F, N(; . ~ 1 S 6 cargo iL1.c..h ' ' .., cone lt!d in th~ busf .~ � ~b n th~ ca r. ...... ttJ n to con.1. � t of blu . seal ciga r .tt s .1 tt at o bt1 lo.u( l':' on hi... v 1 i e . � .r t noultl r. t."' bo l ! r. i .~ S ction 2530( k) cf th ., �.H�iff 8Llt us .oms Ccd.$ it 1' . :. fact of nb j. g ti d ft)l' tn~ orvnyc nea (: t , 9e ~� NT: t I ir 128

Dc 7 1. l w0 h t . (; t (' � Ci , . 1" 5,197'�. c ~c 129