CTA Case No. OC-15566 (Decision)

J7'0BLIC Otl' H riiLI PI~ r � URT OF TAX APPEAL, MANU.... �� . � -n � X� � - � � � � � � .. - ! c nn � stitu 1 u 1c zn 1p o c l ct � t un � n cr t � L' t4 lv a s t c 1 s. l7 t 1n l .' t ~o rt el c 0 l� - � J 1- 1 a ( :2) t � 0 s t t 51, - � 230

231

n ch. ~~ � 0r n 1 i- c c a .c c{ � . ) w th f 1 n v~. fo . ld 1 t h 232

--4 �� J �t w� d '� Rl g dclr n d Ta -. t �fie j la - rmc , r� o. .. ~ 1 { X � � � �~� r c n h tr n d IJe 0:::' Ct . X�?j i c ... a1� r � !i 0 Ol le t . .}. - '� � � � "'g vr L ring h s st t 1 n "d . ,:, fir n � o n a"" t r c.}. .. ct :r�~ { xh. ... ...r of toe #' T!!S �- � 0 ' t� r f the t � n. ;d . � �0 c. n. -�� Cf'll 7. 0 ~ x turn lf of :a.:l � 46 .. n i� 0�' t \l 1' I,. X� r t;. Je lg g Ol.J C nd .1 c i...X � n �h Col 1 ct. of � t p.l � � ( h . ... ...p . ~0 ~ c. t �~ l :~ . l Iu � l ox "' � &i4l " v y.r. r ..i ',)., 3 9J

6 - y � J. 1 { � �� 0 0 �� .� �� 0 � 1 f � $ 1� � t .. � � � 234

J t.e _:;.J t ., ., \<Z "- ""t�! !;hV ,, � s~ u t ( ,,, t � .~ : .L .. ... J., -' t o.J .( tr �: t. 0. � 01 ' t ~~- 1. � � �t .. .~-n,.I, r.: ,. � ~':1 i. l. l .. ~ .' e..1: ~� r. . .~-11 " L � I. ''i � .1:' .l 1";.1$ 9 i!~ . "'� r .u t!i-'"' I..� .. Vi.:: �( t.,.: '! . Fronton , "' �� .,_ ? �. . 1l �...t �' �'� ''"""" ..> 2 35

fl ���.. i � 1" 7 �� � 1 X , 1 -:. t ...... �i . l 1 �I n ... 236

' � ., .v�.&...~.r 1l ~ .... - r ~ r� � tI :.0 <! "!.�~ ~.. � t Q ut i in -e ,, Q cl .~ Ill ~u t' ... , �it ..: � .... l .i.. � L� � � ,\. .' s t'. : ( � to 1 'I -� � �.- ., ~ ... $. � � i..t ' �i 1 �.' 237

. J . .. � l th the u 0 � t 1 1 � ' t � $c h VI: 1 l t. .r. 238 r tp

$� t X 1 : 1., .� i� 0 i GU ee o t;.e ad l '.~ t X l l �. '� o� l . li 1 s n. ii t-l a an'o .'..{., ' no~ 0 !:~" ti nt p- tor s 1 1 em � 'fn t .l ppoin �Gl ..J h ' s. uty ~.: n f..t- l �� J'o d �rf. 1 ft 0 �r. t �uct i 1Iai .! f .i: th ~ ~co~. t t} - ,. ,. -..,., Ql �l )l� ir , J. , !Oto s t �. !-� -l ~e � 7C I~ r � � t r ~1 lt i 239

~i �. �.;l .... tJ i � � nt l t !� 24 0

J .. 1 1 .11 � ot i n 1n n pl 0 l 13.... h .. � 'W t .\ c nt i� 241

.. 1~ - l J- ce t ltt r .in zan 1 te ti t c� J � -l e d nt � n �... t. lc u . o or �� �7 ;.l "' �� _.e. ence, de- ~ 242

d 11 n . " \i � <m .1 l c n :rv l �� c to , ,. � � ,, \~'ilt~ t ... _.[' s '-ol. ( C li".l� ' 1~ � ll4...-. j . .., :.c � n � � � 0 � .n , .\ ,. 24 3

... - l ~ ... .-e ~- n ta th � v t .l-3~ ..ti:. ;. .����������������� ~ � �������������� , �t �. ��; st .-I. 244