CTA Case No. 2859 (Decision)

.RE U f C OFT H.llPP1SE.8 Ct ~ Rf OF T\X APPEAL8 QUb.6uN CITY L.��~ . 1.� ,Tl {f ;1jr; t'u!i, t '1f'� - --� -�- --- --J !J..l 55

u � ..~.;c .JI . .:s 0 . ,ct . " � c.~ Jl..J . ' a~ - ' ... 1 ':! 1 ann tb ; r1 o iul .. : ov~ sic P� r n , ,- r. a y {'I e he . a.. !ln . ~,, ,~� 'r,:t,l"' ' �.,ou'th ~- "'\1'1 ; ... 1 .. te d cf 1 ' ~L :'!!! .. ' 1"" llv ll5 6

!JM! ,1 ~ - .;t'A t;A~ �, ' � 2 .... ;9 - 3 ... 1 .... i h 1 to 1awan, t rr rial t t the .�. c_\' .... p ts 0 W!U bt! 1 Nl . Jan<-'ayint. . ' tl Ta - ��~ .w In �a~ a.l 0 th~ p tron t tf:L e SR1t1 ._ , o;c ag o!' ~1 ~ a r ~e? ttiV'I!l'tO,.:� to, t., y. i~. 1 s.sel, t t1~1o .r Pit 'i to l atro.. in that t:b.e ~j 0 .~..�.. y g utho t , pa tieula l ..... tary lear !\ u t t ' :ro h , r r: l, y si � � "hll'!n. ;�",1(i v~ssel ,.. r ri v~d tit l..ah� :l"i , �b�'t _, ;�,-cal :.;,�..sin , .. u I in"' � ;_� U,."lV ~( 1n.r. _ u ... ,,. �;r. bap.; ./ r (' ~ ...~ug t ::' car L.t!~U' !a t fj~ 2~) ' . 4 ') ' 7, 10'75, or th " tlf "'l" nlo 1n . (~ e 1 ~ J.. 't :air.h i n 1"1"iV~Yl; &i bo.n~ an oe . in .. 11 n a. tb l) hat th. , 1~ 1 ysi � to ill �: al (~) .}l, th

'l - 4- 1ol ..iotl r t l t 1974; (l) t J.t ' et r 111 ~�~�1\lly ele.,orti ~.,. suw r wa inim-1 to . a"tio al I t il!of'& �t � � .3 ; (it) - "'' t t t tte � n �ru 75o, ' 0 .. h~ .s~ ,.1 a te 1", 1"11 ... ~ l-!t1. und .. r p Ol) t-�~ be. d in t e aEC t of 'fl92 t ~. (' . ac, t c y be n pl ~ tbG 1l"t0d1 r tn. e. u .r :ur. t r.:s . et)i~ essel ,. � ( i.)' . .J.. .. ' 3- ?;n �~U 1!1 i t t � ag :~1::\st th~' y 'h 1 by th~E! ..e11~�tor o .:u o s � !' the :rt o �.:am oa .. --ul., 2 , 1- 76 h .(1""in". nd r .orfrdt r tb~ Oo er~ ent . 1976 af'> i i t . for d.1sno i+::ton i. () only is ~. 1tu . r r i lat ""

... ~ ... :ta~if'f and JutJto s ,..icd � , ~t:t on r ntends tb:':lt th ,. ga. on J~ary 1, 1975 in ttde e s , or 'P:trior to FttHsrua~:v '21, 19?5, 1a not p~ s,lizc by P '""'1dant1al. nee!" es N � S19 ~nd 65'9t that tb~:r,g; itt o law which expm~&ly p'tob:U:d.t~, the e pert~t1on or su!'1ar ~ fo ~d � eoun~:r e1\! �h1 f'i'(':~:q~:n~~ el" lef,al '~nti t.i~a otllt.:ir than tb )td.li pin� i.,xeh~ .~ ,_ Co p ny, lnc � J that t1r1ot- to culd lA~""I"'Qft'U t.h~ forfei tt r. ot the 1�/L ,, Nttgro~ star . (/ I*"'' 1 turthe.r ont l'ld�~d th� ,t th~ V~S$ 1 is not ub... a oalY ve.st"'~l:! u unl rullv in $ 1mpo-r t1t.:m ol" ~xpe tation f ar�t.tel ~s, o tn ~nViy:!.nR llttt~/or tl'i..u ~~, ning ecntr ln:tnd l" amu glfF'd arti-.::1(' s na J 5 9 Jo.

t .. ' .. 6 - t �, no s~s i~n , . control of tb.e c nt l � :as@im~n; r the a s �1 e "\Up �rvlsto an vno oted a if' he 1s �n� , fjnoes of th1 s e � ru nplic & .io. to f 1 t1 r o~ ttl o � 1 1.n � e eon in t ~ veaail!l ou ��tion i . that o .s �w "'�und in"fo ed and jt 11 g n 1! r . a esae1 ": ta !I' ~ne lt !o s .1. . can b lP. f:d from hi., s on .ent, iff - c s Coil . t th. "'�~ ct :hc-.t ..... e 0 of t off t!t nb 'l' -~ 1 e for or f :rf .i t.Ut'-.:' .�1t1 v ss.l i:ind .1r� nd i t tin!. .h to h & comrn n a ie hi., or til ti th 2,) 0 '!H'! ~ sni() d 1ve t 1a,

- 1- 1.n .,. . � . 1>1/L � Jcg:ros �"�.art tt qti. f!"c tn t " tand. c.t t Q ~t ~nc or tne 1 � nv lved in tb1.;;> e .rt 1 n, +nc l tv r as m.f.!,...� �h ""'... i ri �. tit"'!\ ot to 'l fH~ 'I; "" Ve9sel nut i('~e l te ~~ .o lea(, hereo l)� h 1 e .artiol-s . \J;1.1e1! el1ar r.'j t!'te ..,$ Wa:S U$9 ... r t fi 1 rte uS Ik .ord; ]!..~ _ _ p � /1, ll", 1� ce _ ~ (3) mont :r. du t � e.arter � ty. t' �. ten . d h1 0"

' � Jt - pflltit1otUtr ~it~o l.tim ~~n"� � .,d til'l.'!l aet el" ete: .nmm1t- ted - y tb~ c -rterer shtntl'i rte��~r, in !aB:r s� ns&, be attr-i utabl te, r a<i"f rs~ly tfe~t the l'H:-ti.t1on~r y d~V!~~1on m;,.de b~r tbe v sa 1 rom. its 1 tend - d oe~l d stin t on te � !{)re1r; J10� t, or to .,. bn,1!n, f:ahat'\., tbe't'eat, w ~ navel" p"!.O~-a by tb-1'1 n'Ztiti.on~.,. . :rh~ lac' ot kr: ~1�~ �t!' .t pt1�1 fion r or th~ fiY.portat. Ql\ o f th _, ~a:r -tn que�tio wrH; e n�i:n~o-d b,-r nD l ~? ... s than Ha si. <il'l h ms~t?l:t aarl two (~) t er v�:itrte-sses, t1.rthu.r s a.y ;,:t .C! A11ton o 'i.hr a, at'lt c-oMequ~ntly, tor l Z' clt o.f nrsviotts kno'Wl.�1df!~ th ~or i'lt1tiorw wa ... lea -ed 'Om detearrtion by the f\., art~nt of fitJ t -t')tH'll z, July lt 7l~, pn . 14(}, 1~~, Custots$ �-. ~e.\ thu.H~~"l Hase1.man ver \4~~ 1 lm~w his oblir;~tions ltttder the enar-t:~ partv t~lher.ein he bottnd .! 13-e:lf ' 0 l $1) the esnftl onl . in Ph 11 ~pin& terl"itotlal ""-'"t "1"$ :>M not .o load p.rooi i t d al"t1eles �r g!>~" ,_ . thereon , The . ll�~c:l~!c lnstruet:tons to hi..: flls..tron -ila.nday1ng not -.~~;.o GJh... ~te th-P vass-Pt 0 1 t~t e terr1 to al vater , whillh a~t w �~ ever eo t:ra- di ot thin , la.rgely on aeeount of th !\ill st p~ !is~ .n \

... 9 - ' rtd eont 1 er h 1 g1>a t. d to , aa ean 1'1.'1' th 'I 1'� �f'lo tn � e � t .r par y a well as the 'P'P v r:r din6 0. l\l � r ~ 1 tible J r Vic - ~or J lo, o-v tt , . . t1.e i~J ~~t . fomrtco p lt t1p' !' r ri to L ' �hi~~ i~ 0 DO~ he ~ in '1 �c 11 . t Sta '' of u lif.1.�:wll Pl' 1 ' .. ::~ . '1. ,_ .;.:i. C � t. � . - i-71 t � 8.. � ' - 972) icll 1 "e.-:: !"(;;{~ j 0. 5'79, ~:t ~~tiv r ") 12, 1 t tll >'.) "~ 11�"~ y, h .'V h r g t to l ~ 1 sour 3 ..o t ~� uth 1 �"1 i t'e ... i t y , it 0 92 � � 5' - '� t to

- ... '! ... � en c ~"" ( ) � 1 tt" f ve i "" � f i - +t~ "'"'-~t. I ~ .,. .j, ' t 1t th r

.- � C~ � ;I ... i l ~v~ � .c 0~ l nud h .I nl rA f .:: h 4.1 .,..... c c c i l � J�. ud .1 1

- .... ..., f'ic f! r, e ~ a "4_1_ er iW nit' lo �"' ng ' sel ' ,.:.,;,;.Ji a ticl�-ti - r 1 i~ :r t n0 s. &n �111 I> 0 $J ~ 1 en .J. t:!C f ~hi~ 't 0 t � (ll e ~ er:; p ivy c t e 1.1 act 0 ~ icb .s e ove ' i+ m t ... sertt �~ e!' :-t .n 1 . t on~ ~ b '"�U. th otual 0 e of .1!' e r JJ1b ~ tot � .nl' 1 .. �n i! ntro or e A i.t t (.':! ,h~ o;;,s to the lo rri .it "" .' � .. ?~ 0' . ... )11 . ) Und .. e '1'1 pre fl:. lol t ,.,~ ..o ~t n emt a net It r, r ~ ?~. S:; l t - ~~- r igh ,ntu in� of' "1 ( 1.) 11! .:. 110. . .. e'i... t ;~ . � t 3} ~t � :$9 .o�,, .37 ,� . :' . 1, , E� 3, .! .t i 6 � 6 v� r th- Ov e:rs .nd, tn ~ kno��'l "~ n.~ly, th e ti-ten .. ti s .tb, 0 f � ' 'J:nv.1 11. . where b� h~ CO.""'~ t ht j,i. ' u.n� .r o ..� ~ "':~ ... .... a "y ..... ~. exclu~1 ve

eDE.; ....I�f.1..J.(Jf,.i;,,..-3'!!. no . ~ 9J is y 1. - 14- ... l t e tb .bl te 11- > b1:; t.b1p 01* ly eon titut .. � r er tf.l j t. !y th e1 t .. i , nt Cf' r I pl~ ont :;; ;. o mm . ~o., 1. -~� eb . lf., 1r� 77 1 t to :1 t ~re .~.:iOul ve ra d ., tb. ttl:} .~ or th r th... � llFg�l u. of his a n r.u-1 us ill or 1 the c 1 ulii 1. e c m�.on c 'rri r , 1 an~~ r 1 r-. ey t subj4et �~tl used s 1 n .11~ c ve;- j 5 b c u~ 1 k .pn ~d to spe it-J.l in a e th s nl in I in t .g b~ttv s of t � . � ulr., in sor fu t. t of ffai ...fir ..., &r hts -~1'""'t � 11an3 r of. t 'l 1 a ;), on .-rol no. t'4"" th t' illl':!. :;l ~ s 4.1 t .,.n co 4. 68

1 t t1 i t . 11 6 r .l'l c .. (

... 6 - . ,; m... � C 1 I' ~f �''\. /' -:') ' ... ru � '>. j 1� 9.) t .. t :!53 J{ ) 'We I" thr; op-t ion. � !I(! � ill� a.t ct t te 'b 2 ){)( ) e ~ ct� ttu~ �h�' th d s itt n i� tc t sij.ice r 1 I. ��nd to r vail lv~n t �:.1 .(0 1 .L f> ,If --~ � ] r, in ... 0 J:.~ hi ' .;1 'l lntJ. u h 1t"" I ;(j of ~ 'hil b el, " ..o ..1111o 'r 1. n~:: d o '!or s 11 t t on y i f t! .. r 1 er. / is ,. tn l. . 4 j .... t ' the 111 ' ' :t

/ .. r i'!"'UJ� ' - ��. ~ �� i t � r~f v� 1 ... 4 )/"'"'1

'l - 9- , f t ..

;� ~ ;., - - 20 .;<\I. (1 ~ ~ v -' 0 rint;; t .. 0 e ..~ w s- l'.t rt ( 3 �) � 4 / 1 I""'