CTA Case No. 436 (Decision)

i!-'YJ'\1 ' 01 1 AP.P~ NAN ~LA , .T.A. C .. 0 - -. - . . - . - . -- . � a n 1 f� {B , � �J: � "i.UJ e 1 l � .. p 1- 1 t ref i fl= wi t sw ' \) 1 .t :l' 9 t 1 lt Pin � thi en ll a ,. 0 n n 9 .... � 1pn h '' u t s� ~ 11!. c. r..t 1� d tD t ,/JI!' - 3 9

... .. (4 i f dol � i. n �o ot �� � d n off,. t l 'r PP nt ( .,) 1 {' } .:''hilip the 0

t J. i.c 't l"".iC1:: ac~ � G 0 t � � � � � a �tn~ � e n l 0 y i (1 t t f .~.r .al it. � i.. o.r O<:.t ' � .c: . ) d tc l:C i .e ..... ,, 41

� ... . p1 a � 1 0 p �, . , .) t �� - f 1- , 42

� -- ' is c t ion f the (.; .,. � t d oz � t 1 .r ,, 4 3

� 6 ... .....__.....__.._........._.__....._ _...._ _......._..L......___.....'

- 1- the r of th ea 'W f:in ' be lY Ott t th t . etiti f ,r . it of l. up .. lf 0 l h bid � ni.t '. .u o;r p n rh �. H., -c- c h ar e,. ) nc. t ~ p(ftlding tt r � ' . ... 4!lo ~18 ' � � nt 4� .allj.l, h� au lt {' � ' .... ~.(. . ~ c ' ... o, II J � � #. err� c ,. ) e J -h l t of xl' . 0 � c bold in oic s ( �xh � p. �c . } n ct r p r:t n nt p .P r to \.t 0 �, co � 1 qu ti n ( �xh ,l , P� "' c ; ~ x.t'l. t pa;tit. �nt � oy ti ~ id d .t- n ��� PFl of 1i t eould not ti , VG � ad �i r \') pl r or . �Ck. G y ... T 01. n tor .., t i ~ ': , ~\ . X' n .c ,, 45

.... J-- ~ .y;(Q 1: durill~ tt a pe:rtuu un er xevl. ,w �. r over � �Je ncr& that the p titl. r n$ .r iJl a roaa c.�ncl twa ~,.he p tit.ion r hitJs J.� r ro o4,.h� t�~oa t.. ' l fit anr.tt l ... for "�r1 t_,c:. �~" .,Kn 'dcu9 ' p $01-J. , �� (; ...~ <# d to tho far.u��~x onsioLU: (.c.x~ � 1.� . f 1-~- l-3 , I-4, P� � 4�i1 "->.i.J~ ti~n tnat e tcica : fa1 in~ ial r e::: Jith �.-.Jr ~ to .:i,;:,. h �� c t fcre ., tie -~H t-d ,.. } .. "f�� n of f� X d x \.~ t .. ,, 4 6

' .. 47 ,

.. .' � � v �� 1 i' 48

�� - 1 l ... ... ) .. � ) � t ... �c 1 ,. � � ,, 4 9� '

� 'I l t - t n r .. � � � t c � � X lit i.l �'r.: .. �� � J. �

r � 12 ... l hel ~") ;. f m. J:: C#$ t f i 1n r . nd t �t to Ufi �h . houl.d rul - ,~ are uf th opinion ~ 1: t rake I u~ t f t "< ' � t ~- y c- c 1v t 1' ;- 0 \3. --~ , ..."""':, � .. 51 ;'

.... l.l"'.t'J.N~ '~-...PP.KAL!< � A I .f. � .� � �� 1'1"' "' ... � act�. 1 ... nl� rl ,. ' ,.:: .r . ,, '59 """

/ ... ... � 0 ... ca. Int r.rnl nt h t -(';: armU.c t l n � � . 53