CTA Case No. 1887 (Decision)

f I I I !' ( J:.Jr�.. r..__, I \ I !. I C.I. y �7 v i c I ' � I � 1' t ,, 19 0 '

10, 1' 1 � ' ' � �~ 191

.. . DE!J c or xpo o.t �d �

t 0 1 ' � h to re � ' J 1 J (c) - ' d 193

� ,1 ? 1 1 1a 5 Ul 1y tor. ( � 2�3,

7 e ( � ( \� 19 5

"' ' . 17 7 g a.t .P � ) b li �. nc t .. o1 .� e 'fi \ �� t�tl.li~ t si er t., r l l -cts ,, � itt of !' 19 6

.ru t 4 or 1 181 . ., e � v. c r e t s, �� � 951, i ly }' p . .. � ortun to i' . c1n s, oc � .tJ. ~io d p *' te, ell the eon .ont1ona of p .t1 ::to � � 1 VI or 1 . p of l o11 :zer in qtle tton, were spe.cif.tcally d 1 3 or .1s $ r r 1 de Ot r 0 l� pr ' t6 v +. a p ttcner p . .tlY' or J. ir~-ctly, 1 th diec t he tro t Y1 ve sel. 11 "h er u ap ct a ...... tr th s � b1 f r n . c () bo � �us of t c sto doeu. . nt i vtal io n 2530(e), ( -1), ( �3}, ( -4) ( -5) 0 0 iff t h by n je t w , 1 tr c l .r 1 c1 , t~tau e r el o� the shipme .s 1 ue t1on rto !! 197

I 1 87 C'll ' dt t . . 0; wlt 1 p ' �DD i b: c 1t1 te:r � ppO~tunits- to, lntrcdua .V1dGnO<A� to ::ro w.n tJ.lept1on , t b � 4m1 ti th. truth -� 0 ai Gli nd ( ~'""""'"~-U1 v_. Ca t \0 h11. osa, &t al., 76 Phil. 115'.) .. 1 :1 l ri~~'" t.~h t t of ..ncwl.Of.l: or 1nn�eanc on tb� t>Ut � of ~l ner 1 , te:ri in to:rte:l � r proo~~ ~~w~~ion J:' 11t 1 t 19 ,. ) I l � l" 0 itt a ptoce n~ �tli.r J.a o st: G 1m U � c tde . 0 � (U. , � . itlo existing Q t~O. J :21 � tl\sr � �Ol.*� ,. ~mP�t t'X'OJt J:l~ p!'JtJI1.. t ',, 19 8

7 tO 0 ti � Co t q" �:tlYt it c 'l!l it and Co , 12 () t1l tl rt �&a 'I l 1 vi b.eut f1 cons ptian tr,,. and l (l ed tner tr , it M � al<l � q,u. ~t1o have .r � f t ti 1 r .x-~llleJlnt �coop 0 at!v e a.s s o � bl:por~ a. od.$ tnt� r~t.1ri for �tli f"lt" t or o ofl.:t.c.ial or 1 as � h t tt.tJ 19l t '13'1 pt~ ' (f t1 1* ) ion eases :n.tion.Q a QVE3:t � 1 67. U)o n~ot�o o.f a his ti. �i r fj 19 9

. ,' l.l. ly t 1 � j 1 ' ( �iii th costs. ( ~~~/Uvt~ ,.�. 1 -200