CTA Case No. 18013 (Decision)

R&UHLIC OF THE PHTLIPPIN.ES CUUh l v.t ...X A.P.PEALS MANlLA . . --- -- - -.... --� w. � ... 1 '* .. l ) 593

y lf i l -

- .. ...., .. - 27. ,.. u D -... "c" ... e � ' y ty � 59 5

- 1 -. IT- � 0 tt. � ft. r: .Jl i o� J J. ... y i cn f. i 0 ... Q l) of id i~o r J to~ t!. t. � x v ... t-JX 0 'I d r 1n... th r.....tr d~ /$ all & f.: . il c cor to th� th 1 ll. l 59 6 '

� � :r ht f ll 7. a ,t , ax l � t' 1 o, j 1 ~ ( h 0 0 �l or 1 ~5 . 1\ � X � n t 1� 1 � 9 f l ;S,' , �- 597 I .... _j

l' - t � � .;I ru;� yy - � � r rc;i. - i� t n ni � �� 0 �x: o� on ch 1 y, t. � 1 ir + . a .ie � hi 598 _____ __..._............. ~--.-.....~----

- ... 1- ll t� 1 tl n :~.c1 nt 1 on t i fac l -.; 11.t y f ~!. f �nd l (\ll .c th� t tat t o! 599

1 ... 1 � - n nJ1 ... c c 0 c r . � � - � . 60

... 9 - � _____ ............... ?,.: ... (.). 0 1. ;

� ... t - �r r c 1 rt � � 0 � t t y � c ) ... - � 6 02

J 60 .._,. lb� s t t ' "'en �

� � 11 ., u t. v r 1� f 5j ki c tf 0 � I a sa- l 1 11 .. � � t .y t 1 in h - r. C ti'\I; f y 1 � d ;,y n� t 1 ff c � n� 0� �d r � X' d u:r ,... pa n 'fv f ~ t. � � - .1 � � � 1~ 6� ,.. 60 4 r

-- 605

_7 RE1U P" TH"I! ' HILIPPfN ~ C.UU h .L \JL � I~-.0. ~.t>&l..S MANLLA �� .. .. - �� ....... f 606 ...

-, _� --- EPUBLIC OF Tim PHILIPPINES CO URT OF TAX APPEALS MANlLA � . �. � .. .. � - (-!SIP - - �CJ�~q, ..,. .... ... ... � �� ___f!L �"'''""� �"' 0 Ql t ~ f.t, s� tl . "... ... �"'� � -6 0 7

=- .._... ... *

� .. , 609

} �� it 1a 610 \

0t � ... .. f � � � u � .. "" 'y ... 611

/ -- � � 612

EO -- ur � a ) 0 �� �� ll �{ i M � ""'l , ... �� 2" ca i I1 r �t iv1 ��� � l J:'i t f of ,.or ; no t ( $ j �( � � �an %'�� ( l s � � � ~)' . y n � 2. n "' r� .. i ) .. I { lt *A � , .t. 613 /

... "" � 6� � � ~1J ( en 1& ' 1 j t � �f r n ~ l~ rr 11 ... l �� cf t:. een :. t y ... 614

� . 1 ' � � v �1 � 1 tfo �. ,� y � 615

- . - 1 .. lt � �. .�-'J' . \ .......} � ! ... 1 y1 1 � 616

- t �, "" � � 617

� - � � � � � � \ 61 8 �

- t 619 - .- ....... __..._._. ,__........___�..'...

- - 1 620

� ---� � 62:t