CTA Case No. 1159 (Decision)

r RF.PtTlkTC Of 11I I ,r[ J ll.~l~b l>lf.ltT OF 'J.\. AiPEA L~ QUEZON CITY l r, cc -.. ..,. . -- c f r c 1 0 � 1 1 1 f 130

� ... � t� � ��� l � �� � �� 1 � !' 131

� i' 13 2

� � ... .ll.-. rl t u of' tn il 11 .. . . � �� � J�� 1 c ��� . . . ... . � ��� � � \!'0 ' 1I :Is ' !' 13 3

fr cr t .1 . d .r r . ( � 7; TA r � 1 ')"1' .. 'J . / .o f h, ,.9 ~ t c. l �r � t � f � � ~a 0 .f ill :t th r v. J � "' .. �� u !. v r 'e '' of '1. y 'l i

� .i .. 6 .. r �� �� � 11 ' ' t

"1 :\~""'(.1 v ct.:~ c _. : ."'~ � 11 7 h 1n tLR 1n~ �nt c (' anut etur r('r ,a r dl ' tl tl" nsr rr or net . ,, , ~ti cl s . 11 of i"J.f! let th 1j I qrJl l nnt 0 In y'* f h ett.r!l"�� 0b ('} l#': v s ( vi t . rr h 00 I .. ...... - ll I th ttu !...,,) ~ .}; f t t.t r or w1ti� ... f!�)"' t 1 nn r~. . ., ..4 ' 1~ J.'lLl. r :t ttl . ' �t,., .. .o ' t b ' l ' ~,... 7t� 1 nr :r nto.r , ... .'!l 1J' ~t':Hlt ' " . ' I fl. : . :' 13 6

a Df\.. .~. �. 1 l - C A C ,.;'1'1 O. 11 5 8 0 a � r or t n oll. ot fro .� sa opri r e r al . ~n in th 0 1 for r -cit d 0 h~ c . . on 1~ a' �� .r11 1 3 t 1 67 d urt in o io 1f ' o 1 rt: ' th Jr, t lu � or m 1.1 X0 , t y 1 6 cf th "9 Go ro t (; of ' 'J ot n r 0 1 (J . 1"' ... �' ell ',. r ol 1 Lf.ll 2 j 11 tX .c 1. h jn ol� in th.� n c' r () ig f 1 t'f ( ) t. c lV~ , r� fr ..111 j ~.n ~0 l ln �t ) tI ; ( 137

- X � 115? 9 t h1 l l ... n � t� �1 0 ... t.~ ro . ln tio. � b �1- no ~1 ;; ,13 8

t'Fcl(ao: - C'T.f c~ ~r.� N~. . 1159 aam, ~r . 1d t ha:- x~.ru t. s , t:l.o tn~ t manufactur1n~ r~r,-rs on1y ~P t ectu 1 ro~ ss of alt r .!ng , eom~ nj' .r , aldn"; or l" rf!r"'r1:o"" raw m t. r1 l 1 to ~-u ff: r r � or f!ni hr-1 r o,.,. ,. t~ 1r�t t ("; s not or nol;~rt th �sal or i tr1bot1,n to <~'t.ti>7"S th _ f'1n1 hn_. t'lcl<-:s.t. J.n , r ~�, et on 194bt) of 'h; , ""' nu. Cod~: a t manufaotnr r ,. m: hject tc th~ l~ti ta:x u �nclude�-� ~v-ry pnr on ho by Jihys:l.cal Ol" c;.., m.ic l Z,'t"OC~ s !llt~.re th " X� te.r1or t x:tv~ or fC'l' or� inn r sub~ ta.f'!ct< of ny r .,,.,. roduet p. D al DS ~r U S cr1rr oa l ��on- ~-t1t1on, or \who by any llUCh �nroees-s - t1;<tt tn qm~11 'Jot ny stH:n raw m.: to 1al o 1 armf~.H.l tll"Pd o.r ~~~u� .J ~l.ly 1f* ,..,. or t'Ct( ct of he ea. o o.f 1.l.ff .:r~rt k1 nd.. .\nd i.n snel rae 1r an . put to such r �rlr'd prcdn t.. in th l .. ori g:l na.l corld1.t1cn eo lld not h or ��nurectur d o reduoe s ~1~1sh ~ nrodnc � ~or 139

� 1 ;J" ' 11 .�t ( d ' ot y �t � h l"O :.n r 1 . 1 "l 140

- i. t t.. f �� of 0 tl c .. h, . -�c""J � t (' l p it It CI t 1 +� � �.'1U C rraterials were used. � � � �c i I t. t j, J' l . 5'6 , 1 l 66 t trolling. ax laws aPe ,e 141

- - c - t c l 0 1 cr � .) � ... ' � tJ 1- � ., � � - � � ��� ' ��� c � t .. 142

/ _;":ClS I 0~ C!A A~ . ; . 115~-~ 15 Cn :ta T:t t s .f'o 111 � �- . . . p "" � � 'n - ry � � � In i~ ted to n f1 cent t 1'L p 1" i , 1' b t c hi et rqlat � ,~ .o b d -ltv y t " tfu:r'nl:lhy .. J- .. ' tw ot �.f. r1 t 1onr r i : ' t') ,.. ns � d iUS .r con. i n -t. c0c+.r -r~ti ... . .:!tll t b net . tl r tor ' ~' 1- PrAn~ T� .,d t 0 p' y c~- ' o 3~ nt c c.....,' . � tn r~ pl:~ m~o,t� ndu ( fh 20-2v9 ( .,_' :tr--.;-. �- . i t c:bj c �~" l.S r.-"f' n nd n~ . . t:ion l-t t"l 1

... .~~ � 11 ; r, r' r 0 . 1 t l ), i ' r' - ~ t � � .. � t � '1 r � ' 1 � v� � - Hi~ 5 ' 0 ) � .. 1,45

... 17 t 1 1' � 1 .. 1 t y r i~ 14 6

~ :(::�uo ~ ... C'l~:~o C~..:1 , � 11 ~;9 ., �t ~ ,_- ".!.fir , 1 n~thJnE in h�!:. L Dflll rti.cl �l t! . �;:,o! d ' t r f�. <! l !'!Sf'd '. tlo;';l!l' .t �1(}�~iu ... ':It-~ c H .lr d' t) :L6 � t� .fe ' ~Vft:r'l �~; '11" 'th,Jt r . qt1_rr~ : Ct" l fl ... n .' by t l 5 on (: .X ~':lCh :tr3t.v. c 1.s ;i til fj,f~ i. d t~rx .. (t"'bn�~ v� Co rt .r . r tl<" itl c. � � (I ,. 1""- ., .'J t �. ��� ' it 14 7

.1 ~ � 1159 rr; th t l�1r t :" 19 .. Or\(' 1 Ol: J � ol~ t 1 t. . n h v.�.. t " t't! t 11y oli. ftl 0 r e .o \ 1{17) hfr ��' .... f; 1 ~Ql !tt ~ lv n ~t Qh t c c bl � nf r't i o r 'I'! .0 r~ i 1d 1.1 li n ,., th' :lO - f1 P. i l~t'iro . �t� .,'tl 1'3 ..~.�.: l 1 l(~� 0 c ~ ( �"'"'" Or'i t .. ct... .:r jt_ � ... .v ~\j c ~ �� J � � t .' � �~"" ~c. /"":' t l1l �� 'f '� � ... ~ .) .l . �t � f'r or g ct~ o.� o� t h :{ '4t 1 at. ,ne t �t h~ Ct'� o;" 1. f �,d ' ll ... '1 4 8 i:,.

- ~. cL 1 ~~~ ... Ci,'; Cr $i� i'l�; � 11;'9 :(0 rmt from th. e.r J ' Mllin .. vr1-<:tG or t .... 0 r� ,.-�oe;1�1Ctl'J ,. 1.'! lt-ril $j., os. .t "" �) a�t 'I t t .,.., tax ""�r � c; .. : co !' ln , ~ fr .1 Jb. . fH"< l 11 OC:I 1 ' 011' ' fl!ld . (Ir:.ul6 \! b r cc . ... \.. r� ll~C. .N" ot . , .v... ,. J � � ,, th (';., .r,.et? eSt of t. ' tJ'�~ � 1. �e 1 doe tJ 1U'Y t tb. ,.., .fl', is Ill''4"i 1J ans by whj.c �tt ;K ot n~tur o! h h., iO ,. tH''l.>J'l" ' u !And � t tl�~. ~ .'lf !) pl . i... 17 ~ .,. � '> ,.,, 7 .s� b "' l l ) .(1 (i. " ... - "' � !t � � r v. i' 14 9

- rr."'.:'l"',U: -~ c~l~~ i'.}...fd. ' ~L "' fro. th. gt"OSS {coeonu ) ~1.1 is t '~ ~ oil, . 11 t ~ i"n 1-- r , .are 1 . , P� L tor th o1 1, r .. <V)UC ... l th ~ S .. t or 1� ~�ro,.tuet �*! � n rn ~~c -~ 1 .,...,ca 1n ov~r ar~ . into lard, _,..~ 1'1 r ,.fU' no~ 1i\Jn,.. f'"\" n 1f'ne tlr~~ -r.~ ~0 '� Th th Ol ;;:d 150

._ -c 1:11{:�1 - c '.tt~ c:"'zi;; f c. � 11 !,i() ,.,-. 2 r, 1956, r lr t the v J 1 ct h ' la ~� ! ' .-;- on ~tl ~"'dip 1i �~ tht� t $.'! �� '~ �' r"'r/t,;; � t V""I'S t.h t ;j 'l4�}!f"!! l:. , r..-o of' a t ... ~ t~,tiJ~t�~' i......~. "',.~;.:� �:�c!;"_'�.",-",,' ","�~r � 1d . ;- r. -:� ~ hou ld $ t.� ' � .f . .. �� "'I Octr) r , �_� ,, or ~ t} ~ 1r .mount c1 us~ ~d hl o11 rr f 7~f .,.. r1 : c 1~:''"'1 ;; Jk !11 sup� ...rt r ,, 151 1

. nr.;c ..~uc ... C"'J CA...�� .. ,. 11 23 h "o inu ., Pll h 11 ur i 't () Ot: t ,, 1 3 ,t�Et3 . 0{~ ., -1. - - 2t ..... lt~ ,ol... ' t\1': pn . 1 -1 1 "'' h ~n c.r " j .. r. (! t1.. t ~ c f .i .r .1 .1 a 0r b �r (' ~1 tnu~ �.t.J. .. h L .lo� rt .1~ 1J r � ~ rc1' i "' * � .. pr r,.n ' p 2 t 10 G, t! . by -~ r .~..c )y t tl ~ ( l~ .r t � nti'Jir or cf t .1 :t::" ! l c - Y ) l . ( ' t " l- f ta CVfl! 1 If>~! a c ic 0 1. 1 .1 , '/ 4 t I� 1.:5 2 ~

l ll ,. ""'. .... ;(~ ,~{"! .. po .d !1 ,t ~tux ~� b7 r -ot or th ttMOOU t l' �� lJ...?-3 t th~ ,�111 r' X l;.t � tit"�.� V- lt " o:nd nt wnu ~ ..... tt .'�'1 (': tH nd r s c. l'f .h~ r ~ !lttfoc� tlf'tl'r ll or Q t l:k J' i1t ?f. o� ' t ~ _,,f(l,. a�t1e et � . of t 0 1 lL .r�or , \/1tt t �nr.�. t. not h� t t\ *t(:> :rrl e n "~ it h

:sc o, . . l>~:c l ~t~ C"X.A1 C" .,!'1i' N, � 11 " - :. . �rt th . r,:�:r~ u 1on eo � or o. thiS! rna:r k . t -va 1ttf.' CJ .f t~� f.:' t~ . 171 �. , It 1 1.a .ld th,/ i.n t � tho .�. coee:mt;t o:! l � f.lu.: e ..ur"'d '1 1t in i ~ 'tm ('tll ill t.~~.!}fl V�"'d by it. � , r w 'ff;S. r l !.1 :,,~nu~..ncturl _, J.A\i.,!�l, ~P "t tal .l�!'. �� . if.1�U" f' �n v ro tn� �t:ilU" irJ O,. .l . r.~') )"t2:; "' /11 .. t rn1�'� � C.ur ' ". ~~ .~ L . .' t ., tha :tn ~ ~{'l!lr. not h~ . ~ 1 r � 0 .roc��~ tiO"' eo t of t..-e cot~\>nt) t oil tnr n~ c� of ttl cc.�n�m t: tio r th~ 1e, .fS,!'~l 1i t'J, 111 r.~� t~ (" .!.' � t .~ lu :IS ' p .U'k t;,;;J~r�: rt!j ""' rn.tfno JI"~&.l ' r-c;J/' b:� :.~ 15 4

26 , 1 on � �.lY' ' . o... � fvt:J � , ;r;t:". \..... . ,,,.., ~h~ 2 �. 1 11~'"~r' n � tot l en t" t:i:f � 1.t1 Ct 0 �hP. 5' octiot 1... J\c} !' . tor t. � t t $ i: 1 :r. en"' i r.. t; �1. ' � Ct ,., C�<'l* �.,'� (fi~�w �10 .- 5?' t �.,ct. :r 1~~(. ~, t::t"" . 1 v . 11. J..,\. 137 !-=. �' .. ~, 1 n "" ~ t ... o L f"tl 1 ,}r � Ca tot Qt 'l'z-~y l.p �~illS� ;ll . 1 "JC,.�~~~ 1 60 ~ 1-fj.l. .aru- r .. , j ctur1 �~ c .�t;-any, � ~nl!; � " "' :'it '11. a nt. .f r,; ~� f't.'fltly, th or.cy t'l:itt!~ �tic to ts tl ,t . �~h J. ' pt d ay in tl Clf th t X .! { t �1 a ~0 � t~ l'i � 1 .. ~,, I�' :( (' t �o 1 1 � o !' 1.. '01' ,&~ � ll. t ��'' \ . r.,.,.,. - 21 . lit , 155

-tr:. . t1.,9 ") 7 ... 2 f 9 ~; 0"' f1t Conti.. 1 !' 4 C::>r � v � l � � �c ic? . 1�.-11~7 t 13. 1.351 ~ D e. 7, r�o � v. ( ,1 � :r Int . ~ v t f..t . � .... 1 70, n ., . ~ 7 � 7t1J 111. rj!r � "'� I 1 � r In "' ' ,) ny, I no. v. 0 i cr r of n Co ia 5~ ur �- ,. tl ~ - " c t ... ru 1 Yl g:r� t:..~r t� � f I' n .) � � 1t p' i.<:H cont ha r �o ni l of i' .r dt c 1 �0 rt �.. 1 h 10 t 1\ 1 t 1n r 0l d d 1" 0 f c 1 ' !e 15 6 '

� .1 . 28 .r 1 1- 1 1 � 1 t u .... 1 - ~1 1 ( 1 I' 157

.r, .... cJ,'.:ll\':1 .... ti'f� CMlP Nt:�. 1159 . 29 that hi ~�. r � r h f of th ill c � an~ 1. u tio . or of' ta~ D"~�. .ill r, � tz1:, � ~ th � 1nclnrt �on of th eo.~r: rOJrds , p~o.$lt.r it th 1 thcr; r 6. � b1 .:.J .". ' ' �. ot (hi of the 158

ore l.Jlm. ... CT.i. CA.td. '''C � 1159 0 l<! � lit ' . r J. tJtio r 1 1 bl� for ~ .-.tc! t'H''!CY �1-s , inelu 1v I .. 1 1 ~~ rt .r ( r � ,rtt"' n �, ..\It. . � � � � �.. 11 . �� c.

:c.y ������ .~~ t<:~x es 0 r~p f . t rn 1 I .� v .' tt .... tnou tl z.c.n ,".',,~. �.;y, vOl r 15~ , 1t~.~7 r.;.>1&~ ---?t:~~'lk;::?.-_ ~ l � ;I f.',. . .JI ......: '" ' ':.. L -.,.~:~~r !2-.- -~~ \ � 160