CTA Case No. 1718 (Decision)

XJ:<:PUJI\LIC OJ' THE PHJLIPPINEf COURT OF TAX APPE.A.Li QUEZON CITY. , ... - . . . . ,. l , ...... l - ' ~oo� � c .. l ,..? .I � oCI) , ~ .. c: '� . .. ~r "' 423

.' Y.r , <.! . t ... ......_______ _ . . .. .J � ---_..._--...-- 424

.. � � �������*~����� rc: 17, ' l ' ' ... ll 425

..; ,,rtt.: o~, .. l7 9 c 1 �t '" t;,_:. t....:. . 17 �; � i t in ' .j. ..4.!.. 1- ' t ' tt 1 - ~ ~6 ll 0 :f'~ r v �: .. Jt.t ( 1..��~ "'1 ~.., , c;l. . :t 7>~; ' .P~ �t:"' ' u I \t t t. u~ .,. v-~ ... ... ~ l,;' � ,... , ' pp... ; e , flU� . ~ ::,.'t � C,l l � ' ' It , 1960, n. f ...

1?19 .t . r t �t tt~ � t1o t f" t- t .. Y�' 1J:i1 .1. ,.:5~ "'��~ l~.;~t, I 427

...:....;ro~. - ,, ::t ' t 't � 't t; I .; ~n 428

D-C I,. ~:: :n~ t..OUJ"'t r .lu& iV"< � !)""' iJJ :1~ 'd~""' ).: )5 ..'. ( t t f11A i a~ _.1 _ t t!l� as""~:'H n~) �;t. ... i.;..i>pb~n� u . .1'1 oc1~t.lc , .a. ~T:4. Coll . ot� lnt.. �~~v,, :LQI>., ~-nil .. . 11+, 3-17; ~o...., � c�f 1.: t .. ..,,e,;,. ""~ ..-il.li) t �.h :t � .:,o., !."" 429

J t '.t.. !:!. 1 v . 1 430

.. 'n , � C"t. � 1 11 ��r� fi.� \; ... 36 efi 1 n �!'11 > on 3 ( ) o t 431

- l l � J' .. '. ..1,. �r' .. !on it on ill l l .. t n~ au ., JJ. t {. ) �. t1o �n� � ._t � 432

. fiVi ,.. ve, ~ po . lii!Ul.t i.ta~ 1 ftlY t!: :e: ( !i) u.;r: t~ Q ' the da ~.r<AUlt W1 th1~ Wb Oil tO U �t .~ l1t!td.o 1 tnt � "ra~l Ji. vat\Uil.l ta , otbervtc~ bG 11� tol!eve~ � I'!' . �( ())n ar7 to wl . t . a ��Jcnite t Ji. �a t �d, h~ . �iJi-y,oa.r p rlod wi :t1 '1 wht . to cal.~ ot tb~~ t�~ not 1')e s1t~p rtd~fl by �h�~ fit ~'" ftl..o.n.~ of , .re;r t ro P~ O'ls' r1 "a loll 011 � ..1 ll'e&.1 t. tto~ (Co1.t, �Qf I t . t;J~ � �� sn c C{)lt olld"l It JU.oin!t co., et 1. � _do, <! . l . !(~, -- ?G �77 , A�;~ ro� 29, l96o; Jo~ 'i r �,.. Jos r.. r�lntcd: �hh, c, ,. oo . lf'il+, ~f-!)t.. 2b, 19 . ) b1 tb x~eat:t~ t a weiVf1't or tn<t statute or liaita- 1on by th~ t~:xp Y�r (t.eetlon :S'J:~,te7, !\f'f!-t-t1) , ('}~ l '!I c th~ s ats$Gilsee. ~tti.nzt ui � UJoll. ot '"'n;t,., .sav., ve � ..,f.1�oe� Oo ollt.tet.. ..H.t~i � ,3 Co. at .a�l . , , ...�!~� ,) In tt~oh aa-e , thi !l�'1l"'ioft �!�~tf'tn,~ ,~ ,>t lctt ~.'1~ ..,,.. Qat. or roqll~at tor r con 1d .ratir:ul. by p~t! tlQM.:tt w s p nd.t 1 dct. � fro. t tl(& oomputa:tton of t ile ti v y J' p� 1C41 433

/� .. '-l f" . l ; h ,.r � .} 1 G. ..fo 1 ~ 1n t' co �t ,. }Kf/ :...~ CCHlC! 41' � �T >If; . - " '"o � �� ~ f� . ., a. f . C:'A, . ., �� ' ' � op a� s � � � f .) 3) in 19 s o � $ 0 p :t t llo 'ti 434

l 436

or r 4~ ' , 1965 , 1t. "4 . � lr . � t Yt � Y�dU' P' 1n 'Ai'�l eh to coll� ct t ' or . Ill a ~ b� 0!)1 1 or f ti t r tl f r .�.�� :ri 0 ... p en ttY r� 1 b 11 t , an , r n .$ \ t :;x~t .t th ....� ret.~ e ~ t rr oJ" tn Bara o er � . a nu cb 1� ' ' r wht to p ~' '1:

15' ci te 1 r .. 1 10 ' �t~J111" ion *~U nt, � t. X 4- . ed - r "' r 437

\ �~ . 1 ,,c,vot;Ul.e ., .f:r t�� t ht tir~fi; g~.~t1t1ot~Cl'' !'.! r s s~ d'fl �O;e �t ci:s.ney lnc�on.v.t ~. - fl."Pr 1 � ~2 and 1956. '$~ not l. al� _1 P"~o.v � n~d �to �Oll(iot tt~~ s�ni t.J?J1� r~e t.~ let il!iY~ t$e b:t:; ri !t te c l <:cl. elth$.l' b:- t5 t~tra1 ~t e..., l V� , or 1:<1 3:.4'-i lc:iftl .s.ction,. or both str11u.lt .-o~.t;ly {'"'~.Ct-Uf J l , ~ .~~�v~..:tU�~ C�Pe.} .Qt. t'h0 only J'f!t;,;,!.!itU. bfl ... to � h ""c~ltJ. ccl.l~ct �~ s tv r.:. ti n u s-a t�~""~rtt v1t ~ 1 . l. ,. ~� �1 ll 1 . . l..'<t ~. e,.~, n "1 I�$ ~ � �~nt., It ....o t '3" � " " d4;f.~usa. uf :.;.:;..ttop,pel.) (,.. aca;u.bl .� v � 438

. . .. ""' .'"l 'i o~ \ . I � t ~� ~ l Dec! � � 439