Legal Insights

Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.

Showing 10811104 of 1,774 articles for supreme court

Official Duty vs. Discourtesy: When Public Officials Cross the Line

The Supreme Court clarifies that public officials cannot hide behind official duty to justify discourtesy, reaffirming public office as a public trust.

Determining Just Compensation in Agrarian Reform: Balancing Legal Factors and Fair Valuation

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies how courts should determine just compensation for agrarian reform lands under R.A. 6657 and DAR formula.

Mission Orders and Memorandum Receipts: When They Don't Replace a Firearms License

The Supreme Court clarifies that mission orders and memorandum receipts cannot substitute for a valid firearms license, even for confidential agents.

Prior Physical Possession Is Key in Forcible Entry Cases: Gonzaga v. Agan

Philippine Supreme Court explains why ownership alone is not enough to win a forcible entry case—prior physical possession is required.

Certiorari Dismissal: The Strict Requirements for Filing Petitions in Philippine Courts

The Supreme Court affirms that certiorari petitions must attach certified true copies of assailed orders—mere xerox copies will lead to dismissal.

Forum Non Conveniens in the Philippines: When Courts Keep Jurisdiction Despite Foreign Elements

Philippine courts can hear cases with foreign elements; a choice-of-law clause does not automatically strip them of jurisdiction.

Medical Certificate Authentication: Proving Physical Injuries in Philippine Courts

Learn how Philippine courts treat medical certificates as evidence, why authentication matters, and what Postanes v. People teaches litigants.

Corporate Rehabilitation, Foreclosure, and Judicial Independence: Key Lessons from Rombe Eximtrade

A Supreme Court ruling clarifies when courts may issue injunctions against foreclosure after a rehabilitation case is dismissed.

Theft vs. Estafa: When Misusing Entrusted Funds Becomes Theft in the Philippines

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when misappropriating funds received for a specific purpose constitutes theft rather than estafa.

Finality of Judgments, Due Process, and Counsel's Negligence in Contract Rescission

A Supreme Court ruling on finality of judgments, due process, and counsel's negligence in a construction contract rescission case.

Delaying Tactics Unveiled: Repeated Motions to Quash in Criminal Proceedings

The Supreme Court rules that repeated motions to quash and inhibit judges are delaying tactics that impede justice.

Judicial Accountability: Judges and Court Personnel Held Liable for Undue Delay and Misconduct

Supreme Court holds retired judge liable for undue delay in deciding 23 cases and clerk of court for issuing false certification.

The Fine Line Between Unpaid Bills and Criminal Fraud Estafa in Restaurant Settings

When does an unpaid restaurant bill become a criminal offense? A Supreme Court ruling clarifies when non-payment crosses into estafa.

Presumption of Regularity of Public Documents: The High Bar for Proving Falsification

Public documents enjoy a presumption of regularity. Learn the high evidentiary standard needed to overcome it in administrative cases.

Online Psychological Abuse Under RA 9262: When a Public Facebook Post Becomes a Crime

The Supreme Court clarifies how public social media posts can constitute psychological abuse under RA 9262, and when using ICT raises the penalty.

Search Warrants for LPG Cylinder Misuse: Probable Cause Standards Under R.A. 623

Supreme Court ruling clarifies probable cause for search warrants involving unauthorized LPG cylinder use under R.A. 623, as amended.

Forum Shopping Dismissal of Land Registration Application Over Larger Properties

When does opposing a land registration application become forum shopping? The Supreme Court clarifies the rule in Calinisan v. Court of Appeals.

Restrictive Custody in the PNP: Balancing Discipline and Liberty

The Supreme Court explains when restrictive custody of police officers under investigation is lawful and not a ground for habeas corpus.

Bail and State Witness Rules in Murder and Parricide Cases: The Valerio Case

The Supreme Court clarifies when bail may be denied and when an accused may be discharged as state witness in murder and parricide cases.

Contractual Obligations and Third Party Rights in Property Lease Disputes

Supreme Court ruling on when lease penalties bind only contracting parties, not property owners who are third parties to the contract.

Backwages in Illegal Dismissal: When the Employer’s Obligation Ends

Backwages in illegal dismissal accrue until actual reinstatement or payment of separation pay, per Mt. Carmel College v. Resuena.

Balancing Infant Health and Commercial Freedom: Limits on Restricting Breast Milk Substitute Ads

The Supreme Court struck down parts of the DOH's 2006 rules banning breast milk substitute ads, ruling the agency exceeded the Milk Code.

When Contract Claims Must Yield to the Sandiganbayan: Jurisdiction Over Sequestered Assets

A contract dispute over sequestered shares belongs to the Sandiganbayan, not the regular courts, when the assets are subject of ill-gotten wealth cases.

Duterte v. Kingswood: Burden of Proof in Disease-Based Dismissals

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies that employers, not employees, must secure a health authority certification to validly terminate on disease grounds.