Legal Insights
Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.
Get a cited, plain-language answer from 184,000+ statutes and decisions — free, no sign-up.
Free Patent to Minor and Prescription of Reconveyance: Heirs of Timbao v. Enojado
SC ruling on free patents issued to minors, indefeasibility of titles, and the discretionary power of appellate courts over dismissed appeals.
Timely Filing and Substantial Compliance in Appeals: Lessons from Caballes v. Court of Appeals
The Supreme Court reminds appellate courts that procedural rules yield to substantial justice when appeals are timely filed and defects are promptly corrected.
Ombudsman Appeals and Procedural Rules: When Technicalities Yield to Substantial Justice
The Supreme Court reminds appellate courts that procedural lapses should not defeat the merits of an administrative appeal, especially when a government employee's dismissal is at stake.
Striking a Balance: Upholding Agrarian Justice Without Sacrificing Procedural Rules
The Supreme Court reminds appellate courts that minor procedural lapses should not defeat the right to appeal, especially in agrarian cases involving social justice.
When a Trial Court Cannot Deny Your Notice of Appeal: PBCOM v. Court of Appeals
The Supreme Court clarifies that only appellate courts may dismiss appeals for being improper remedies, and when a motion for reconsideration is excused.
The Limits of Appellate Courts Introducing New Evidence on Appeal in Philippine Law
Philippine appellate courts generally cannot receive new evidence on appeal; review is limited to the trial record. This article explains the rule.
Navigating Factual Disputes: The Supreme Court's Stance on Appellate Review
The Supreme Court clarifies when appellate courts may review factual findings and correct arbitrary penalties in homicide convictions.
Navigating SEC Appeals: Understanding the Scope of Review and Due Process
The Supreme Court clarifies when appellate courts may relax procedural rules and the limits of certiorari review in labor appeals.
When Courts Overturn Convictions: Lessons on Evidence and Reasonable Doubt
The Supreme Court acquits a rape convict, explaining when appellate courts may disregard trial court credibility findings and why prosecution evidence must stand on its own.
Redirect Examination Waiver and Court Discretion: Soriano v. Mendoza-Arcega
When a trial court may deem redirect examination waived due to a party's delay, and why appellate courts will uphold that discretion.
Preliminary Injunctions in Ejectment Cases: When Immediate Execution Yields to Equity
The Supreme Court clarifies when appellate courts may issue preliminary injunctions to stay execution of ejectment judgments despite their immediate executory nature.
Unraveling Appeal Deadlines: The Fresh Period Rule and Appellate Court Discretion
Learn how the Fresh Period Rule reset appeal deadlines and when appellate courts may relax procedural rules.
Procedural Compliance and Corporate Rehabilitation: Ensuring Fair Adjudication of Appeals
The Supreme Court reminds appellate courts that procedural rules serve justice, not frustrate it, in corporate rehabilitation appeals.
Positive Identification Prevails Over Alibi in Homicide Cases: Lessons from Lascano v. People
The Supreme Court reaffirms that credible eyewitness identification outweighs alibi and denial in criminal cases, explaining why appellate courts respect trial court credibility findings.
Docket Fees and Dismissal: Balancing Procedural Rules With Substantial Justice
The Supreme Court affirms that appellate courts may relax procedural rules on briefs to serve substantial justice, not strict technicality.
Automatic Review of Death Penalty Cases Cannot Be Waived: People v. Flores
The Supreme Court rules that appellate courts cannot dismiss death penalty appeals for failure to file briefs, as review is mandatory.
Who Represents the Republic: The Solicitor General's Exclusive Role Before the High Court
The Supreme Court clarifies that only the Solicitor General may represent government agencies before appellate courts, not their own legal offices.
Judicial Discretion vs Neglect: Balancing Speed and Justice in Philippine Courts
A Supreme Court ruling clarifies when appellate courts may disturb factual findings and how negligence is proven in quasi-delict cases under Philippine law.
Service of Pleadings in Appellate Courts: The Solicitor General's Exclusive Authority
In Salazar v. Romaquin, the Supreme Court clarified that the Solicitor General exclusively represents the People in appellate courts, making service on the Provincial Prosecutor ineffective.
Execution Pending Appeal: Why Only Appellate Courts May Judge a Dilatory Appeal
Philippine Nails and Wires v. Malayan Insurance clarifies that trial courts cannot declare an appeal dilatory to justify execution pending appeal; only appellate courts may.
Upholding Prior Possession When Courts Must Correct Errors in Forcible Entry Disputes
The Supreme Court clarifies when appellate courts may review factual findings in forcible entry cases, emphasizing prior physical possession.
Certiorari's Reach When Appellate Courts Overstep in Injunction Cases
Learn how certiorari limits appellate courts from issuing injunctions in labor cases, based on a Philippine Supreme Court ruling.
The Weight of Witness Testimony: Why Trial Courts Hold the Key in Philippine Parricide Cases
A look at People v. Villarez, explaining why appellate courts defer to trial courts' assessment of witness credibility in parricide cases.
Can a Pauper Litigate Before the Appellate Courts? The Martinez Ruling
The Supreme Court clarifies that indigent litigants may seek pauper status before appellate courts, ensuring free access to justice.