CTA Case No. 2180 (Decision)

.. R!- IC OF THE PHILIPPJNE8 ( t ( H. r (JF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY - ... i' - ............. ... ......... - � ...... 1r r Ja .0 ' of h 0 d I'! 0 th~ r~ md .r ta~ CI' ci of t ...,0 nt of � 26.� 2 r :1. 0 0'1!" 1 n � � 1 0r rc 0 1 fn h m� rs .ha jn h .. t l.�!1 '.f ,.,. 'Q t..i t r-n, ro L 0 il�r.r=n as e n n l.t 0 _'1, th � of h ... - ~ ,1, I' .... 00 957 t 196 ' t . l .� _u. ')'Jij

- � 21U .... ... t in u 0 w.r c 0 .o ro ~.r ot th . ~ �~ b ACt it r� 1 t� ' ~ (~ r:o ll r r onor't .nr ' h :r~ .r. 1 '? 19" rlfl 1 6 e:;r .~ o . � l"'lOU 7, . 57. , .'r 1 It 15 , .<!. 55 , ... t 0 po � n. rt i .. W'l t .. otal n r 0 r t at . l i. ~�hil i ty o� 1 7 . e I" r:;' . - l .in o. ;y '~~ d nt rn .d ; KM- 0 �r ' !" ~... ~~ 1..: "'.l'i'... ra t1 in- "' y .Jl r~" "' t ..mb.1 to 0 r.� 0 .. m~s .:h~ n r in nt

.. ., 21 .. or n t 1 ... 3 ... 11 f' t 0 0 n-r:: t t l, rr f! . .0 pt of.' , 7 r pr a n 1 ym nt :X! ' ~ a don r b 11 1 th . lo �. ""to � 1nat:1on .,........p. id 1 1 t J.r. t l d ...be in t I -- ti, ion for befor hi. ' Co rt n cto X' ao , 1970, nh 0 nv b dt th- .1. ~ er 1 7, 6. 2 o- 0 r� n. u ly e 11 c. n on f f � to b ci by th.1 Cour 1 t " a!~ or r ,r )n ly f' l ~ -; t .l ru b n rt 1 ti ut ti � l 1 �11 n nnd l1 ~r 1 r - b "'1 ~ n lly col- 1 cr1 iv 2 'v) .9

DI -- c y� r i et �o� 3 6 t l cr ~> 7, tl t th of th ., he 1 1ch. � ot �O nt r th tc r �o f ll b ci , ec n to on � it ha �if tl 1 on 1 t nn11'\,.,..ll!'~flitl. 0 t l 11 a 1o c o r ne,e. r t � nd r ro or t �o d or in � �ct on 3 ) C sho 1 t. r :. , 1 6 so th ~ ol 1 1nr i h ll n p titian l l in t � ~ ithi h � r ~1- t y r� 240

.a ~l8C - ... r.! ) s nd 00 t Q n� i~ e y r ;.1 t 1)6 tb r -1�� ......, n .r 7t: t 1~6;: cr , .... l~I.C C�f one d r fro "' -f or c��.ip f � n~-l .. ttt' on t 3 ?65. 'on f &C-..01" d ~ -.r a. t ;ff. n ��;, nt_ 0 t ...... 1 fin 1 c r 1.1 r or } "~oi tio.n r - ..ir 1 l.l tc �I j_ t r <: ton ? n l l fict :�o. 1125. . Tl ... r i l ~ ' d .n � t r hi t 0 l:fn d r.rui o:f ! nt in of in�nrn r 'J :ion I lJ 1:!5 :qhjc bl ,.. 1 t f tl t r�y ~ a .ci..-ion n i1 l I t ction li 01 th it 1 1 .c 241

' - 21 - 6 ... 6 t or ' lt !) n �1 \l :r t f th a U~PJ c '~l t tl t n~ c0) 6 3 of It* 1\ tV cd � 'plicitly . to , ..y r (.; 't' !1 t c :.) is -i n r 1' n1� Co any t urt of c r 11 ,. 1967 . ., 23? nr t of Co r or lnt s . 1 '1C ..o .. ' 1 g l o., r th. law ' 1968 12, ., .t l- cl .! r t ll t 1~, 11y, o- h� thr~n f cti 1 im �or 242

. C.~ 'l � ht si .... ' d '�" ' "' I t r �J , t ,1. It,,. "l ' /' .1: ,J. t. 243

.. .. !l 1 . ory, if y .r 16 r' tbfJ t � 1 (? ttai 1 .y p ti-� whl'"" ... h1. ., r . t Ill!~ at 0 s or h .r .ht n l t t Co 1 ! ut a_ pr ~1- n of "lt'l"",? of l F lin� :o. cto l" 2 19 th. or ' h !:!t f" t� e ' hi h 1 on 1 r.:r b c� ' r "by 1 r hi f.! ' 1 ot put hi l.A d r 7 lie � 1125', an . d ,d or 1 n r "C- 3 h t 0 al t(!l ' 1 v- 0 .11 1' ....1.." .fu " . i.t' n c" i 1. � ou t 0 T th h f ll by i.t �on pr 1 Qn. 0 1 3''1 .. 9 0 t 1 t1 J. 1 .tnt~ 1

- tl ' -c t tG (! 0 0 s il rron '....r... ~('I 'l~.; '�' u ; .l-. Jt 1. m� . .t�p. t t r..,.. r:: l) c..r' ..: ft �J ng t llt r: r� J" i F�"'. 1<"' .... r: J. 6'5 . r .. .� r:t ~ ~ �v"'� c ";: l "�' I.... a �tb ' h >~,~'l "~ '\ . 'J " 'fl -. .J.l ~"" o . n .. ,..,c .. 0 -' r' .t o. tj C'" ~, '' l ...

..D .J '� r � ..:1 ,(. - - 10 tobPr 22 , 96tr, �.,: l ,} th c ( r r Int r l u ... ( 0 ,1_ � ..Cl.., .. id ty ~ '�\ ~ I. !if' :i ..,ur {I"> 11' t t , j �C't 0 ~�r t ~ e, th( ti tj �~nP c .. 7 ~o � v ..1. I') jc y (} ~~'. �.: J (\l! n:r .. I' - 1� & lrl r:),, I':' I' . ~.1 ,... rf" 0 ~ ,.; 1.1 .. . H .; 1 .-... ...,.., ""' .. , "l ""~\ ~ _.,_ ~~ ~ (' or f , ;a � r "r """ -'h*�� � f 1 3t; ,~ 0 rt r . ) .,.. r I .ranc .. r ''v 4 ~~ t~ :t: . J - 0 ' J 1 r .. .. . "". -1 ( ,., L ~... """' h r" ~ .. l"f , nn ... ... .,... ,. $:. . �t"' c. p� 'I 1 ( 6 Co ttl asior.: ,.... ev .,.,. ,.., ~ 1.! 0 1 ~"' � 246

- ........ .. 11 ' ' '7 1 c 1 ) 0 1 t t! .1 T, 0 t r �..'l t; c 0 _r � ~ 1n ~� t' . t. .P. 1 . J. r. ' f, 1 1 247