CTA Case No. 1978 (Decision)

)~ ,/ 'EPUBLIC O:P' THE PIIILIPPIMEI C-OURT OF TAX APPE.A.UI QUEZON CITY l Ll . D~Cl~IOA 't>O,.fH b f" � t - nu. l i b1. ~ � v "P"' A''.J~. Q, .. "' '� bAJ~~n }~..~1-~ - - ' \ ' ' " ' - ......... ;;..;rr t1 c t. ~ t l tl\11rt?.Ut t of ', 12 , .4B '.� ~5 , r p:rPs.;, "tin , .,t:~fJ, ... � cy n<: o n1 1 . 0 thly 1 ~�ms s c ~- r r vi .... ... .n ~ {,. .l on l ~~ ~ p t i .. . .... ... . ........,, . .. . ' . 353

.c ... � 17 . . . . 1 1 .. ! �� � .. ��� it r d .- r t l"fi rt ot 1 ' t t i �cr r ,1 t r ty c ._o ; 1� I' � ,eo t: .. h negative, �� t .r h 5 ty i , 354

� 197 0 1--5~ ' 1' � 1 � 1 t � i.l .. ~ ty o. ' ~ 1 t . ./":! 1� .. 1. 1 .7 ry . l ' 3 �5 5

-~t r ' .. 19'/,. h ' h f 1 .. ~. h , ll � in t!> h p. � � .. .:r !'le . � .h.. nd Jl n, and ,nnll'l , u! 1y fl -h1cn b~ ) his �omily . . t~lf'lf t:r. r '}~t : onor r t Ccr:,.., of t he f' ~1 J..- n 'c ux � cc 0 19"' 1 S.~ "' :nor � 1J Q p ~ ch 1 h~ t th i t r"sts Af i"'(} j i~J .nos 'I !..e i ..{' 1n au; i m~. t 0 �p .r) so~ .ly . 1!1 �tH'cr. .. (') '-1 # ~ p t .tionnr j_$ G,bnr r f,fO!K_ !! tan.c� i nr: ~r t .r s AS..-"r!: tic:n 't h ~ f'' ~1 ~ i ce 1:'$�JJ f L~ . C tine noI of ' n:L .... :;; ~�..ee I q 5'~: of 'iht- f:la~ 1/ev�d cw.~ of 1:Ail p�;.,1!.ff? 't-11..(~ 356

- c I rc- of .l .. rr c C 11 - nil. , Inc~ since 1969 . � re 3, s( t ' 1 5 357

t Jc'JIO; � ...o. 19 / . t mt <>f it .' 358

7 .t patti but 0 h in t1ry '0 1 t .th r .. rrl !",) t. tf.." l�11 th .an f\ t f ' Lu .1.0 hi. 1 nd t":Ubenq ,.,n n 75 . .. ' (CtU'.:� � irs � Ot.t d ~t t i.'J t< >f!l' n ,. fi( 3) ... "'Ot\ t t petit 0 .1" <C:! t,h111 p :_~1 nr ~!d ~t '1:1' th . 1ur i � ' tht.� r od 359

... \ ''.; ~ 1?'7 ' .� � ., .h ~ ' t r � r tl t �"""n by thf�. . 't .r � � �� . tJm:pr i nr~t ti � 't':.f('; :r1u ~d. ~nt <!., ~....J ~JJ:f> h t��~ � 360 '

.. � � 17 1 � � at any given time 36

10 a.n C� bl ' at: th ;l)r .y Of'~ 1 t 1 . ('! hi f .Ji J;r . OJ.. Jt n-' t :;, ~ 1 ~6�; .., t t r r\!d not ., havin g a � .. ' 362 ., .

., �l I 1 ( 7 .... s " ? 363 . "