CTA Case No. 2530 (Decision)

REPURI,JC OF TIIE PHILIPPI NE8 COURT CW TAX APPEALS I~UEZON CITY - va u - I 0 ti len r, on . t . .T.... � 256'7 tit!u r, c. ��� c ..) � ~ - - - - - - - - - - - X. Dc ~ l s two lv1n �s d- tlL ' �1 S .;;\.!P.S 11�'4r r� ct .. .. r~ 1 r .... jo lt 0 ly - , c1 io n 1. �r nd In . tic .r I v! 'J ; t I-:' y I'r'-lft.m f "a r c ~ ... ' o. .tJO ~� r. � s o .. I' , "1 1 p ;.> I s c in r t~ t v r- ou ro li~nt

p r1 , 195f t. 1963 a d 1953 to 1 56; r ~p.ct vely . tfe s tt t t d ul 75� eh b th ... o� ti , p;_ t i io er r.o ... ~ t~c c\.,or ora 1 uoi.n s. . ur no :Po al Pol;~.ci { '"'f Inf'ura CR Com ssioner ��� n. � � � tt6 4(J0 2 ' 24 :� . 8 5

... . .. � ( � �' c. . . ( ?) 86

� 2530 � 57 r j .. y 5 rt 1 f X t r t1 c it j . tl 1 d 0 th h ocu X y t. 1 ' o. 2 7' ow t it h e 1 y. ~~ ;< 8 7

~. ,.o. 2 3,~7 -5 - e ... c 0 j ' Ut ' f ur- � c , r n hi poi of 't lv h y t 0, " nr nc . . , c ,J � v . ..t'r ? , 970 . (C' �� ... o. 196 ' ct ' 1971) . lOJ.' 1"1 � � o � 2 'l ' ie 1 !I c' rr cr 1 ct r - t a iti n r d hr ct t t l i.c for 1f n 0 t by on 225 of h D. to e, 1 hf t. c � I8 8 lr ''

o. 25 ; � 2 .... ? .. 6 - in :'�. . 8 9

� 25 . � 25 7 - 7-

n c1:ao - ~A G �.0 . 2530 & C'�, C/tS: r; . ~~::i67 .. 8 - grlf1canc 1 th ] ut t' s ro . t icEAl !' - po .... e -r ti i e t ... r s g .. -<.1 b � 1 t rr; lc 1. x � �in~� c r n""t 1. :fb1t A-1 p ., <~h 1 � 1 ~comn11sh u or in bnl � tt r ollo �in t r v ~ ry f ti- 0 1 ci .r. anti pr the ' r. ' .t-:d h ( 1.i d) . at thl'1 r ar.::k the ""r-- 0 ~,a n .to .. .y l. ollr'}� nf t ~� :i cl,.., ,f tr pt'.H'tt if' �r~tt n .4... t r',.Y ( t ,.,.. ��y, .. r- t.v C!<� he :',f' ,ny 111n s v pair ::.n- t t_l(.')!' '}t�h ph ica X XX ( .lnt �r' en . ppl_t . . ) t 0 d ca ""r:\r+ a.r" not ~0 p i-- plo (! ~~ i' ., 91

o. 25'3 o. 567 � 1 1 c � 92

- 10 - t 1 ln h 1 r .. 1 r ap 1c 1 0 of. c i 0� X �2, 1 hr 1 t lo 0r 0 rr 0 or � o. .3 .n 0 1 ..t .. 1 (!'l u jf

�5 � '567 - , -- .. 1. ... v 0 ly l h J:"Ol n t t, it th y- n t. X :.4. po e 1c. r l du r:; c .rro or 11 1 n t r r 1 i q s ion r ly gr X to clo or 1 h t X bl l c E, by 1 tax !' lt in 1 of tt " nt rr. t 1:) incl� in na 1 s d in r - 1r <l 1 ir.t lf f t . y, �rt v n 1d h t i her ... in, is th r ro�n 11 ci 1, cri r , 1n1 r1s .n r 1no1- 0 u d th nt r- n 1 v nu nl t f ... G r a f t c t, thr. v n~ r 'i C.ivil on 1 ny p- I~ 0 ocl � tio � c. - � 15-72, c . 11 l9l ) . 0 t - ;il ' 94

a5 - 12 - j n of 1 h ~ j of t (:, ny hn cr e , ::X v t 0 c dc 0 h. t f>U ~ to f d X h nc � t r nd b - c rt oc e y cl n t � r n 1h' C c n "' con ... - r 1 ich lCYt' v1 f thf tr t fun cr. 1 .. im~t~ l" d ' ich _l- ni � ch t� t / I 1d 1 of � n l"l11 0 nno llo r~ntP. ii" :r. 1:! ci o- r.i n ' n y r 0 t j_ � nc � � �� ' t . ~ 19 . 2; c 7: '� ' 0 ' tr ' I � � ' - 1.,J17, �' 61?� v. 1 ., 11, 7, 6 ' c 71 �' v . n~r ;;. 95 !�

. ..., -- �5 � 57 -1 Gr o, 12 , � t 1 '7 21 ; r an r ' c. � 0 1 r .., 48 . ) ny for ' r1 I G 'I n 'r cc f o� t j o. c �� t t c1 or to .. ~63 r y � .1 .. co t 0 .. � � '''3 l 7f . . i� ., 96 ;-