CTA Case No. 2147 (Decision)

� Rl t' H IC OF TC . PHIUPPUiWS <_,(IL 1T OF TA. APPEA LS QUEZO. r ClTY � D l 1 0 1 n .. �V I' I ,:. c l ~ � c t vi~,; C l 1' ' tit � .; � "r 0� n o. , i y

u. 2 4'7 W� e e � into ~rt r lnvi t tion to Pld s s .. ue y e por aent Co r� is ... ioner of Cust ms at the .�ort o1 Dra ao . n ' Instruc-'-ion to Di er ~~ �as al- ' 0 issue \ b ro ... onc.ent to ail )1 U(: !' �, 9� in the ret f arr�str <! ar es on i r~orts well e por were e b died in s i a instruct! n to biua.ers at tl .1.-'ort f lJ vao , in accordance tith he instruc- tion o th 6ecreta1 of ~'inane � 1 f t e r the a e- n .n~..i bi u1n , tne r1 stre 'an e 1t Contr ct a fin lly aw rded to �ne herein private respo a nt on � pril 22 , 19 , the ate the sr 1 contrac laS ;c;;tp l'uVed by . the Secret~ ry t' ""ir-a c � or 11 a r stre r lc s re 1d re , resp lden ustavo � S a!'e2i .a bee1 coll cting the rate proviued d.n �t.he .n. ement c ntr�ct . Howev r, on r 2 , 19 5, an .i~dminibtl�ative Oru.er ~ � 1- �6 �w...,w 1;;, u.eti !sin he r;., tes of ar a tre ch rges ti an i''ern na ... Union , Cebu, Da ' o, Il .11 ~J o(i4n (6.2 . &. 17~9) . I er i::l , 19oo, petitioner eApor 2 50 t.ons T'"' a road an paiu the COl respondin..~ ar- r- ~..r in ~:;he sum. of i ~ 8 � . 0 the c .let r f the 'o t f 'a ao un Cl' � � o. H- 36 on ece ,r 6, 19 d, it exporte:d 1, 01 tons 0 copr!. n. lso aid he cor r spending arrastr charg~s !n t~ ~mount of 2 , 032cOO to re~pondent i.' 28 5

-0 - 21 7 � ""'u I �a. � � � w~� r t pr�~:u d by ' 3 t 1~ o:n July 29. f l. �C or 0 enie~< p 't l- 1oner 286

� �~ i to o o � a ;or a v !> l I lev .Led t:r . � P ~c ve.., �el co n� or li,eJr,ine po � uf c t of fac , w Ol r 1n i� ( v.t� w . A.t . .._ � 3,19'" . ) ' l'h lill ~ � r c iviz~ ' t cat. witt t . r &p .rt.... or 4-p J.� e<..' 0r j,,u. Cl( �e 0 'I'�:f ---- (,,,ec t.i l "' jll-l, ~- if-' ~~nu. '-'U~;...O' � "'�ue . ) r th ea .l 1c e er o... o.:. he 0 err. e t, "'tor cha 1 col- ' .) ) t d. .:. rl y en e �� port �o , u.nl ija_u r � otl � (1 i v s_, u r.l.v cJ. i in a �our of

v v ..,',.J! ""' ......... >+ 7 dl 1p- v1 .1. .�: tot:l , l th or t� . .., s nt..~r.... , I ! :.h~ 1 .te td ..... 1>!.. ;;al.l '-"'-~ r i i ...l~ ... CV "' , ic ,the ire .�c. JIG.Y .~.n_ly , s1c..n l::.U ct e l ��IJ . ry ...~...~.-~ ')! i c : ;:, n t ! ,.~ � ..~.;~ve;: l. at all port..; of e.n ry . rr.a t i J ~x(~r � rc 1 ut l l ,,... t � c ....i l t t . fir �..rt . f~ 28 8

1 h ti.& fl 1: - co tr .ct or tb �11ver 1 � c ' e ca l t w t 00 lus1on ' r 11'1 ~ n� t ,� lol t I n n ... .1 . - f 1 l' .. :11 law th r �tt ' 1' . �t el r 1, t upon i s l c 81'1~ e 1 l~ f Op n s p -r - p l. n .. o n~ e - fo t h .r'.;;, C �t y 0 1cl .r t J. � tt 1� n 1 f hei ; .I o t~J � ion t Pr� � cc to � wn r s; u l the 1t - rt .t:.n t b pur h���. ' cvrtO..t d.:.;, .~.i and ,t i - 0 l "S l e 1e ::> 1' 289

... v .ter - 't � (.1 \rJd ,, . ~"'V . , l t. n � .,., eh f b I) o� lu ~it 1-t ~,;h � < '.r�t �~ ' b. - ( �e l 290

c�� ct :r i a �C �,1;;: fo . rv.1 G t l1n�, ree c. tw. c r e: id t. e .m r ~ . affor . to v � ' S l , ce nt 0 tt a ls o the words .. n r �p t e nr r � ' � o- t, r t.r eh r .e. ) E'urtn r a- , u ..1c 107 T ~ ~ flee or . �nc r o3t . ch r 0 lin , -ce 1 n e l.ody o por teo or e~ - p rtou '<icil- .e..:., y .no.~ l't.n- ta u:l � ot ar t co in � t: rl n � t r ::;ervices ith l

9 ct t .r in po t t.h in r i �y p te th in er t uf t nt ~ :x .x ttl � (u ct1� n - e. ) bu. t ~t r isio s 1 a o . i sion rmine or at .1., ' r ch on s � l � x o t ... , 1n l l por � ... r -11 pin it lo ic~ l o .clusio .. , r- r to t uain ~.er ~c ~n U'\1 of 'h ' :) . ,n th b "' e 1 �1 lt 0 .� the tf I'e- ,ua ca 0 a s to m it , p� :e rs u e of tb p�rt i..' 1 ie th t ii!O no ule t.O r th e v c "" l th t: ts uir u . prl.va, ther� it lt:J � "'O !'.l'&t' !'<.: c 1ar all ..or� ty t. 1 the e 1 w:l- ~tl lO t. 1 i.mpo ~ ed or po t . ' i ls i tv l' 0 .f.:., ... 2 92

UEH it 1 vi r� ' y iil"i ~} u . I ." �t I a' u- 7 c 1� "' 1 th ur� u ;� 2 9 3

E,lvl''. - ~� J~ ~� � 2llt7 l 1 r t 5 {a a tre C ar ) ~ l s n Cl ar �w f or �l � ervi 0 Nt~ 1� er .d b,v td~ uureau i tu� nt. lt I rctly c �t J.c:. th 0a e {!. ' eet 1. tl.l �v y 1 $ ft 1 '1 :n �ire~~ . t �tion r ' J! r 0!.0 �u t ~1: rr tlr r e em cu1e � in u rr � tr~ cont1� ct. :..~ u~e � an 6:2l rci:il of lc;.;ia- ~.ar...,L:a ion 1~ D .ur~ l {\. v 'H.) l . � ch of i.h �r- � in.to consiu t "u 1~ its a J.t ~ cr:. ion as to 1 b!� t. G:Gll th or 1 w, wh1eh. 1r. 0 v < er c , n t it... 29 �1

'I # 1r . t c l!. t � I (~. 1t t ~ll \.:;... " ...../..,7....n .......:�;�� lr~ ; � .. Com- �t. . 52 " 96' , citJr � Cl "c nn. t1, .. . <.. "" � It . Co . v. li t 0 to, br no r, <.: ni. .h\l~;j thu \> ' rra tro char ~ � p r tl.c th l''t f .va'V 0 u l. G ~' O � � �.tv , 1 op s1v � ' ��hi i port t ..; ' t� (J ar� ti tr a t~ t tl"E:~ ' $l'V1C or �il al :It riM , . ~ c in t.o � L. t l ' G ervi e teu , petiti n r .. p ur � J.:n ttl ~ ;:;rt w r ~ .H ch i. l'.- ly J;'i.AC <: to , h � el .. . l 0 t t . r. n:; c r ; o t.> c� i fi 295

- . e 1- ; \,i, c v .., ... t ~� t t .... } I1:t: Jl' .. \ t clu: ,:; I.' r.J) ... ~ ,. ...... u. 1 u... , flO to � .in a � �~ 2 9 6

LJ.Cl;,..l .... .. C'i: fl. " i- t-i r�, .:hJ. 21 ? '~ I 14- ( 0 ~1 lit .one o _" "ust. .., rII. ( . 1, J.ect 011 31 ~tn� .iee , palci � 1 stmil� rly �1tuet :;:: ns avai;ting the . el.vas of like ben f'1t. n<ll f 1Ut .ies � on iuere ttl J. : J. ply 1 pCF' . ana l iad .tb t .� nictl t.h.e low has 1Jl'P- iu u� .cc -Qint:..l.Y, tte c:1~1o. c.r rtuJpon ant Com:.i<'l.... �o cr <)f Customs ch ...ed J.~ril 48 ., $t'70, \.!.stain1Il0 tb~ u ci.;;;.:t.on ot th.~ C�oll"C or o(' CW:Stoms of' toh tort OW'! of ,e..t.,~Lto. �vas .r as re eli �rt~es .Paid o.rtation \>f co,Prn, i~ affil"ed; a.t .Pet1- io.nr'.a cot. ./ . ,z; :. ~L---; J:{vl> U., � .ui ~ vtn.Uin � J <oJ.t � -~ j