Legal Insights

Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.

Showing 21852208 of 2,278 articles for court of appeals

Surety vs. Guaranty in Philippine Law: Key Differences and Liability

Learn the difference between surety and guaranty under Philippine law, and why contract wording—not titles—determines your liability.

Unreliable Affidavit? Why Courtroom Testimony Reigns Supreme in Philippine Criminal Cases

In People v. De Guzman, the Supreme Court ruled that courtroom testimony prevails over affidavits and police reports, explaining why.

Proving Marriage and Filiation in the Philippines When Documents Are Missing

How Philippine courts allow proof of marriage and filiation through witnesses, baptismal certificates, and other evidence when official records are lost.

Counterclaims After Complaint Dismissal: Philippine Rules Explained

Learn when counterclaims survive dismissal of the main complaint under Philippine civil procedure, based on the Fletcher Challenge case.

Implied Trusts in Philippine Property Law: When a Titleholder Is Not the True Owner

Learn how implied trusts work under Philippine law, the gift presumption for children under Article 1448, and key lessons from Morales v. Court of Appeals.

When a Child Eyewitness Fails: The Roman Meneses Acquittal and the Law on Identification

The Supreme Court acquitted Roman Meneses due to unreliable eyewitness identification, explaining when a child's testimony and police show-ups fail the test of proof beyond reasonable doubt.

Rent-a-Car Liability in the Philippines: When Is the Owner Liable for Lessee’s Negligence?

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on when rent-a-car companies are liable for lessee negligence under quasi-delict and vicarious liability rules.

Shipping Delays: When the 1-Year COGSA Limit Does Not Apply in the Philippines

Philippine law distinguishes physical cargo damage from pure economic loss due to delay. Learn when the 10-year Civil Code prescriptive period applies instead of COGSA's 1-year rule.

Caveat Emptor in Philippine Law: The Fule Case on Buyer Beware in Property and Jewelry Deals

Philippine law applies caveat emptor—buyers must inspect goods before purchase. The Fule case shows how failure to verify authenticity can defeat fraud claims.

Online Psychological Abuse Under RA 9262: When a Public Facebook Post Becomes a Crime

The Supreme Court clarifies when public social media posts constitute psychological abuse under RA 9262 and how ICT use raises penalties.

Quasi-Delict vs Criminal Negligence: Civil Liability in Philippine Accidents

The Supreme Court clarifies when a driver's negligence creates civil liability under quasi-delict, even without a criminal conviction.

Litis Pendentia in the Philippines: Stopping Duplicate Lawsuits

Learn when Philippine courts dismiss duplicate lawsuits for litis pendentia, the requisites, and how to prevent splitting a cause of action.

Substantial Justice vs Technicality: When Can Appeal Deadlines Be Relaxed

The Supreme Court explains when late appeals may be allowed despite rigid rules, balancing technicality against substantial justice in Trans International vs. CA.

Conspiracy and Criminal Liability: Understanding Intent and Participation in Philippine Law

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when circumstantial evidence proves conspiracy and guilt beyond reasonable doubt in criminal cases.

Validity of Court Decisions: Judge Incumbency and Jurisdiction Explained

When is a judge's decision valid after transfer? The Supreme Court explains jurisdiction, incumbency, and ratification in ABC Davao Auto Supply.

Prosecutorial Discretion vs Court Authority: Navigating Criminal Case Dismissals in the Philippines

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies the balance between prosecutorial discretion and judicial authority in dismissing criminal cases after information is filed.

Private vs Common Carriers: Understanding Liability for Cargo Damage in the Philippines

Philippine law distinguishes private from common carriers, affecting liability for cargo damage. Learn the rules and practical implications.

Free Patent Restrictions: Can Leasing or Mortgaging Your Land Cause Reversion to the State?

Learn when leasing or mortgaging free patent land can void your title and cause reversion to the State.

Lis Pendens in the Philippines: When a Defendant Can Protect Property Rights

Learn when a defendant can register a notice of lis pendens in the Philippines, even without a registered title, based on a Supreme Court ruling.

SEC vs Stock Exchange: Who Decides Which Stocks Get Listed in the Philippines

Supreme Court ruling clarifies the SEC's power to review stock exchange listing decisions and the limits of that authority.

Service of Summons: How to Ensure Valid Jurisdiction in Philippine Courts

Learn how defective substituted service of summons can invalidate court jurisdiction, using the Toyota Cubao v. Guevarra ruling as a guide.

Overriding Commissions After Retirement: Employee Rights in the Philippines

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on whether employees can claim commissions earned before retirement but paid after. Learn the rules.

Conditional vs. Absolute Sale: How Philippine Courts Determine True Property Ownership

Philippine courts look beyond contract labels to determine if a sale is absolute or conditional. Learn the key rules from a landmark Supreme Court case.

Illegal Firearm Possession: Understanding the Nuances of Philippine Law

Learn how Philippine courts decide illegal firearm possession cases, from warrantless searches to penalties under RA 8294.