Legal Insights

Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.

Showing 337360 of 762 articles for abuse of discretion

Demurrage Recovery in the Philippines: How Subrogation Protects Payers

Learn how legal subrogation allows an indent representative to collect demurrage from a defaulting buyer, as ruled by the Supreme Court.

Missed Your Court Date: Understanding Loss of Remedies and Probation in Philippine Law

Learn how missing court deadlines can forfeit legal remedies, and why demurrer grants may not always mean final acquittal.

Quasi-Delict Liability and Negligence in Vehicular Accidents: Insights from G.R. No. 279772

Supreme Court affirms quasi-delict liability for negligent driving, clarifying rules on overtaking, right of way, and vicarious liability of employers.

Final Judgments Are Immutable: Limits of Legal Review in Labor Cases

A final judgment cannot be reopened. Learn how the Supreme Court applied the immutability doctrine in a labor dispute.

Double Jeopardy in Philippine Courts: When a Case Dismissal Is Not Final

Explaining the Supreme Court's ruling in Cerezo v. People on double jeopardy, valid case dismissals, and when courts may reopen criminal cases.

Upholding Court Efficiency: Judge Fined for Delays and Inefficiency in Bareng v. Daguna

A judge was fined P15,000 for gross inefficiency and undue delay in rendering orders and transmitting records. Learn the lessons from this administrative case.

Probable Cause in Graft Cases: SC Upholds Ombudsman's Discretion

The Supreme Court affirms the Ombudsman's broad discretion in determining probable cause for graft charges under R.A. 3019.

Courts Cannot Second-Guess Executive Road Project Choices: Torrecampo vs MWSS

Supreme Court clarifies courts cannot enjoin government infrastructure projects based on policy disagreements, only on grave abuse of discretion.

Grave Misconduct vs Conduct Prejudicial: Understanding Employee Discipline in the Philippines

A look at how Philippine jurisprudence distinguishes grave misconduct from conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service.

Delayed Payment Claims and COA Audit Powers: The Lotrim Construction Ruling

The Supreme Court affirms COA's broad audit powers and the strict application of procedural rules in government contract disputes.

Substantial Evidence in Administrative Cases: Why Photocopies and Hearsay Don't Suffice

Learn how Philippine courts treat photocopies and hearsay in administrative cases, and why substantial evidence remains the standard.

Certiorari and Evidence: Court of Appeals Can Receive New Proof in Special Civil Actions

When may the Court of Appeals admit new evidence in a certiorari case? The Supreme Court clarifies in this foreclosure dispute.

Party-List Registration and Religious Affiliation: COMELEC's Jurisdiction Explained

When can COMELEC cancel a party-list's registration for being a religious front, and when does the HRET take over? The Supreme Court clarifies.

Mortgage Obligations and Appeal Rights in Real Estate Disputes

The Supreme Court rules on mortgage obligations, appeal periods, and writs of execution in a dispute between borrowers and PNB.

Judicial Propriety and Impartiality: Lessons from a Family Court Judge’s Administrative Case

A Supreme Court ruling reminds judges to avoid impropriety, intemperate language, and bias in the discharge of judicial duties.

Overpricing and Accountability: The COA's Role in Ensuring Prudent Government Spending

How the Commission on Audit ensures prudent government spending, and what the Supreme Court says about overpricing and public accountability.

Evidence Rules in Philippine Administrative Cases: The Atienza Case Explained

Administrative bodies in the Philippines follow relaxed evidence rules. Learn what Atienza v. Board of Medicine means for professionals facing administrative scrutiny.

Conviction for a Different Crime: When Courts Can Convict You of an Uncharged Offense

Philippine Supreme Court explains when a conviction for an offense not charged in the Information is valid under the Rules of Court.

Redirect Examination Waiver and Court Discretion: Soriano v. Mendoza-Arcega

When a trial court may deem redirect examination waived due to a party's delay, and why appellate courts will uphold that discretion.

Right to Present Evidence: Examining Forged Signatures in Graft Cases

Sandiganbayan's denial of a graft accused's request to have questioned documents examined by the NBI was grave abuse of discretion.

Navigating Libel Law: Probable Cause and Privileged Communication in the Philippines

A Supreme Court ruling clarifies that probable cause for libel is a prosecutor's call, and privileged communication is a trial defense.

Liquidation Court Jurisdiction Over Claims Against Insolvent Banks in the Philippines

When a bank is placed under liquidation, all claims against it—including annulment and damages suits—must be filed with the liquidation court.

Homeowners Associations vs Non-Members: HLURB Jurisdiction and CMP Benefits

When can a homeowners association evict non-members from CMP land? The Supreme Court clarifies HLURB jurisdiction in Eugenio v. Sta. Monica Riverside Homeowners Association.

Partial Summary Judgments: Why They Are Not Immediately Executable

A partial summary judgment is interlocutory, not final. It cannot be executed while the main case is pending, explains Philippine Business Bank v. Chua.